Running very cool
Running very cool
Author
Discussion

rabowman

Original Poster:

284 posts

219 months

Tuesday 21st September 2010
quotequote all
My 4.5 is running at about 65c on a run. The temp guage seems ok on the basis that
if you let it tick over the fans come on at an indicated 90c.
Although it is great to have a car that does not overheat, this can't be right.
Suggestions (polite) please.

Rob

.Mark

11,104 posts

307 months

Tuesday 21st September 2010
quotequote all
Yes, mine has always been the same, on a run nice and cool. It'se never deviated from how it is in the last 9 years so I've stopped pondering it.

minkybob

341 posts

202 months

Tuesday 21st September 2010
quotequote all
My 450 is exactly the same.
Had a new temp sender last week due to failure and still reads the same.
Cheers

centauro

17 posts

195 months

Tuesday 21st September 2010
quotequote all
My 450 runs at 70c normal running, only goes up to 90c when stuck in traffic.

Cider Andy

1,889 posts

256 months

Tuesday 21st September 2010
quotequote all
Check the 'radiator top hose'. It actually goes from the engine to the swirl pot. On starting the car from cold, it should warm a little bit (as coolant passes through the bypass drilling in the thermostat) then get very hot very quickly as the thermostat opens. If it warms up gradually, the thermostat isn't closing properly.

If it needs replacing buy one from a specialist. The 82°C thermostat should be fine; alternatively fit a 74°C thermostat. But don't buy a standard Range Rover one: they have a narrower aperture.

debaron

878 posts

228 months

Tuesday 21st September 2010
quotequote all

+ 1


Definitely sounds like the thermostat is sticking open.

When you have air moving over the radiator - ie when you are moving, all the coolant is being cooled *all the time* resulting in 65 deg temperature, it's only when you stop (in traffic etc) then the air stops moving over the radiator and the temp slowly rises to 90 deg until the fans cut in or you start moving again.

Exactly the same happened on mine til I changed the stat. Not good for fuel economy I would think as 'cold start' is on up until the coolant hits 70 deg.

A temporary fix/diagnosis can be wedging some cardboard or similar down the front of the radiator to reduce (but not completely cover) the amount of cooling 'area' available. if your gauge then reads a bit higher while moving with less rad area available or as Andy says if your top hose slowly progressively warms up rather than a noticeable jump then chances are you have a stuck stat.

rabowman

Original Poster:

284 posts

219 months

Wednesday 22nd September 2010
quotequote all
Thanks for the repplies and suggestions.
Will get new stat from C.T and re post when fitted.
Rob

Chimpaholic

9,637 posts

210 months

Wednesday 22nd September 2010
quotequote all
This has been discussed before.

You can find all your answers here.

http://www.pistonheads.com/gassing/topic.asp?h=0&a...

Have a read, in summary (and in my opinion) the answer is to swap thermostats as the seasons change.

In the old days it was common to fit summer & winter thermostats.

However in the end I opted for a rad blind in the winter months as its easier than swapping thermostats.

A rad blind can be easily adjusted if we get a freak hot day or I am doing a lot of town driving.

Edited by Chimpaholic on Wednesday 22 September 10:17

Bassfiend

5,530 posts

281 months

Wednesday 22nd September 2010
quotequote all
debaron said:
Definitely sounds like the thermostat is sticking open.
Not necessarily ... there's enough airflow through the engine bay at speed to cool the block directly - the rad and cooling system in this case does very little. So little that my car was fine on runs (would sit at well below 70deg) and I only found out the rad was severely blocked when it overheated in traffic!

Replaced rad, hoses and thermostat back at Christmas and it *STILL* sits at around 60 degrees - gets up to 90 degrees within a minute or so of being in traffic and then cycles the fans in and out as expected - drops back down to below 70 degrees after a few minutes of open road again.

Seems normal from what I see on here. biggrin

Phil

Chimpaholic

9,637 posts

210 months

Wednesday 22nd September 2010
quotequote all
Bassfiend said:
debaron said:
Definitely sounds like the thermostat is sticking open.
Not necessarily ... there's enough airflow through the engine bay at speed to cool the block directly - the rad and cooling system in this case does very little. So little that my car was fine on runs (would sit at well below 70deg) and I only found out the rad was severely blocked when it overheated in traffic!

Replaced rad, hoses and thermostat back at Christmas and it *STILL* sits at around 60 degrees - gets up to 90 degrees within a minute or so of being in traffic and then cycles the fans in and out as expected - drops back down to below 70 degrees after a few minutes of open road again.

Seems normal from what I see on here. biggrin

Phil
Correct!

I changed my thermostat when I first got my Chim to try and solve the problem and it made absolutely no difference.

Both my old and new thermostats work perfectly.

Looking at the file that came with the car the rad was changed a few years ago, this seems to be common on our cars.

I thought perhaps that the rad reconditioner may have added an extra core like I used to specify when I was in the restoration game.

I now think the direct cooling of the block plays a big part like Phil says.

Its my understanding that the Chim/Griff rad is a slightly modified Range Rover item, this may also explain the over cooling.

The Range Rover cooling system and radiator capacity was almost certainly designed to cope with slow speed off road driving and towing conditions.

The thing is big improvements can be made by fitting a rad blind, my one works a treat.

Edited by Chimpaholic on Wednesday 22 September 13:47

dog man

552 posts

233 months

Wednesday 22nd September 2010
quotequote all
Numberplate on the grille might help nudge temp up.

Bassfiend

5,530 posts

281 months

Wednesday 22nd September 2010
quotequote all
dog man said:
Numberplate on the grille might help nudge temp up.
Oh yes - best put mine back on for the MOT... wink

Phil

Cider Andy

1,889 posts

256 months

Wednesday 22nd September 2010
quotequote all
Another thing to consider is the amount of heat dissipated through the heater matrix in cold weather (as it bypasses the thermostat).

Bassfiend

5,530 posts

281 months

Wednesday 22nd September 2010
quotequote all
Chimpaholic said:
I now think the direct cooling of the block plays a big part like Phil says.
Once it's moving I think that *MOST* of the cooling is directly of the block otherwise it wouldn't sit so damn cold - mine sits well below 70 degrees with the thermostat closed. I did take temperature measurements across the blocked rad and at 70mph I was getting a 1 deg drop between inlet and outlet so I reckon that it's safe to conclude that at speed the radiator actually does nothing!

Chimpaholic said:
Its my understanding that the Chim/Griff rad is a slightly modified Range Rover item, this may also explain the over cooling.

The Range Rover cooling system and radiator capacity was almost certainly designed to cope with slow speed off road driving and towing conditions.
I don't think it's over cooled because of the rad in *ANY* way TBH - if it was then when the fans cut in in traffic the temperature would drop much quicker but I reckon my fans still struggle to keep the temperature down.

Phil