Golf or Jetta?
Author
Discussion

Mojooo

Original Poster:

13,291 posts

211 months

Sunday 10th November 2013
quotequote all
My previous car was a 2004 Skoda Fabia which to be honest I was perfectly happy with and would have kept it had it not had a serious water leak. I have replaced it with a 2002 BMW 3 Series which I am not liking at all because of the harsh ride.

I like the VW interior so am deciding which of these 2 models to go for.

Budget is between 4500 and 5000.

For that price I can get a 2005-2007 Golf or 2007 Jetta.

Good and Bad poits for each car

GOLF
Nice shape and size is ideal
A common car so plenty of choice
They hold value well so although there are a lot of them appear to be a bit overpriced
Older cars perhaps more likely to have been thrashed


JETTA
Possibly a smoother ride due to bigger size?
I don't need the boot
They are rarer but for the same money I can get a newer car
Much mroe likely to have been looked after (old mans car)
No rear wiper
Newer 1.4TSI engine within my budget - though unsure if this will be underpowered.
No as nice looking as a Golf

If budget wasn't a barrier then it would be a Golf no question but given the Jetta offers a newer car and I 'wouldn't mind' it over a Golf I am undecided.

Anyone driven both cars? Anyone have any thoughts or opinions?



EDIT TO ADD: Will prob keep car for a few years and economy is important - the newer Jetta engine appears to be mroe fuel efficient than older Golfs. Unless I go for diesels i nwhich case looks pretty similar.

Edited by Mojooo on Sunday 10th November 01:37

va1o

16,118 posts

238 months

Sunday 10th November 2013
quotequote all
You certainly get a lot more for your money with the Jetta. I would say don't bother with a diesel unless you're doing the miles to warrant it. The 1.4 TSI is a pretty decent engine offering a nice combination of performance and economy.

Octavia or Golf Plus would probably be worth a look also as they too are cheaper than the normal Golf.

agxster

396 posts

212 months

Tuesday 12th November 2013
quotequote all
I bought my 1.9 tdi Jetta 5 years ago and also looked at Golfs but for my budget the newest I could afford was a 2-3 year old. For the same money I could get a 9 month old Jetta. Overall it has been good to me (touch wood!) with a warranty fix for some droplinks on the front.

I think it's more or less the same as a Golf except for the boot. Interior size seems the same. Also Jettas are made in Mexico and Golfs I think generally in Germany. Not that makes much difference.

Personally I would get the newer car (assuming it's in better condition etc.) if you're not too bothered about the difference in looks.