Nearly did something very very stupid
Nearly did something very very stupid
Author
Discussion

rbryant

Original Poster:

318 posts

272 months

Tuesday 17th August 2010
quotequote all
OK guys, those of you with more mechanical knowledge than me, I want you to explain to me why my engine, gearbox and drive shafts are still intact.

Here is what happened ....

... basically, after 6 years of Chimaera ownership, blasting up a motorway slip road yesterday, I changed up from 5th to 6th at around a ton.... !! had a massive Oh st moment and realised what I had done, never let the clutch up and took it out of reverse gear as quickly as I could.

I am convinced it went into gear, but no crunch, no untoward noises at all, at all is absolutely fine.

So - what would have happened if I had let the clutch up? Engine and gearbox spread out all over the A1 ? Was I really half a second from disaster ? I spent the rest of the journey thinking about it and find it hard to believe that the gear actually went in but it did. In my defence, my other car has a 6 speed box .... and the TVR has no reverse lock-out as you all know

CraigW

12,248 posts

313 months

Tuesday 17th August 2010
quotequote all
i'd imagine you'd have been spread all over the road, im no expert but i'd imagine the effect wouldnt have been dissimilar to jamming on the handbrake

Alexdaredevilz

5,697 posts

210 months

Tuesday 17th August 2010
quotequote all
Im 99% sure the box wont let you unless you have arms the size of tree trunks

If it did go in, bad things would of happened

miniman

30,239 posts

293 months

Tuesday 17th August 2010
quotequote all
I've often wondered about this. Seems to me that there's a Top Gear / Mythbusters style experiment to be done. Although ideally not with a Chim...

Mark_S_24

405 posts

207 months

Tuesday 17th August 2010
quotequote all
Mythbusters did try it on both manual & Auto boxes.
and they were unable to get either to go into reverse while in forward motion.
The manual just ground, I assume the cogs would be going in opposite directions?

Mark S

4Lmike

1,910 posts

201 months

Tuesday 17th August 2010
quotequote all
doing 100mph up a slip road and still changing up!? i was always taught to slow down when coming off the motorway.

Edited by 4Lmike on Tuesday 17th August 16:03

TVR Beaver

2,874 posts

211 months

Tuesday 17th August 2010
quotequote all
You can't do it.. things are going the wrong way.. never in 1 million years would you get it in reverse... you may have got it into 3rd... but even that could give you a bit of a shock...
Years ago I had a Jap motorbike and a Triumph Boni (old type).. the gear change on these were on opposite sides of the engine and in opposite dirrection to go up / down the box... A couple of times whilst thrashing away from the lights I went the wrong way on the Kawa 1000 and slid half way up the tank as a result!! laugh

simonej

5,513 posts

211 months

Tuesday 17th August 2010
quotequote all
You sure you didn't slot it back into fourth? I remember following my Mum who was driving my brother's Fiesta for the first time. Driving down a dual carriageway at 40mph and suddenly the reverse lights came on! So you're not the first person to look for 6th gear in a 5 speed 'box! biggrin

(Apparently it made a loud grinding noise!)

rbryant

Original Poster:

318 posts

272 months

Tuesday 17th August 2010
quotequote all
Was rejoining the motorway after a fill-up. Can't have actually gone into reverse then can it ?

By the way, also managed to get 300+ miles and 26.6 mpg from that tankful - a V8 developments rebuilt 4.6 with a Mark Adams chip and genuine 300 bhp. Not the point of TVR ownership I know, but a new personal best mpg. :-)

TVR Beaver

2,874 posts

211 months

Tuesday 17th August 2010
quotequote all
Thats good MPG... when MA did my car he didn't cure the problem we set out to cure (not his fault).. but I did notice a big gain in MPG.. not sure but on a good run, bet mine is 25 mpg at least...driving

ButtonIt

385 posts

209 months

Wednesday 18th August 2010
quotequote all
I've watched the result of an auto Aston DB7 being driven with beans and the driver "changing gear". The result was the gearbox making it's way into PARK and the rear end locking out, multiple spins and off the side of the road into a lampost and hedge (luckily it was only a clip on the post and a nice soft hedge). From behind I saw a flash of reverse lights and then several flashes of headlights as the car spun. Luckily no major injuries, just a very bruised man with a very bruised ego and a very very bruised DB7.


RumbleBee

333 posts

237 months

Wednesday 18th August 2010
quotequote all
I recently saw a colleage go from 5th to 2nd at around 60mph in his Type R. End result was a massive cloud of smoke and engine cut out. Most of the valves are bent a right angles at the moment. Other damage may present itself.

Should have got a proper car.

blueg33

47,025 posts

255 months

Wednesday 18th August 2010
quotequote all
4Lmike said:
doing 100mph up a slip road and still changing up!? i was always taught to slow down when coming off the motorway.

Edited by 4Lmike on Tuesday 17th August 16:03
You mean you have never joined a motorway via an uphill slip road? You cant do much motorway driving

Bluebottle

3,498 posts

271 months

Wednesday 18th August 2010
quotequote all
simonej said:
You sure you didn't slot it back into fourth? I remember following my Mum who was driving my brother's Fiesta for the first time. Driving down a dual carriageway at 40mph and suddenly the reverse lights came on! So you're not the first person to look for 6th gear in a 5 speed 'box! biggrin

(Apparently it made a loud grinding noise!)
I followed a Porsche out of Le Source hairpin at Spa a couple of yrs back, and he selected 1st instead of 3rd...I nearly spin of on his oil as he grenaded his enginefrown
As others have said things are spinning in different directions so will not engage until the final drive shaft is stationary, all that would happen is a very noisy deburring of your gears if you held it against the gate for and period.

nikman

878 posts

236 months

Wednesday 18th August 2010
quotequote all
CraigW said:
i'd imagine you'd have been spread all over the road, im no expert but i'd imagine the effect wouldnt have been dissimilar to jamming on the handbrake
nono I assure you it'd be VERY diferent to that!! laugh

TVR Beaver

2,874 posts

211 months

Wednesday 18th August 2010
quotequote all
nikman said:
CraigW said:
i'd imagine you'd have been spread all over the road, im no expert but i'd imagine the effect wouldnt have been dissimilar to jamming on the handbrake
nono I assure you it'd be VERY diferent to that!! laugh
INDEED!!.. laughlaughlaugh

dbv8

8,676 posts

251 months

Wednesday 18th August 2010
quotequote all
About 22 years ago (ouch) i had an automatic V8 Rover SD1.
Travelling along at about 35mph i thought i would slip it into neutral (dont know why). I managed to push the gearlever too far and it selected reverse.
The car immediately started wheelspinning backwards!
I guess it was a good thing it was pouring down at the time.

DavidLScott

1,048 posts

255 months

Thursday 19th August 2010
quotequote all
dbv8 said:
About 22 years ago (ouch) i had an automatic V8 Rover SD1.
Travelling along at about 35mph i thought i would slip it into neutral (dont know why). I managed to push the gearlever too far and it selected reverse.
The car immediately started wheelspinning backwards!
I guess it was a good thing it was pouring down at the time.
Similar thing even longer ago than that as I was about 10 at the time.
My friends dad had taken both families out for a day trip in his Vauxhall auto (there would have been 4 adults and 3 kids in it!!)and told us to keep quiet while he concentrated on overtaking the caravan in front.
Two big black lines and a squeal of tyres later we were still behind the caravan.
Handbook said it is impossible to select reverse when moving forward - wrong!!