Seat Arosa - Any Good?
Author
Discussion

JayT

Original Poster:

10,974 posts

188 months

Monday 17th December 2012
quotequote all
Evening,

I hope you can help with with a possible option for a first car. I would ideally like to know more about the mighty, powerhouse that is the Seat Arosa. I understand that you can get them in either a 1.0l or a 1.4 Sport - which one is the better option? I have yet to test drive either as I am not seriously looking until early 2013 but I was wondering if the 1.4 was actually worth the premium over the standard 1.0 in terms of insurance premiums etc.

I have a mate that has a 2000 VW Polo 1.4 as his first car and it has adequate power for the first few years of motoring and I bet in a lighter, smaller package it would be cooler. Is the engine that is in my mates Polo near enough the same as what is found in the Arosa/Lupo? I bet they are very cheap to keep running, whatever engine but what problems and/or weaknesses will I need to look out for?

I assume the Lupo & Arosa are identical but is there any major aspects of either the Lupo or Seat that would tempt me to pick one over the other? I actually prefer the cosmetic changes of the Seat, but again wondered if there was something that the Lupo offered that the Arosa did not..

A photo to complete the thread: hehe



Sorry if I have confused you, but any input would be appreciated. If I have more questions, I will update the thread. Thanks again. smile

aka_kerrly

12,506 posts

241 months

Tuesday 18th December 2012
quotequote all
If you can insure a 1.4 16v as a first car then go for it, if not a 1.4 60hp is well worth the extra as it barely uses any more fuel than the 1.0 but offers a 3second improvement in 0-60times and more noticeable performance in daily driving.

I haven't owned a Arosa/lupo myself but have had a few mk4 polos with the same 1.0 and 1.4 16v engine in them and they have been incredibly reliable and needed nothing more than servicing.

The only real downside is the size, yes you can fit 4 people in one ( assuming those in the back are good friends!) but the boot is more like a glovebox. You can fold the rear seats down which certainly helps create a pretty usable space but for example a mountain bike needs both wheels to be removed where as you can just fit one in with the front wheel off in a Polo (6n)

edit - more info here - http://www.seatcupra.net/forums/forumdisplay.php?f...

Mighty Flex

925 posts

202 months

Tuesday 18th December 2012
quotequote all
Great cars.

Some getting a bit tired now, but plenty of good ones around , and still cost less than the equivalent Lupo.

My Arosa Sport (first car, parents' before that) has been fantastic - in 11 years and 67000 miles it's needed a power steering pump and a door strap (£15).
Nothing else beyond standard consumables (which it consumes very slowly anyway). There is now a little gearbox/ clutch noise though so this is worth watching out for. I probably should sell it but I may need an economic commuter again soon, and would definitely miss it.

Engines can be smokey/burn lots of oil if they haven't been looked after, but this goes for any small VW motor.

The sport is fun to drive - lively and chuckable - naturally it's not perfect, and understeers a fair bit, but great fun around b roads. I gather the non sport models are a little dull, but I have never tried them. The 1,4 diesel is properly quick especially when remapped.

The boot is indeed tiny - mine rarely had the rear seats up though rear seat space isn't bad.

Makes a slightly different choice, but good, well made small cars.

sorry for the unstructured reply... it is 2am biggrin

Felix


JayT

Original Poster:

10,974 posts

188 months

Tuesday 18th December 2012
quotequote all
Thanks for the replies. I was opting more towards the 1.4 as I think the 1.0 would get tiresome after a while as I try to keep momentum.

Again, thank you for the replies so far and keep them coming! smile

cptsideways

13,896 posts

283 months

Tuesday 18th December 2012
quotequote all
If you can find one & afford one then a the Tdi is best option, they are loads quicker than the petrol variants & gutsy. Also stupidly eco.

Just watch for - window switches, door latches (inner bits)

Dr G

16,007 posts

273 months

Tuesday 18th December 2012
quotequote all
I helped a friend buy a Lupo as her first car a few years ago and drove both 1.0 and 1.4; I initially thought the 1.0 was broken it was so slow. Service history was minimal or non existant on most cars we looked at and virtually all of them had crappy paint/repairs too (the life of a town car!). Ended up buying the first one with reasonable history and original paint which turned out to be the highest mileage one also. Her car had a few annoying niggles (bought at 104, sold 2 years later at 120) including window switches and door latches - it did also need a couple of hoses, bushes and discs but nothing catastrophic and nothing a halfway competent home mechanic couldn't do on the driveway for a pittance. Fun little car to drive, too.

JayT

Original Poster:

10,974 posts

188 months

Tuesday 18th December 2012
quotequote all
So I guess we all agree that the 1.4 is the better option then. smile

I see some Arosa's with single centre ehausts, does that indicate that it is a 1.4 or anything special?! smile

Mighty Flex

925 posts

202 months

Tuesday 18th December 2012
quotequote all
JayT said:
So I guess we all agree that the 1.4 is the better option then. smile

I see some Arosa's with single centre ehausts, does that indicate that it is a 1.4 or anything special?! smile
it's the 1.4 16v 100bhp sport model. or modified. These also come with sport suspension, rear disc brakes and more sporty seats. And maybe some other stuff. This is the one I have (see profile).

