Is the Audi Extended Warranty worth it?
Is the Audi Extended Warranty worth it?
Author
Discussion

FUBAR

Original Poster:

17,065 posts

269 months

Friday 15th November 2013
quotequote all
Well, yes when you've just been told your 4 year old S4 needs a new S Tronic gearbox yikes

So glad I renewed 6 weeks ago hehe

TonyTony

1,882 posts

189 months

Friday 15th November 2013
quotequote all
FUBAR said:
Well, yes when you've just been told your 4 year old S4 needs a new S Tronic gearbox yikes

So glad I renewed 6 weeks ago hehe
Saved a nice £3-4k there then! smile

My car also has DSG and warranty is out in Jan, going to need to look for another one!!

fatboy b

9,666 posts

247 months

Friday 15th November 2013
quotequote all
FUBAR said:
Well, yes when you've just been told your 4 year old S4 needs a new S Tronic gearbox yikes

So glad I renewed 6 weeks ago hehe
That would have been covered under SOGA, but as long as you're happy, that's the main thing.

Edited by fatboy b on Friday 15th November 17:01

TonyTony

1,882 posts

189 months

Friday 15th November 2013
quotequote all
fatboy b said:
That would have been covered under SOGA.
Howcome? I know you could probably request them to look into it, but I thought once the warranty is over its not their problem if you haven't covered yourself?

fatboy b

9,666 posts

247 months

Friday 15th November 2013
quotequote all
TonyTony said:
Howcome? I know you could probably request them to look into it, but I thought once the warranty is over its not their problem if you haven't covered yourself?
SOGA is for 6 years on cars. If a car fails to function as a car within that timeframe, then it's covered (other than wear & tear)

TonyTony

1,882 posts

189 months

Friday 15th November 2013
quotequote all
fatboy b said:
SOGA is for 6 years on cars.
I thought it was if you can prove it was unfit for purpose at actual purchase though?

I still wouldn't risk not having a warranty though and hoping you can chase it up through SOGA!!

Just seen this:

Requesting a repair or replacement

If a customer has accepted the goods and is requesting a repair or replacement because the goods are faulty, the onus on who is required to prove the problem depends on how long ago they purchased the item.

Under six months - the customer does not have to prove the item was faulty when they bought it from you. If you disagree it is up to you, the retailer, to prove the item did conform to contract (or that the fault did not exist) at the time of sale.

Over six months - you are entitled to ask the customer to prove the item was faulty when they bought it from you. If they are able to do this they are entitled to a repair or replacement.

Edited by TonyTony on Friday 15th November 17:11

GrahamC230K

384 posts

275 months

Friday 15th November 2013
quotequote all
TonyTony said:
FUBAR said:
Well, yes when you've just been told your 4 year old S4 needs a new S Tronic gearbox yikes

So glad I renewed 6 weeks ago hehe
Saved a nice £3-4k there then! smile

My car also has DSG and warranty is out in Jan, going to need to look for another one!!
And the rest surely.

What issue did the gearbox have? Any symptoms before hand? How many miles?

blueg33

46,991 posts

255 months

Friday 15th November 2013
quotequote all
In 2010 when my car was 3 years old Audi quoted me £2500 to extend the warranty for 3 years. I declined.

In that time the total cost of parts and the labour to fit them is £130. New arb droplinks.

I am happy to self insure!

fatboy b

9,666 posts

247 months

Friday 15th November 2013
quotequote all
TonyTony said:
fatboy b said:
SOGA is for 6 years on cars.
I thought it was if you can prove it was unfit for purpose at actual purchase though?

I still wouldn't risk not having a warranty though and hoping you can chase it up through SOGA!!

Just seen this:

Requesting a repair or replacement

If a customer has accepted the goods and is requesting a repair or replacement because the goods are faulty, the onus on who is required to prove the problem depends on how long ago they purchased the item.

Under six months - the customer does not have to prove the item was faulty when they bought it from you. If you disagree it is up to you, the retailer, to prove the item did conform to contract (or that the fault did not exist) at the time of sale.

Over six months - you are entitled to ask the customer to prove the item was faulty when they bought it from you. If they are able to do this they are entitled to a repair or replacement.

Edited by TonyTony on Friday 15th November 17:11
Obviously mileage dependant, but if a gearbox fails after 4 years with average miles, it's not fit for purpose.

blueg33

46,991 posts

255 months

Friday 15th November 2013
quotequote all
fatboy b said:
TonyTony said:
fatboy b said:
SOGA is for 6 years on cars.
I thought it was if you can prove it was unfit for purpose at actual purchase though?

I still wouldn't risk not having a warranty though and hoping you can chase it up through SOGA!!

Just seen this:

Requesting a repair or replacement

If a customer has accepted the goods and is requesting a repair or replacement because the goods are faulty, the onus on who is required to prove the problem depends on how long ago they purchased the item.

Under six months - the customer does not have to prove the item was faulty when they bought it from you. If you disagree it is up to you, the retailer, to prove the item did conform to contract (or that the fault did not exist) at the time of sale.

Over six months - you are entitled to ask the customer to prove the item was faulty when they bought it from you. If they are able to do this they are entitled to a repair or replacement.

Edited by TonyTony on Friday 15th November 17:11
Obviously mileage dependant, but if a gearbox fails after 4 years with average miles, it's not fit for purpose.
having been there on an item [not a car] its not as cut and dried as you may think. The seller can and probably will insist that you demonstrate that the fault was pre-existing. Of course there is a test of reasonableness, but once a car is 4 years old "reasonable" is quite a grey area

Dilligaf10

2,431 posts

241 months

Friday 15th November 2013
quotequote all
IIRC the terminology in law is "reasonably expect".

