Megasquirt or Emerald
Discussion
hi guys still waiting for my sc kit to be done.but now i want to change my ECU.i see that u guys in UK use Emerald or Meguaskirt.after seeing the price and the features i have to say that i am a bit impress.but why so cheap here they use Haltec or Microtech etc...so questions how good are the Emerald and Megasquirt.please need ur help tks for all ur comments.cheers
chimaera1855 said:
hi guys still waiting for my sc kit to be done.but now i want to change my ECU.i see that u guys in UK use Emerald or Meguaskirt.after seeing the price and the features i have to say that i am a bit impress.but why so cheap here they use Haltec or Microtech etc...so questions how good are the Emerald and Megasquirt.please need ur help tks for all ur comments.cheers
Hi Denis, you need to talk to Daz the plumber he has Megaskirted!?!to the max.
Me I'm going back to a pair of SUs, maybe this will give me a bit qmore than my pathetic 188 hp

Its not simply the type of box of electronics you fit, but the skill of who maps it for you. The MS system does have the advantage of cost and availablity of support, as lots of tech guys have been fiddling with it in various form for some time to make it do what they want and theres plenty of info on web sites and forums (dont forget the Landrover world out there).
blitzracing said:
Its not simply the type of box of electronics you fit, but the skill of who maps it for you.
Never a truer word said. Whol is going to map it for you? Find out what they prefer and are familiar with. Check out the features, and see if there's anything that stands out about any of the systems you are considering.
I have an Emerald K6, the new model, and was swayed by the switchable maps (operated by a dashboard-mounted switch), idle valve control and "moveable speed sites" meaning that very fine mapping could be achieved in the "shunting" zone - but to be honest, 99% of the time you probably wont be interacting with it.
...unless you are a compulsive map-tweaker

HTH
Dom
domV8 said:
I have an Emerald K6, the new model, and was swayed by the switchable maps (operated by a dashboard-mounted switch), idle valve control and "moveable speed sites" meaning that very fine mapping could be achieved in the "shunting" zone
That sounds a bit like saying I picked a Ford car because it had wheels? I'd have to think very hard which if any ECU's didn't have those features TBH, I'm certainly not racking my brains for that exercise now 
I've held back on replying to this post as I didnt want to jump in with my biased opinion. I have to agree with the replies you have received so far. The one critical item you NEED for a SC setup is a system which has a MAP sensor. (MS happens to have one built in
) Id also go for a wasted spark setup that has some form of intake temperature compensation related to the ignition advance. This is to reduce advance if the intake air gets too hot, helping reduce the likelyhood of detonation. (MS has this too
)
Most have similar options, features, etc, (switchable maps, movable load and rpm sites) some you pay more for, some you pay a realistic price for.
Talk to local tuners if your going to get someone to do it, if you want to do it yourself then look at the software, backup and help thats available for each ECU. To be honest, any good tuner should be able to map most systems, but if they dont want to tune one setup or arent over familiar with one, you may end up with a less driveable car due to that. One wont give you more power than another if you compare the same type of control.
Phil
) Id also go for a wasted spark setup that has some form of intake temperature compensation related to the ignition advance. This is to reduce advance if the intake air gets too hot, helping reduce the likelyhood of detonation. (MS has this too
)Most have similar options, features, etc, (switchable maps, movable load and rpm sites) some you pay more for, some you pay a realistic price for.
Talk to local tuners if your going to get someone to do it, if you want to do it yourself then look at the software, backup and help thats available for each ECU. To be honest, any good tuner should be able to map most systems, but if they dont want to tune one setup or arent over familiar with one, you may end up with a less driveable car due to that. One wont give you more power than another if you compare the same type of control.
Phil
Edited by daxtojeiro on Thursday 9th September 07:05
Phil,
Still looking for a solution for my car, SC400, so this may be relevent to Dennis as well.
Pretty much decided to get the MS fitted, using the PlugNPlay version. I will be going coil packs as well.
I've been searching and reading to try and gen up on the tuning side.
I came across Tuner Studio, which it appears to be able to Map the car for you whilst running on the road (Registered version only).
Is this as good as it sounds?
Cheers,
Simon
Still looking for a solution for my car, SC400, so this may be relevent to Dennis as well.
Pretty much decided to get the MS fitted, using the PlugNPlay version. I will be going coil packs as well.
I've been searching and reading to try and gen up on the tuning side.
I came across Tuner Studio, which it appears to be able to Map the car for you whilst running on the road (Registered version only).
Is this as good as it sounds?
Cheers,
Simon
sgrimshaw said:
Phil,
Still looking for a solution for my car, SC400, so this may be relevent to Dennis as well.
Pretty much decided to get the MS fitted, using the PlugNPlay version. I will be going coil packs as well.
I've been searching and reading to try and gen up on the tuning side.
I came across Tuner Studio, which it appears to be able to Map the car for you whilst running on the road (Registered version only).
Is this as good as it sounds?
Cheers,
Simon
Hi Simon,Still looking for a solution for my car, SC400, so this may be relevent to Dennis as well.
Pretty much decided to get the MS fitted, using the PlugNPlay version. I will be going coil packs as well.
I've been searching and reading to try and gen up on the tuning side.
I came across Tuner Studio, which it appears to be able to Map the car for you whilst running on the road (Registered version only).
Is this as good as it sounds?
Cheers,
Simon
Ive tended to stay away from auto tuning to be honest, as its prone to issues that you can only see by looking at the fueling and you dont get an understanding of what needs to be done. If its used correctly and you study the fuel maps to keep it from creating lumps in the fuel table then it can be very useful. But you may as well datalog and go through them manually if your going to do that.
But, having said that, I have ran the autotune on my car a few times lately and it does a superb job at fine tuning it.
Personally I recommend getting it tuned as close as possible using the normal manual method (which means using Tuner Studio, just that you dont need to register it) then if you want to get it really perfect then do the fine tuning with autotune in Tuner Studio. You MUST use a wideband lambda for this though. If you use the standard TVR lambda then you can only tune for 14.7AFR (cruise economy/efficiency) and to be honest, you dont need the autotune to achieve that, thats easy enough to get manually.
I will be doing a video manual for Tuner Studio and its functions soon, see here:
www.youtube.com/extraefi
cheers,
Phil
Edited by daxtojeiro on Thursday 9th September 12:22
Just my cents worth but the Techedge gets good f/back http://trigger-wheels.com/store/contents/en-uk/d27... as does the Zeitronix http://www.efi-parts.co.uk/index.php?categoryID=87 I am using the Innovate LM2 full kit http://www.grahamgoode.com/innovate/new/inn3806.ht... i chose this as it is a handy OBD scanner which i often use at work for quick read outs and you can record and playback sessions and s
t loads of other stuff i dont use yet,I would recommend it but I get random start up freezes with which is most annoying once it's running it works perfectly but it's also the dearest in this company or was
and you can log session's with the laptop anyways 
t loads of other stuff i dont use yet,I would recommend it but I get random start up freezes with which is most annoying once it's running it works perfectly but it's also the dearest in this company or was
and you can log session's with the laptop anyways 
Edited by Simon says on Thursday 9th September 13:51
sgrimshaw said:
I hope you don't think I'm hijacking your thread Dennis, but I think you will have these same questions ...
With regard to the Wideband Lambda.
The sensor is the cheap bit.
Is it necessary to have a Controller as well?
What does it actually do?
With a wideband? then yes you need a controller With regard to the Wideband Lambda.
The sensor is the cheap bit.
Is it necessary to have a Controller as well?
What does it actually do?
personally I would not map with narrowband it can be done but...........Basically if you want to tune it yourself then you'll need a wideband lambda to do it properly, as these tell you the AFR in the range of 10.8 to 20, which is the range youll need on a petrol car.
Yes you'll need a controller too, cost is around £130 upwards. The controller keeps the sensor at the correct temperature and converts the signal into something that the ECU can work from. Theres a lot to the controllers as they hold the reference values to trim the sensor signal to keep it acurate and they can interface with a laptop so you can adjsut the output range, etc, etc.
If you take it to a tuner to map it then you wont need one, unless you really want one. This could then be used to fine tune the fuel map over a larger range, but I wouldnt recommend having it finetune at wide throttle openings, incase the sensor goes faulty. (they do tend to drift a little with age) This is all adjustable in the MS ECUs.
A narrowband (standard on most cars inc TVR) will only tell you your rich or lean of 14.7 and nothing else, so its pretty useless for tuning, it can be used to fine tune the mixture by the ECU for cruising (economy / efficiency) which is fine if the map has been tuned and you just want a little trim to keep it efficient. This would be how the Lucas works.
I used to sell the LC1 but I had loads of issues with them and the warranty was painful, so now I refuse to sell them, Id recommend techedge too
Phil
Yes you'll need a controller too, cost is around £130 upwards. The controller keeps the sensor at the correct temperature and converts the signal into something that the ECU can work from. Theres a lot to the controllers as they hold the reference values to trim the sensor signal to keep it acurate and they can interface with a laptop so you can adjsut the output range, etc, etc.
If you take it to a tuner to map it then you wont need one, unless you really want one. This could then be used to fine tune the fuel map over a larger range, but I wouldnt recommend having it finetune at wide throttle openings, incase the sensor goes faulty. (they do tend to drift a little with age) This is all adjustable in the MS ECUs.
A narrowband (standard on most cars inc TVR) will only tell you your rich or lean of 14.7 and nothing else, so its pretty useless for tuning, it can be used to fine tune the mixture by the ECU for cruising (economy / efficiency) which is fine if the map has been tuned and you just want a little trim to keep it efficient. This would be how the Lucas works.
I used to sell the LC1 but I had loads of issues with them and the warranty was painful, so now I refuse to sell them, Id recommend techedge too

Phil
Edited by daxtojeiro on Thursday 9th September 15:42
For wideband lambda, I would recommend this one every time: http://www.demon-tweeks.co.uk/Motorsport/Brands/Dy...
Gassing Station | Chimaera | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff






