High mileage Mk5 GTIs
Author
Discussion

rob1234

Original Poster:

932 posts

228 months

Monday 28th October 2013
quotequote all
Have got about £4500 to spend on a new (sensible) car... I'd really like a Mk5 GTI DSG, but this is the lower end of the market.

What are people's thoughts on 100k+ DSG cars for <£5k?

Eg:


http://www.autotrader.co.uk/classified/advert/2013...

(I'm also contemplating an A3 3.2 quattro - fantastic engine (my dad has a Mk5 R32), but concerned about the universal deriding of it's ride and handling. Same question though if anyone has any thoughts!)

Deerfoot

5,259 posts

215 months

Monday 28th October 2013
quotequote all
Have you seen this one?

http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/Volkswagen-Golf-2-0T-GTI...

It`s been for sale for ages (I was looking for one in the summer but have had a change of circumstances). It looks like a decent car, I really can`t see why it hasn`t sold.

qureshia

4,773 posts

237 months

Monday 28th October 2013
quotequote all
Mines done 114k
Had it for over 4 1/2 years
Gearbox has been great (2 proper services in that time...coming up for it 3rd) everything I've read says must have a change of gearbox filter and oil every 40k miles

Mines been through a couple of wheel bearings (common fault)
A air con compressor (and knocked belts) common fault
Couple of odd sensors, etc
And I would say the shocks are now very tied

Other than that normal service (included belts and water pump at 40k intervals however I believe this is overkill)

AudiSport

1,499 posts

247 months

Tuesday 29th October 2013
quotequote all
Maybe an idea to keep £500 - £1000 back to get the car in shape over the first 6-months.

rob1234

Original Poster:

932 posts

228 months

Tuesday 29th October 2013
quotequote all
Deerfoot said:
Have you seen this one?

http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/Volkswagen-Golf-2-0T-GTI...

It`s been for sale for ages (I was looking for one in the summer but have had a change of circumstances). It looks like a decent car, I really can`t see why it hasn`t sold.
Yes thanks, but it no longer appears on their website (and it's in boring silver) - but looks good. On my shortlist!

qureshia said:
Mines done 114k
Had it for over 4 1/2 years
Gearbox has been great (2 proper services in that time...coming up for it 3rd) everything I've read says must have a change of gearbox filter and oil every 40k miles

Mines been through a couple of wheel bearings (common fault)
A air con compressor (and knocked belts) common fault
Couple of odd sensors, etc
And I would say the shocks are now very tied

Other than that normal service (included belts and water pump at 40k intervals however I believe this is overkill)
That's great, many thanks.

rob1234

Original Poster:

932 posts

228 months

Tuesday 29th October 2013
quotequote all
Any thoughts on this one? Slightly over-budget (although below average for miles?), but pretty perfect spec for me:


http://www.gumtree.com/p/cars-vans-motorbikes/2006...

Always suspicious of Gumtree, but the numberplate checks out as:

The vehicle details for YX06 HNM are:
Date of Liability 01 09 2014
Date of First Registration 17 08 2006
Year of Manufacture 2006
Cylinder Capacity (cc) 1984cc
CO₂ Emissions 190 g/km
Fuel Type PETROL
Export Marker N
Vehicle Status Licence Not Due
Vehicle Colour GREY
Vehicle Type Approval M1
Vehicle Excise Duty rate for vehicle
6 Months Rate £143.00
12 Months Rate £260.00



qureshia

4,773 posts

237 months

Tuesday 29th October 2013
quotequote all
Gumtree cars seems too cheap ???
Or just a bargain

Juicetin1

647 posts

221 months

Tuesday 29th October 2013
quotequote all
Too cheap for a 49k miler. Be wary of it.

rob1234

Original Poster:

932 posts

228 months

Wednesday 30th October 2013
quotequote all
Golf GTI Mk5 forum says said:
Searching the keywords in the ad brings up the old eBay link from a year ago:

http://cgi.ebay.co.uk/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewItem&am...

......and another one:

http://www.muamat.com/classifieds/229/posts/2_Vehi...

Suspect it's a scam.
I'll steer well clear I think!


rob1234

Original Poster:

932 posts

228 months

Wednesday 30th October 2013
quotequote all
Rubbish advert, but might go and have a look at this:


http://www.carlians.co.uk/index.php/used-cars-surr...

Concerned about potential cam chain stretch though. Is it out of order to bring VACOM with me and ask to measure blocks 208/209 at the garage?!

SBN

1,030 posts

183 months

Friday 1st November 2013
quotequote all
I'd be more concerned if they wouldn't let you

rob1234

Original Poster:

932 posts

228 months

Friday 1st November 2013
quotequote all
I think it's a buyer's market for A3 3.2s, so will walk away if they say "no". Is there any way of telling mild cam-chain stretch without delving into the OBD, if there's no CEL on?

I think the one above has already gone - at that price I'm not surprised, even if it was a bit tatty.

va1o

16,118 posts

238 months

Friday 1st November 2013
quotequote all
Start it from cold and listen for any rattles as that's normally the giveaway for chain problems. Wouldn't pay too much attention to dashboard warnings as they don't always come on and when they do are easily reset

rob1234

Original Poster:

932 posts

228 months

Tuesday 5th November 2013
quotequote all
Any thoughts on this one (bit of mission creep from the thread title...)?


http://www.mawsleymotorcompanyltd.co.uk/used-cars/...

Miles a bit higher than I'd like, but looks in good condition and nice spec for £3.5k?

anonymous-user

85 months

Thursday 7th November 2013
quotequote all
You seriously need to drive both cars back-to-back to make an informed decision. The Golf is a far superior car IMO. The Audi in comparison feels slow and incredibly numb. It will also be fairly thirsty.

rob1234

Original Poster:

932 posts

228 months

Thursday 7th November 2013
quotequote all
andrewparker said:
You seriously need to drive both cars back-to-back to make an informed decision. The Golf is a far superior car IMO. The Audi in comparison feels slow and incredibly numb. It will also be fairly thirsty.
Thanks for this - I tend to agree. However, it seems GTIs are a bit overpriced (or A3 3.2s are underpriced?!) I have extensively driven a Mk5 R32 manual and a Mk6 TDI DSG - I'll ask my friend if I can have a go in his Mk5 GTI (manual), but there aren't any available for the c.£3.5k you can get an A3 for...

I understand the criticisms of the A3 (steering, weight, suspension set-up…), and I'm not concerned about MPG. Positives are value-for-money, build-quality, quattro, and a glorious narrow-angle V6...

I think I'd rather have £1000 in the bank and an A3 3.2 than a ropey Mk5 GTI - controversial I know.