JayT

Original Poster:

10,974 posts

188 months

Tuesday 18th December 2012
quotequote all
Mighty Flex said:
JayT said:
So I guess we all agree that the 1.4 is the better option then. smile

I see some Arosa's with single centre ehausts, does that indicate that it is a 1.4 or anything special?! smile
it's the 1.4 16v 100bhp sport model. or modified. These also come with sport suspension, rear disc brakes and more sporty seats. And maybe some other stuff. This is the one I have (see profile).
Thank you, it looks cooler with the single exhaust. I am loving the dirt on your profile, maybe not the colour though. hehe

Thanks again. Food for thought. scratchchin

va1o

16,118 posts

238 months

Tuesday 18th December 2012
quotequote all
I'd agree that 1.4 is the better choice, as always with these do check the cambelt

Also I presume it's the facelift version you'd be going for as per the picture, far nicer than the original Arosa smile

Quite rare cars but not a bad buy and better than the equivent Ford or french car

JayT

Original Poster:

10,974 posts

188 months

Tuesday 18th December 2012
quotequote all
Oops yeah, I would be looking at the face-lifted example (IIRC 2003-05). It seems like a decent car and a hidden gem in 1.4 guise. biggrin

Another photo: biggrin


Mighty Flex

925 posts

202 months

Tuesday 18th December 2012
quotequote all
Anyway, head over to clublupo - lots of good stuff there about what to look out for - my ideal Arosa would, err... be a Lupo GTI. ignoring that, if you can afford a sport, it's the way forward for econmical, lively fun.

The facelift in 2001 mainly cosmetic. I believe there might be a little more soundproofing, but its basically the same car.

Edited by Mighty Flex on Tuesday 18th December 20:07

JayT

Original Poster:

10,974 posts

188 months

Tuesday 18th December 2012
quotequote all
I will give that website a good look later - I just prefer the new nose that came with the facelift, and I assumed it was just a cosmetic facelift that they did so any extra is almost a bonus.

smile

croakey

1,193 posts

219 months

Tuesday 18th December 2012
quotequote all
As a member that owns one ill give you my views

Bought my 03/53 arosa 3 years ago as an economical stop gap - bought it on 36k

Now it's showing 72k and has needed serving (every 10k) a cambelt/water pump (as a precaution) , and new discs/pads as the originals were worse for wear

Yeah it's got 60bhp and the odd mark/scratch on but it polishes up great and just keeps going - comfortably doing an 85mph cruise and returning 44mpf whilst costing naff all to insure

Be sad to see it go in the new year - but needing something 5 door and diesel will end my ownership



Oh and since I've had mine I've bolted on £500 of weitec stainless steel coilovers and golf g60 15" steels to make it slightly more PH (manly) and some ever useful roof bars

JayT

Original Poster:

10,974 posts

188 months

Saturday 22nd December 2012
quotequote all
Hi.

Thanks for your contribution - are you the poster that had it really dirty at one point in a mucky motor thread or something?! If so, that was impressive! hehe

I think some subtle mods can make it look good, and sometimes improve it but I would need to check if the mods that I wish to do would void the policy, or what the increase in the premium would be. scratchchin


TSpark

11 posts

179 months

Saturday 22nd December 2012
quotequote all
I went to go view a few Arosa 1.4TDi (the only engine I would have in this car)

Went to go view three in one day...

x2 where dogs

x1 sold before I even got there.

Its rare to find a nice 1.4TDi, but I get the feeling they are worth it.

Once mapped, should push a tad over 100bhp and still come in at under a ton, thats borderline warm hatch per ton with 60mpg!

Alot newer, but a Citroen C1 does the same job and are nippy....

va1o

16,118 posts

238 months

Saturday 22nd December 2012
quotequote all
The little TDI is good but expensive as its fairly sought after. Not quite as much as the Lupo and A2 with the same engine though! Think they fall into the £30 tax bracket too IIRC

Clarkson did an excellent review comparing the petrol and diesel before Top Gear went silly - http://m.youtube.com/watch?v=8OEdx8dOgUw

ATTAK Z

19,569 posts

220 months

Saturday 22nd December 2012
quotequote all
we've had one from new in 2002 ... still going strong as a third car between two of us ... reluctant to sell as it still comes in handy at times ... 1.0S in red

croakey

1,193 posts

219 months

Sunday 23rd December 2012
quotequote all
JayT said:
Hi.

Thanks for your contribution - are you the poster that had it really dirty at one point in a mucky motor thread or something?! If so, that was impressive! hehe
Most likely as living in the country renders cleaning it over the winter near enough pointless.

When it comes to diesels I think the 1.4tdi is a great engine - but they carry such a tax they make little sense.

3 years ago when I bought mine diesels of comparative mileage were 3-4k with around 70k on... I paid £2.5k for mine with 34k on the clock. I also get a solid 40-41mpg

Even now having looked around diesels with under 100k are nudging 3k in places.. Mines worth £1800 tops!

TSpark

11 posts

179 months

Sunday 23rd December 2012
quotequote all
I know the two I went to go see were sub 2k (the only two TDi's at the time) and both were sheds.

Both needed atleast 1k thrown at them to even make them worthy of being sold imho.

They do command a premium, but if you plan on doing mega mileage or plan to have short term, you will get that back and more and have a nice little nippy car inbetween!