Engine hesitation... Can I get some suggestions please?!
Engine hesitation... Can I get some suggestions please?!
Author
Discussion

450Nick

Original Poster:

4,027 posts

243 months

Thursday 12th August 2010
quotequote all
Hi Guys,

I've noticed over the last week or two that my Chim is developing some sort of hesitation on the throttle. I can induce this problem the most when I jab the throttle from low revs. Instead of picking up as usual, it seems to wait for half a second, cough, and then shoot into life and off it goes.

Quite annoying really as its making the car a bit jerky. My car's not very standard though so the diagnosis might be more difficult than usual... I'm running Emerald ECU, aftermarket idle valve, supercharger, uprated fuel pump, injectors etc. On the AFR gauge, just as the hesistation happens it shoots lean for a fraction of a second and then picks up as normal which led me to think that it might be the transient fuelling. The thing is though that it was working fine before and its now doing it on all three maps I have (closed loop/open loop/closed loop no fuel cut).

So if its not the ECU, what might it be? Air leak? Fuel pressure problem? Ignition issue?

Any suggestions would be much appreciated so I can have a good look at it at the weekend and fix the bugger!

slideways

4,101 posts

252 months

Thursday 12th August 2010
quotequote all
450Nick said:
Hi Guys,

I've noticed over the last week or two that my Chim is developing some sort of hesitation on the throttle. I can induce this problem the most when I jab the throttle from low revs. Instead of picking up as usual, it seems to wait for half a second, cough, and then shoot into life and off it goes.

Quite annoying really as its making the car a bit jerky. My car's not very standard though so the diagnosis might be more difficult than usual... I'm running Emerald ECU, aftermarket idle valve, supercharger, uprated fuel pump, injectors etc. On the AFR gauge, just as the hesistation happens it shoots lean for a fraction of a second and then picks up as normal which led me to think that it might be the transient fuelling. The thing is though that it was working fine before and its now doing it on all three maps I have (closed loop/open loop/closed loop no fuel cut).

So if its not the ECU, what might it be? Air leak? Fuel pressure problem? Ignition issue?

Any suggestions would be much appreciated so I can have a good look at it at the weekend and fix the bugger!
Nick have you checked the TPS?
do you have a MAP sensor?
And lambdas check those too!



Edited by slideways on Thursday 12th August 21:29

taylormj4

1,635 posts

297 months

Thursday 12th August 2010
quotequote all
Mine does this too and its a standard 450. Notice it most when have been on overrun up to a junction and then open the throttle again. Short delay then a sharp acceleration, seems its not possible to gently accelerate away if the throttle has been closed for some time. If I were running carbs I'd suspect the carburettor fuel pump thing that gives the instant enrichment on acceleration.

I reckon the TPS diagnosis could be right or at least worth a check.

Matt


spend

12,581 posts

282 months

Friday 13th August 2010
quotequote all
Reduce the acceleration enrichment and see if it improves?

450Nick

Original Poster:

4,027 posts

243 months

Friday 13th August 2010
quotequote all
Hmm well I switched back to the original map (open loop) that the car was originally mapped on which was pretty light on accel enrichment and that doesn't seem to have much effect. From looking at the AFR gauge though, it looks more like there is a lack of fuel or too much air for a split second before the engine does anything so if anything I'd say it was not enough accel enrichment? As I said, it worked before though, and nothings changed, and the car still drives fine when not jabbing the throttle...

The TPS is a good suggestion, I'll check the calibration on this, though I looked at it not very long ago and it was spot on so I'm not holding up much hope. My bet at the moment is an air leak somewhere!

CHGRIFF

326 posts

283 months

Friday 13th August 2010
quotequote all
Hi Nick, check the pressure relief valve has not stuck open.

v8 racing

2,064 posts

282 months

Friday 13th August 2010
quotequote all
Nick it may be worth looking at vacum pipe from the fuel pressure regulator, when i map cars i barely need to run any fuel enrichment using the vacum, if this pipe has a split or has fallen off this will definetly cause this issue.

chimaera1855

334 posts

199 months

Friday 13th August 2010
quotequote all
just wanted to ask u,how are those sc kit????cause still waiting for mine.i just hope that it ll give me the extra go go that i am looking for.i know someone will tell me to get a 5 litres but here we dont have.plus someone told me that an sc400 is faster than a 500.so ur opinion is more than welcome.

450Nick

Original Poster:

4,027 posts

243 months

Friday 13th August 2010
quotequote all
CHGRIFF said:
Hi Nick, check the pressure relief valve has not stuck open.
Thanks Colin, will do! When I get a chance I will also change that power steering pipe and send the old one back to you - just been too busy lately!

v8 racing said:
Nick it may be worth looking at vacum pipe from the fuel pressure regulator, when i map cars i barely need to run any fuel enrichment using the vacum, if this pipe has a split or has fallen off this will definetly cause this issue.
Thanks Rob, that sounds like a very good shout there, I'll check it out...

