2006 (06)Golf GTI Vs 2007 (57) Leon Cupra
Discussion
As usual when one if my mates want to buy a car, I get dragged in to look over them and offer advice. Then they ignore my advice and buy something slower, more economical and boring. But not this time.
Mate wants a hot hatch. Needs to be 5 door, and wont have the focus ST I recommended. (we all love 5 cylinders here dont we)
So after some autotrader we are drawn between two cars, both under 45k miles with good history, very similar money.
Seat has 240bhp so I'm advising that, golf should be better built and has same basic engine box, running gear but tune is only 200bhp.
Anyone out there owned either or both who can offer an opinion or view, we would be very grateful.

VS

Mate wants a hot hatch. Needs to be 5 door, and wont have the focus ST I recommended. (we all love 5 cylinders here dont we)
So after some autotrader we are drawn between two cars, both under 45k miles with good history, very similar money.
Seat has 240bhp so I'm advising that, golf should be better built and has same basic engine box, running gear but tune is only 200bhp.
Anyone out there owned either or both who can offer an opinion or view, we would be very grateful.

VS

Edited by Tame Technician on Monday 14th October 21:58
as you have said the golf is a bit better built, nice interior, worth more and visibility is a tad better
however the cupra has a bigger turbo(ko4 based i believe) and will hit more or less 300bhp with a remap
depends what he is after and if he could live with the cupra for example, i personally think the mk5 golf is fairly bland unless its a edition 30 myself
however the cupra has a bigger turbo(ko4 based i believe) and will hit more or less 300bhp with a remap
depends what he is after and if he could live with the cupra for example, i personally think the mk5 golf is fairly bland unless its a edition 30 myself
i was in exactly the same position and car choice this time last year. Both good cars in themselves - although i never got round to test driving the Cupra.
In the end i went for the mk V gti as i prefered the looks, interior and slightly better residuals. Its just the best compromise and all rounder. if my budget had stretched (i needed a car not more than 4 yrs old due to car allowance reasons) i would of gone with the facelift cupra with the better interior. Both are quite rare cars and difficult to find an unmolestered example.
I think with the cupra you would notice the extra pull from 50-60mph onwards, but economy would be a little worse. I hear they ride quite firm. I regulalry see 35-38mpg in the gti which is as claimed on my daily commute and it never really drops below 28 when you press on, although i did acheive 22mpg when i had to rush back one evening last week but i wont go there
In the end i went for the mk V gti as i prefered the looks, interior and slightly better residuals. Its just the best compromise and all rounder. if my budget had stretched (i needed a car not more than 4 yrs old due to car allowance reasons) i would of gone with the facelift cupra with the better interior. Both are quite rare cars and difficult to find an unmolestered example.
I think with the cupra you would notice the extra pull from 50-60mph onwards, but economy would be a little worse. I hear they ride quite firm. I regulalry see 35-38mpg in the gti which is as claimed on my daily commute and it never really drops below 28 when you press on, although i did acheive 22mpg when i had to rush back one evening last week but i wont go there

Gassing Station | Audi, Seat, Skoda & VW | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


