camshaft or electrical problem???
camshaft or electrical problem???
Author
Discussion

Ozmira

Original Poster:

1,175 posts

220 months

Tuesday 31st August 2010
quotequote all
A couple of months ago I had a problem with the chim, basically when I was in first and ready to pull away there was some hesitation with the engine and then we were off. It would just sort of die then come back to life again. I could stop this from happening by keeping the revs high and not staying in first to long.

The car then went in for a 12k service, i let the mechanic now what the problem was and he let me know it was probably the spark plugs as they were quiet filthy. Anyway after the service everything was sorted. Or so i thought. About three/four months after the service it came back. Same sort of problem, only in first and only when I’m stopped and need to start again.

i let my mechanic know it came back when i had a new radiator put in and after he had the car for a week he explained to me it could be the camshaft is knackered and in need of replacement. The car had done over 100k miles and almost everything I’ve replaced on the car is original.

a friend of mine has suggested it may not be the cam but an electrical issue. as it the problem only happens in low gears at low speeds, due to the increase loads being put thru the computers in the car. I’ve had a second opinion from another garage, let him know the issue, let him know what my mechanic has said, let him know about the possible electric issue rather than cam issue and the second garage answer was also undetermined.

now my question is getting the cam replaced with all the other bits and bobs that go with it will cost me around £1000, is there any way of checking myself if they need replacing. now if i check and they turn out to be fine what sort of electrical problem would/could be causing this stop/start.

any help, any help at all would be great.

spend

12,581 posts

282 months

Tuesday 31st August 2010
quotequote all
Check replace the pipe from the back of the plenum to the fuel reg, and check the fuel reg is working OK.

When opening throttle you suddenly release the vacuum and if the regulator doesn't adjust fast enough there's not enough fuel (decreased rail pressure) - then the silly ECU tries to compensate every which way.. ie twisted knicker algorithms hehe

You can try disconnecting the lambdas to force the ecu to run limp mode and see if the symptoms are improved, which may isolate fueling problems.

blitzracing

6,422 posts

251 months

Tuesday 31st August 2010
quotequote all
None of the symptoms sound directly cam like, thats just a drop in power and the engine does not sound right (uneven).its worth dropping all the plugs out and check the colours. If they are all black its either overfueling, or there is a misfire, as the ECU mistakes this for a lean mixture and puts in more fuel. As for the electrical diagnosis, it has nowt to do with ECU load at all, but you can get a simular fault if the ignition coil starts to fail, as the HT voltage drops below the point it can cleanly ignite the fuel air mix under load. Any half decent garage or mechanic should be able to do an HT voltage check for you.

Ozmira

Original Poster:

1,175 posts

220 months

Tuesday 31st August 2010
quotequote all
there is a slight miss fire and as for the HT voltage check is this something i can check myself.

blitzracing

6,422 posts

251 months

Wednesday 1st September 2010
quotequote all
You can get various cheap HT testers on ebay that will give you an indication of HT Voltages but not a measurement as such, but they are cheap enough to give a go.

http://www.gunson.co.uk/item.aspx?cat=698&item...

http://cgi.ebay.co.uk/LINE-HT-IGNITION-TESTER-/160...

Gunson used to do a better electronic unit with an LED voltage indicators to measure the peak, but Ive not seen them for a while now. HT is funny stuff, you need enough to fire the plug, and enough energy in the coil to keep the arc burning, but if you get very high HT voltages on your leads, something is open circuit, as the HT voltage should only rise until the arc starts at somewhere around 12 -25KV and this voltage varies considerably depending on the engine load and mixture. This is why coil faults can show as a bad misfire as the load goes up, but not at idle.