chimaera1855 said:
just wanted to ask u,how are those sc kit????cause still waiting for mine.i just hope that it ll give me the extra go go that i am looking for.i know someone will tell me to get a 5 litres but here we dont have.plus someone told me that an sc400 is faster than a 500.so ur opinion is more than welcome.
Its a f**king awesome bit of kit. Best thing I've done with the car without a doubt but it must be part of a package. Combined with a decent ECU, brakes and suspension it feels like a completely different car to any other Chim/Griff I've driven - Epic muscle, fantastic road holding, and extremely predictable and easy to drive. Its a pussycat around town and even my girlfriend is happy driving it in high heels with no problems, yet it will destroy just about any other TVR on track and give you the biggest kick of adrenaline when you want it - cracking car!

blitzracing

6,422 posts

251 months

Friday 13th August 2010
quotequote all
Jsut a thought on the "lean" bit- The lambda probes cant tell if its lean or unburnt fuel, both look the same in terms of Oxygen content in the exhaust, so a misfire will give the same reading.

450Nick

Original Poster:

4,027 posts

243 months

Friday 13th August 2010
quotequote all
So it could be a slight missfire then? It doesn't sound like its missfiring but its possible. My ignition system is relatively simple being just coil packs -> HTs -> Extenders -> Plugs. Could this be caused by plugs or extenders on the way out? I'm sure I when I've heard them going before though its tended to be a missfire at higer RPM as they arc to the block or manifolds but I admit that my knowledge is limited in this area.

spend

12,581 posts

282 months

Friday 13th August 2010
quotequote all
Try doing exhaust manifold temp checks, that may throw up light on odd ignition probs if you can scan the temps quickly just after it occurs?

ESDavey

713 posts

250 months

Friday 13th August 2010
quotequote all
I had a problem with a duff AFM which made the Griff run like a dog. I think you can run with the AFM disconnected - could be worth trying.

450Nick

Original Poster:

4,027 posts

243 months

Friday 13th August 2010
quotequote all
ESDavey said:
I had a problem with a duff AFM which made the Griff run like a dog. I think you can run with the AFM disconnected - could be worth trying.
Don't have an AFM in my car! Or a MAP sensor, just temps, TPS and wideband lambda smile

Mark Adams

358 posts

291 months

Friday 13th August 2010
quotequote all
Hi Nick - do you really have no MAP sensor???

If not then there are a whole host of possibilities for your hesitation. However you absolutely should be running one with a forced induction engine, and I believe the Emerald can use MAP for metering (although I've never seen one on it).

Throttle angle has absolutely no chance of fuelling correctly, for the simple reason that the pressure across the throttle butterfly is nowhere near constant. There are large pressure pulses behind the throttle butterfly as you move the throttle, due to the fact that the total air output of the supercharger is supposed to be absorbed by the recirculating bypass system at anything less full throttle. This would be OK if the bypass had 100% capacity - but it doesn't.

If your recirculating bypass valve were to stick shut (which they certainly do and could well be your problem), you would get a large pressure build up behind the butterfly at part throttle. This would also mean that for a given throttle movement you'd get a lot more air than you bargained for, against the amount factored into the original map. This would give dreadful hesitation.

I think everybody knows that I regard throttle angle as very much a third class method of metering unless the application forces you to use it. It definitely has no place outside a naturally-aspirated engine, and even then it should at least be used with barometric pressure compensation. At least in a naturally-aspirated environment you know the pressure on one side of the butterfly, and it has a relatively small range.

Wideband Lambda is no substitute for proper configuration, otherwise it is a just a system that is playing constant catchup with the inherent errors. Since there is just one Lambda sensor, you are also very vulnerable to sensor problems since there are no plausability checks or balances.

Although I map many cars that are on throttle angle (usually because they are on throttle bodies), they all need routine re-fettling because the systems cannot cope with normal wear of the engine and throttle linkage, build up of carbon in the combustion chamber, etc. Any forced induction engine should be run on either MAP or MAF (boost less than 1.0 Bar).

Good Luck and I hope it is only something simple such as a plug, coil or lead breaking down, which you would find very quickly on a rolling road with an ignition analyser. However in the longer term you really should think about going on to MAP metering, since you have an ECU that apparently can use it.

I really don't mean to be negative and I hope that's not how it comes across, but I am known for my obsession with detilas and accuraccuracy...



Edited by Mark Adams on Friday 13th August 17:25

450Nick

Original Poster:

4,027 posts

243 months

Friday 13th August 2010
quotequote all
Thanks for the input mark, i've had it mapped by a couple of people now and no one has mentioned that..

I'll certainly look into getting a map sensor in there and see what it does to the car. That said, it runs very smoothly right down to very low loads on throttle angle and has done for over a year so it can't be that bad?!

I hope its something as simple as the recirc valve! When I serviced the car a few weeks ago I had a stiffer spring put in the valve and cleaned/regressed the whole mechanism so it should be working but I'll check!

CHGRIFF

326 posts

283 months

Saturday 14th August 2010
quotequote all
Nick, has the problem only occured sinced you serviced the car? Try the lighter spring you removed in the pressure relief valve to see if that has any influence. Also check your HT lead routing to ensure you have no signal contamination to the ECU between HT leads and engine harness where they might be touching.

Mark Adams

358 posts

291 months

Saturday 14th August 2010
quotequote all
Out of interest Nick, why did you change the spring anyway?

Since the valve is operated by plenum pressure, it should only close when the pressure in the plenum approaches atmospheric. If it closes too soon there is nowhere for the pressure produced by the supercharger to go. This loads the supercharger unnecessarily, and hence robs power from your engine. Even worse the power absorbed will produce an increase in the supercharger discharge temperature, which increases the likelihood of detonation (although your Intake Air Temperature sensor should take care of that) and again will rob you of power. It's a lose-lose situation!

Increasing the spring pressure won't produce any increase in boost for a supercharged motor.

Sadly it looks like you have been given bad advice regarding the absence of a MAP sensor, although this sort of thing is quite commonplace in the tuning industry. I've read and studied hundreds of reference works and proceedings of conferences on the subject of engine management, and examined lots of OEM software (including the supercharged Range Rover - 76,000 maps and variables). You always get the same answers, because it is wrapped in the Laws of Physics and Chemistry. Diligent study is necessary to answer the tough questions.

It will be a bit of a nuisance for you to convert, since you will need to re-map again after re-selecting the load breakpoints. However it will be worth it, and should produce much more consistent results. Frankly I'm surprised that it runs as well as you say it does (since I've never seen it), although at low revs the supercharger produces almost no boost so the original map will suit it more.

Hope that helps! smile


Edited by Mark Adams on Saturday 14th August 16:44

450Nick

Original Poster:

4,027 posts

243 months

Tuesday 17th August 2010
quotequote all
Mark Adams said:
Out of interest Nick, why did you change the spring anyway?

Since the valve is operated by plenum pressure, it should only close when the pressure in the plenum approaches atmospheric. If it closes too soon there is nowhere for the pressure produced by the supercharger to go. This loads the supercharger unnecessarily, and hence robs power from your engine. Even worse the power absorbed will produce an increase in the supercharger discharge temperature, which increases the likelihood of detonation (although your Intake Air Temperature sensor should take care of that) and again will rob you of power. It's a lose-lose situation!

Increasing the spring pressure won't produce any increase in boost for a supercharged motor.

Sadly it looks like you have been given bad advice regarding the absence of a MAP sensor, although this sort of thing is quite commonplace in the tuning industry. I've read and studied hundreds of reference works and proceedings of conferences on the subject of engine management, and examined lots of OEM software (including the supercharged Range Rover - 76,000 maps and variables). You always get the same answers, because it is wrapped in the Laws of Physics and Chemistry. Diligent study is necessary to answer the tough questions.

It will be a bit of a nuisance for you to convert, since you will need to re-map again after re-selecting the load breakpoints. However it will be worth it, and should produce much more consistent results. Frankly I'm surprised that it runs as well as you say it does (since I've never seen it), although at low revs the supercharger produces almost no boost so the original map will suit it more.

Hope that helps! smile


Edited by Mark Adams on Saturday 14th August 16:44
I actually only changed the spring on the recirc as the guys from SC-Power offered me one as they said I had an older lighter spring. Maybe I'll have a chat and ask what the difference was about. It sounds like I did receive some bad advice re the map sensor. I will look at getting one installed and get the car remapped at some point. Out of interest, what do you charge for a mapping session? I'm just down the road from Austec so would probably get it on the rollers there for convenience.

From what you've said though, I'm also surprised how well it runs. Its far smoother than on the original ECU and will crawl in 5th with virtually no throttle and pull away cleanly. The shunting is also greatly reduced over a standard car (still there a bit though I must admit). On boost it feels great too, and glancing at the AFR gauge I don't see any horror stories but I haven't been through and data plots etc..

Anyway back to the problem!

I had a quick look at it over the weekend and found that Rob, you were quite correct... The vacuum pipe from the pressure reg had ripped all the way through! It looked like it had torn over time, hence why the symptoms had got worse over time I guess..!

I took the recirc valve off as well and that appeared to be working perfectly. But to test it, I ran the car with the valve in place, but with the recirc feed to the second plenum (pre-charger) removed so I could feel the air dumped by the valve. I was pretty surprised just how much was recirculating - Under idle, it was like a hairdryer, and under load or when I revved it, it was enough to push my hand away. So it seems that there's a hell of a lot of air just going around in circles, yet the valve did take a reasonable amound of force from my thumb to open. Does this sound about right? It seems to run ok but I'm just interested!

Edited by 450Nick on Tuesday 17th August 14:34

CHGRIFF

326 posts

283 months

Tuesday 17th August 2010
quotequote all
Hi Nick, we had one early sc400 where the valve stayed open as the spring pressure was too light. Changing the spring with increased rate resolved this problem, hence my suggestion if yoy had the lighter spring. Drove my car recently with the recirc tube removed and could beleive the air noise, quite deafening and not a nice sound. If the spring rate is too high, the valve with not open under under vacuum causing the air to return back along the inlet and through the supercharger turbine slowing it down. The affect of this apart from adverse loads on the charger, is reduced throttle response as you can imagine. Anyway hopefully replacing the vacuum tube has resolved your problem. Never realised you did not have a map sensor fitted.