Scirocco or Golf GTI
Discussion
I've been thinking the same as I have a 2.0tsi scirocco 210 which will probably go in the spring, a brilliant car.
I've had lots of VWs with power but having driven a 150 tdi golf I found it a little too big compared to the scirocco, which it is of course. I think I'll probably get another 'roc', maybe get the 177 diesel next time but not a mk 7 golf gti. It's a great car though, I'm sure. Remember that the scirocco is wider at the back in particular and planted well on the road, it depends what you want from a car really.
I've had lots of VWs with power but having driven a 150 tdi golf I found it a little too big compared to the scirocco, which it is of course. I think I'll probably get another 'roc', maybe get the 177 diesel next time but not a mk 7 golf gti. It's a great car though, I'm sure. Remember that the scirocco is wider at the back in particular and planted well on the road, it depends what you want from a car really.
Based on MK5/6 GTI
Golf
+ Practicality esp with 5 doors (its like reversing a green house compared to the Scirocco)
+ Same performance from the same engines, and better with MK7
+ MK7 will have new chassis & interior (better refinement)
+ Performance Pack available with MK7
- More common
- Cost
- Colour choices
Golf
+ Practicality esp with 5 doors (its like reversing a green house compared to the Scirocco)
+ Same performance from the same engines, and better with MK7
+ MK7 will have new chassis & interior (better refinement)
+ Performance Pack available with MK7
- More common
- Cost
- Colour choices
I've not long ago gone from a mk5 gti to a scirocco R, I did wonder about waiting for the mk7 but my decision process was this. Putting aside all questions of practicality as you have already had a scirocco, and don't say you find it unpractical in any way.
I had a loaner mk7 (non GTI) was nice enough to ride in and cabin was nice but exterior was fairly slab sided and bland. The GTI or even the R don't really jump out to me, and the interior somehow looks more like a cruisers rather than a focused, more sports orientated car.
On the Golf, the mk4 had a major leap in quality over the mk3
for me the Mk5 was a major leap in refinement and handling over the mk4, but interior quality felt less, probably as VW struggled to contain costs
mk6 , ironically a cost reduced mk5 ( from VW's build perspective)with a nicer interior finish, but suspension , handling the same as the mk5, was never quite so keen on the mk6 looks.
Mk7 looks are quite jelly mold/flat sided, the current VW style, I don't think the chassis is vastly superior to the mk5/6/scirocco, but a new car on test drive will almost certainly feel quieter/more refined, as the tyres will be newer, and suspension buses etc will be a little more tired on your car.
For me I just wanted something a little less common on the roads in the end. In 2-3 years time the mk7 will be a very common car on british roads, probably 8-10,000 plus GTI's around.
At the end of the day, personal choice is just that, if you are happy with the scirocco I'd stick with it until something really grabs you.
I had a loaner mk7 (non GTI) was nice enough to ride in and cabin was nice but exterior was fairly slab sided and bland. The GTI or even the R don't really jump out to me, and the interior somehow looks more like a cruisers rather than a focused, more sports orientated car.
On the Golf, the mk4 had a major leap in quality over the mk3
for me the Mk5 was a major leap in refinement and handling over the mk4, but interior quality felt less, probably as VW struggled to contain costs
mk6 , ironically a cost reduced mk5 ( from VW's build perspective)with a nicer interior finish, but suspension , handling the same as the mk5, was never quite so keen on the mk6 looks.
Mk7 looks are quite jelly mold/flat sided, the current VW style, I don't think the chassis is vastly superior to the mk5/6/scirocco, but a new car on test drive will almost certainly feel quieter/more refined, as the tyres will be newer, and suspension buses etc will be a little more tired on your car.
For me I just wanted something a little less common on the roads in the end. In 2-3 years time the mk7 will be a very common car on british roads, probably 8-10,000 plus GTI's around.
At the end of the day, personal choice is just that, if you are happy with the scirocco I'd stick with it until something really grabs you.
I've just changed from a Roc to Mk7 GTI & absolutely love it 
My scirocco was the 170bhp diesel so change back to petrol & the extra 60 horses obviously makes a difference.
But other than the power difference, prefer the interior (red strips on the doors & the white LED's look great at night) the ride is better, the steering is better & the car has loads of grip. Then theres the standard toys adaptive cruise control, adaptive xenons etc...
Also good being able to open the boot via the VW badge on the golf rather than being limited to either a button on the keys or on the drivers door lol
Scirocco is still a cracking car tho & looks good
Few pics...





My scirocco was the 170bhp diesel so change back to petrol & the extra 60 horses obviously makes a difference.
But other than the power difference, prefer the interior (red strips on the doors & the white LED's look great at night) the ride is better, the steering is better & the car has loads of grip. Then theres the standard toys adaptive cruise control, adaptive xenons etc...
Also good being able to open the boot via the VW badge on the golf rather than being limited to either a button on the keys or on the drivers door lol
Scirocco is still a cracking car tho & looks good
Few pics...




Gassing Station | Audi, Seat, Skoda & VW | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff




