Unexpected rear seat passenger
Unexpected rear seat passenger
Author
Discussion

Busdriver

Original Poster:

12 posts

195 months

Saturday 7th August 2010
quotequote all
Hello all,

So driving to work today and next thing I know, following a loud bang, im pointing skywards with the back end scraping along the floor. After coming to a hasty stop I look behind me to find I have a new passenger in the form of a rear spring which has punched a hole through the shell and is now inside the car with me !

The shock was fitted around 4-5 months ago and is still therefore under warrenty. Its predessor (the same type) was replaced after 2 months of being fitted as it also failed (less spectacularly).

Question: Now I have a gaping hole in my rear shelf and potentially a whole host of other damage (tires? paintwork? carpets? suspension parts? - yet to be assessed) who's responsible for the bill?

The work was carried out by a reputable TVR specialist and the car has been only used under normal driving conditions. My immediate reaction is the shock manufacturer? The mechanics are out of pocket as they've already fitted it twice and now they have more work ahead all under warrenty and Im out of pocket as I have to find alternative travel arrangements again whilst its sorted, plus the prospect of another rather hefty bill!

Bearing in mind its the second time within 6 months one of they're shocks has failed I can only assume a faulty batch hence i've been stung twice! I believe the first was due to a fracture of either the piston rod or casting that sits on the end keeping the spring compressed.

Any experience, wisdom or thoughts to share regarding these situations would be appreciated.

Edited by Busdriver on Saturday 7th August 23:28


Edited by Busdriver on Saturday 7th August 23:28


Edited by Busdriver on Saturday 7th August 23:29

bobfather

11,197 posts

286 months

Saturday 7th August 2010
quotequote all
For the suspension to break through like that I'd say the spring and damper are probably OK and not to blame for this. It sounds to me as though your top mount has separated from the chassis. If you could post some photos we may be able to make sense of this

Colin L

1,243 posts

298 months

Saturday 7th August 2010
quotequote all
Sorry to hear of your trouble. What make was the shock?
Did both incidents happen with the same brand-name shocks.

If it was then you should be able to prove its there faulty parts thus they should pay something if not all the cost this time.

Colin l

Busdriver

Original Poster:

12 posts

195 months

Saturday 7th August 2010
quotequote all
wow, quick replies! thanks chaps,

The shock was the same name brand type twice. Im afraid no photos as i had to leave the car is in the hands of the RAC and dash to work, but the spring alone, uncompressed without mounting point joined me in the car. Im 99.9% sure it was a failure of the shock. I can only assume the end cap is still attached to the top mount (this is indeed where the previous shock failed and the mechanic said he was suprised the spring hadnt fallen clean out last time.)

Edited by Busdriver on Saturday 7th August 23:41


Edited by Busdriver on Saturday 7th August 23:51

Busdriver

Original Poster:

12 posts

195 months

Saturday 7th August 2010
quotequote all
....at a quick glance the piston rod itself appears to end abruptly with nothing attached to its end if that makes sense. so i guess the plate that forms the end of it to keep the spring compressed, which also forms a mounting point to the chassis has become detached / fractured at some point (maybe previously), and as ive rounded a bend the torsional stress has popped the spring out which has released into the wheel arch fibre glass into the car. a picture tells a thousand words i know, wish id taken one now!

chimaera1855

334 posts

199 months

Sunday 8th August 2010
quotequote all
sorry to ask but what brand was it????cause will change mine soon...

haircutmike

22,511 posts

235 months

Sunday 8th August 2010
quotequote all
There was the problem with a brand of dampers that was well documented that people found very useful.

In this case, people should know the brand.

They can then check if theirs are the same batch as the o/p's.

This is a very important imho, not naming and shaming as there is a safety issue here...

neal1980

2,585 posts

270 months

Sunday 8th August 2010
quotequote all

Fit Protech, Racing Reds or Nitrons and you will be safe in my bet smile

GinG15

501 posts

202 months

Sunday 8th August 2010
quotequote all
so maybe the shocks came from GAZ?

http://www.pistonheads.com/gassing/topic.asp?h=0&a...


anyway...if the same type of shocks fail in 6months...i would say there is something wrong with the geometry of the fixings points which transfer too much load onto the shock?
but this should have been recognized already during fitting!!

is your chassis mabye not ok...or did the car had an accidant in the past?

Busdriver

Original Poster:

12 posts

195 months

Sunday 8th August 2010
quotequote all
Chassis and mounting points were given a clean bill of health after the last one failed and the cars never been in an accident.

Its a shock thats been fitted many times to TVR's and until my experience the TVR specialist had never had an issue with one failing.

I can only assume at this point ive been stung buy getting 2 shocks form the same batch.I wont name the make as i couldnt provide enough info regarding batch numbers etc for it to be of any use, and i havent had the mechanic state categorically that it is to blame, once i have i shall spread the word.

The question I really need answering is: who's responsible for the bill (assuming the shock is to blame) does a 'Warrenty' cover the damage to the item itself or associated damage aswell?

Cheers for all your thoughts so far!

Edited by Busdriver on Sunday 8th August 12:01

neal1980

2,585 posts

270 months

Sunday 8th August 2010
quotequote all

I wouldnt want that brand IMO. You were lucky this time but it could of been fatal and to happen twice!

I looked around and put my money in to Protech - the only manufacture to offer 3 years on shocks! That says alot in my book smile

Be interesting to see where you stand regarding the damage to your P&J now.


Busdriver

Original Poster:

12 posts

195 months

Sunday 8th August 2010
quotequote all
Thankfully it happened at low speed but as you said, it could of ended very differently! the spring was only a few inches from my spine! Oh well wont be fitting ***'s again.

SMB

1,523 posts

297 months

Sunday 8th August 2010
quotequote all
Busdriver said:
Thankfully it happened at low speed but as you said, it could of ended very differently! the spring was only a few inches from my spine! Oh well wont be fitting ***'s again.
This story reminded me of this
http://www.pistonheads.com/gassing/topic.asp?t=696...

BliarOut

72,863 posts

270 months

Sunday 8th August 2010
quotequote all
I would suggest this falls outside naming and shaming as it's a clear failure and other purchasers should be given the opportunity to check theirs!

Tyre_Tread

10,697 posts

247 months

Monday 9th August 2010
quotequote all
You need to look to whoever supplied the shocks to you if the damage was caused by component failure.

If the garage supplied them then its the garage's responsibility.

If the workmanship was at fault look to the garage.

So, unless you bought the shocks and gave them to the garage to fit, its the garage.

Busdriver

Original Poster:

12 posts

195 months

Monday 9th August 2010
quotequote all
Yep that fits in nicely with my way of thinking, and then its upto them to recover their costs from the manufacturer / their supplier.

For the time being it would be irresponsible for me to speculate / reveal the make&model until I have had the definitive answer from the mechanics as to the cause, but once i have that and have agreed whom is responsible I shall of course let you all know such that you can check yours if needs be!

Tyre_Tread

10,697 posts

247 months

Monday 9th August 2010
quotequote all
Busdriver said:
Yep that fits in nicely with my way of thinking, and then its upto them to recover their costs from the manufacturer / their supplier.

For the time being it would be irresponsible for me to speculate / reveal the make&model until I have had the definitive answer from the mechanics as to the cause, but once i have that and have agreed whom is responsible I shall of course let you all know such that you can check yours if needs be!
Of course you won't be relying on the mechanics who fitted them to diagnose the cause of the failure will you? It would be a bit like asking the wolf to tell you who killed the lamb.

Busdriver

Original Poster:

12 posts

195 months

Monday 9th August 2010
quotequote all
A fair comment......Well the car has to go to them for a shot of the work being done under warrenty. I've been using these guys for a good while now and I know that they are explicitly trust worth and honest, so im not too worried about that.....maybe more like asking the farmer who guards the lambs, analogies never where my strong point!

AMsquared

39 posts

201 months

Monday 9th August 2010
quotequote all
My advice would try not to be to hasty looking to apportion blame but try and enter a proactive dialogue with component supplier and installer (assuming thy are two different entities). The key aspect for the supplier is obviously safety and so you should discuss this aspect with them in order to prevent any further incidents. The associated damage caused could be considered consequential loss which would not normally be covered by a components supplier or manufacturer (in fact its normally a limited liability to the value of the original goods). As far as the installer goes then faulty workmnaship would be their responsibiity but defects in proprietary goods purchased for the task would be outside their control and again consequential losses would be specifically excluded. Check your paperwork, particularly conditions of sale (normally on reverse of invoices, quotes, websites etc - or you can request them)and avoid suggesting responsiblity for repairs but be prepared for some lengthy communication. I would try and set up a face to face meeting with component rep and installer in the first instance to ensure both are made aware of the seriousness of such a failure and give them an opportunity to recommend a solution without accepting legal responsibility (this always scares companies into doing nothing). As you say a few degrees different and you could be looking forward to a totally different kind of wheels. Good luck. Doing my shocks in the winter so will keep looking at the thread.

SMB

1,523 posts

297 months

Wednesday 11th August 2010
quotequote all
Any update on this, I guess a few of us might be concerned if there is a safety issue here....