You would reasonably expect a gearbox to last longer than 4 years on a premium car.

GrahamC230K

384 posts

275 months

Saturday 16th November 2013
quotequote all
I would rather pay a reasonable amount for a warranty than be arguing SOGA in a hope it went my way, which is not going to get your car on the road in the time the warranty will.

I wish it were as easy as suggested above, but it isn't is it?

FUBAR - how much was your warranty extension please?

My general rule of thumb with non-mandatory insurance and warranties is not to have a policy for anything you can afford to self insure unless the premium really is next to no cost. I would happily self insure up to a reasonable amount, but engines and more so gearboxes are my fear and those I don't want to be paying for out my own pocket.

Skipe

616 posts

226 months

Saturday 16th November 2013
quotequote all
I'm just weighing up my warranty options now...is the Audi warranty better than warranty direct or others? (My insurer are offering me a policy via Warranty Direct that's pretty competitive).

TonyTony

1,882 posts

189 months

Saturday 16th November 2013
quotequote all
Skipe said:
I'm just weighing up my warranty options now...is the Audi warranty better than warranty direct or others? (My insurer are offering me a policy via Warranty Direct that's pretty competitive).
I asked Seat about extended warranty and they just gave me a number to ring, I'm not even sure the extended warranty you buy off them is the same as the warranty you get when the car is new.

I'm not sure how Audi work it but you can extend the warranty on purchase of a new car as well.

For an R8 it must be a fair chunk though!

ChrisRS6

736 posts

214 months

Saturday 16th November 2013
quotequote all
Worth every penny.


Try dropping the engine and gearbox etc....to replace a 53pence oil seal on a C6 RS6!!

Without a warranty!!....believe me it hurts big time!

FUBAR

Original Poster:

17,065 posts

269 months

Saturday 16th November 2013
quotequote all
GrahamC230K said:
What issue did the gearbox have? Any symptoms before hand? How many miles?
Car has now done circa 57k miles. I've always had the occasional thump when slowing/in traffic and gears change from 2nd to 1st, but in the last 7-8 months I've noticed when cold (engine and ambient) and reversing uphill of my drive it would be as if the clutch was slipping...rev, more revs, then catches. After the initial incident it was fine for the rest of the journey. In the last 3-4 months I would get occasional hunting of the engine at lowish revs/feathered throttle. Sometimes even coming to a stop you could see the rev counter chunting up and down a couple of hundred revs. I thought it might be an engine issue (having a Cerbera I know all about coil packs etc going kaput hehe)Took it into my dealer, left it overnight and went back and road tested with the master technician. He thought it could be the clutch pack (car wanting to change gear but not actually needing to) so I left it there and they plugged it in, sent the info off to Audi who advised them to install updated software. Dealer phoned me to say that since the update the car is driving considerably worse. They sent new info off to Audi who advised a new gearbox was needed. Unfortunately the S Tronic (for the S4 at least) is built to order and mine wont be in the country until the 3rd December so I'm 'stuck' with the 1.8T Avant. Just hope we don't have snow and miss the quattro!

I know some main dealers get some stick, but this time and always, Stuart & Mark in the service department at Brighton Audi have (always) been brilliant. Gold star from me.

GrahamC230K said:
FUBAR - how much was your warranty extension please?
Obviously the warranties are age/mileage dependant, and also what you want covered. You have unlimited mileage or > 15,000 p.a. and everything covered or exclude electrical (radio/satnav etc)

I went for full warranty >15,000 pa and it was about £660 from memory. Peanuts to what this episode could have cost me. Id be paying that in hire car alone!

GrahamC230K

384 posts

275 months

Saturday 16th November 2013
quotequote all
Thanks FUBAR. The warranty cost is roughly what I thought, as I did enquire before I bought. No doubt that I would renew at that price. The car I bought luckily had a 2yr warranty extension from new thanks to the first owner.

There is a thread on Audizine (a US Audi forum) about B8 S4 gearbox issues. There is a strong trend for gearbox replacement on 2010 cars with mileages roughly 40-60K there.

Edited by GrahamC230K on Saturday 16th November 20:51

va1o

16,118 posts

238 months

Sunday 17th November 2013
quotequote all
The Mondial warranty VAG use is excellent, would definitely recommend

Scuffers

20,887 posts

305 months

Monday 18th November 2013
quotequote all
FUBAR said:
Obviously the warranties are age/mileage dependant, and also what you want covered. You have unlimited mileage or > 15,000 p.a. and everything covered or exclude electrical (radio/satnav etc)

I went for full warranty >15,000 pa and it was about £660 from memory. Peanuts to what this episode could have cost me. Id be paying that in hire car alone!
paid up for it on the last S4, the idea of the gearbox going is what pushed it for me...

Do you have any idea what the box cost on the S4? (just had a new manual one on the S5 under warrentee, and that was apparently over a £5K bill)

FUBAR

Original Poster:

17,065 posts

269 months

Monday 18th November 2013
quotequote all
Scuffers said:
paid up for it on the last S4, the idea of the gearbox going is what pushed it for me...

Do you have any idea what the box cost on the S4? (just had a new manual one on the S5 under warrentee, and that was apparently over a £5K bill)
Oh my life, that's made me feel dizzy! No, no idea. If I'm honest I don't want to know, but I certainly wont have an Audi without a warranty, be it theirs or a 3rd party one.