exhaust mod question
exhaust mod question
Author
Discussion

pinchmeimdreamin

Original Poster:

10,918 posts

249 months

Tuesday 5th May 2009
quotequote all
Was thinking last night with all the discussions about sleeving exhausts and cherry bomb etc, what would be the problem with getting some pipe cutting the silencer box off totally then just replacing with straight through pipe and fabricating a bracket to the existing mounts ?

scotty_d

6,795 posts

225 months

Tuesday 5th May 2009
quotequote all
It would be VERY LOUD biggrin as mine still has cats in place and is sleeved and is LOUD. depends what you want from it.

Barkychoc

7,848 posts

235 months

Tuesday 5th May 2009
quotequote all
Would the MOT tester also be more likely to fail it as it has no silencer?

I think you can get away with a silencer with a pipe welded inside if the MOT tester is sympathetic to the noise, but a straight through pipe is a bit blatantly made to be effin loud isn't it?

slideways

4,101 posts

252 months

Tuesday 5th May 2009
quotequote all
it would sound like a diesel tractor

debaron

878 posts

228 months

Tuesday 5th May 2009
quotequote all

I went through this same exact same thought process myself. After listening to clips on the net and gathering other opinion from PH threads, I decided that the straight through was too 'tractorey' and just a bit 'rough'. I went for this:

http://www.pistonheads.com/gassing/topic.asp?h=0&a...

Great thread and if anyone is looking for an exhaust conversion that gives good volume/tone versus cost it's ideal.

Also - I believe that putting the 'cherry bombs' inside the silencer helps with the 'affixing to the car' problem. You'd need to fabricate a load of new brackets etc if you get rid of the silencer box.


HTH


Ryan

daz the plumber

14,997 posts

262 months

Tuesday 5th May 2009
quotequote all
just noticed you live in nottingham .ive just had a real professional job done at smarts cars in lenton ,the guys name is andy he does them on saturdays .he drops the exhaust, removes the silencer box and fabricates from sctatch two silencers , similar to cherry bombs .he fabs up new brackets etc , looks like the act sports exhaust .you can drop it off in the morning and drive away early afternoon .its not as loud as the straight through set up but very raspy and gets better with time .if you want to have a listen to mine feel free to contact me as im in nottingham .the guy builds a car similar to the atom so he is a top class welder .thanks .i would say its similar to this
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=inEGGozMiXs&fea...

pinchmeimdreamin

Original Poster:

10,918 posts

249 months

Tuesday 5th May 2009
quotequote all
debaron said:
I went through this same exact same thought process myself. After listening to clips on the net and gathering other opinion from PH threads, I decided that the straight through was too 'tractorey' and just a bit 'rough'. I went for this:

http://www.pistonheads.com/gassing/topic.asp?h=0&a...

Great thread and if anyone is looking for an exhaust conversion that gives good volume/tone versus cost it's ideal.

Also - I believe that putting the 'cherry bombs' inside the silencer helps with the 'affixing to the car' problem. You'd need to fabricate a load of new brackets etc if you get rid of the silencer box.


HTH


Ryan
I have looked at that very thread a few times I must admit if only i could weld laugh

And i realy dont know any garages In the mansfield area who would be capable of doing it to my satisfaction, So will proabably have to wait until i sell one of mu cars before the OH allows me to spend any more money on my "weekend car"argue

Evo

3,462 posts

285 months

Tuesday 5th May 2009
quotequote all
I will speak from experience as i have had both done on the two Chims i have owned. The first Chimaera had a Fernhurst sports exhaust which involves cutting out the perforated pipes and welding in new solid pipes (not cherry bombs), then replacing the wadding and closing the box back up. Result yes a little bit tractory at idle but bloody excellent sound with lots of pops and bangs on overrun. By cutting out the back box altogether and just welding in two pipes this may be louder still and heres what you have to consider as i have done.

1. Remove the rear box and if the rozzers inspect your car they may ask questions. Unlikely i know.
2. If you ever fancy removing the precats your car maywell be too loud for you, see other posts on this.

My current car has had the David Batty sports exhaust which sleeves the perforated pipes and whilst not quite as loud as the first (perforated pipes replaced) it's still pretty loud and pops and bangs.

I'm about to take out the precats out which will increase the volume further and should be more bearable with the sleeved option rather than the full replacement.

Choice is yours but if you intend on keeping the precats in go for the full perforated pipe replacement or better still have two cherry bombs welding in instead of just straight pipes as this would sound awesome, just dont get rid of the back box completely as you may find this too much and create legal issues.

HTH
Jeremy.

Blown2CV

31,662 posts

234 months

Saturday 9th May 2009
quotequote all
Chim 500 straight-throughs with new steel pipes and pre-cats out. It sounds fantastic on the move but yes sometimes I do think canal barge at idle. I wonder what a decat performance Y-piece would sound like on mine?

rolling_thunder

152 posts

223 months

Monday 11th May 2009
quotequote all
The nice Mr Batty has just completed my exhaust and i must say that i very much like what he has done. It is sleeved (solid pipe enclosing perforated pipe) and all wadding replaced.

Makes a beautifull low burble on tickover with a hint of a NASCAR sound and it is not too loud on motorways. For me this is perfect - huge grin on my face and now so has half the office as well.

Awsome, many thanks to Dave Batty for this. I heartily recommend his work.

Cheers

RT

jbarker

40 posts

279 months

Monday 11th May 2009
quotequote all
I glad Mr Batty sorted you car, can't recommend him enough, a very honest chap.

Now get the precats out smile