VW Golf MKIV or V for first car?
VW Golf MKIV or V for first car?
Author
Discussion

The Stiglet

Original Poster:

2,063 posts

225 months

Monday 18th November 2013
quotequote all
I'm thinking about buying a car for my girlfriend to learn to drive in. She's 30 and should have passed her test twice before in her early 20's but made silly confidence mistakes on each occasion and hasn't needed a car since. I think me spending time with her at the weekends with learner plates on in the countryside would be a good way to build up her confidence again (maybe!)and was looking at some cars. As an aside, I was hoping to use this car to take my road bike to races at the weekend with the seats folded down.

I don't really want to spend more than £3,000 in case she prangs it and I think anything more expensive is a little excessive with the first year of insurance, which I imagine will be quite high. Keeping costs to a minimum is the key requirement. I see that some high mileage Mark Vs fit the criteria but is there any reason to pick one of these over the MKIV? I think the 1.6 variant fits the bill.

Thanks in advance



chris285

812 posts

163 months

Monday 18th November 2013
quotequote all
Mk5 has a better chassis, better on the inside so would choose one over a mk4 myself

The Stiglet

Original Poster:

2,063 posts

225 months

Monday 18th November 2013
quotequote all
chris285 said:
Mk5 has a better chassis, better on the inside so would choose one over a mk4 myself
I read that the MKV interior was criticised for being below par, which was addressed with the MKVI.

Don't think we'll be exploring the limits of the chassis any time soon though biggrin

mk1fan

10,919 posts

256 months

Monday 18th November 2013
quotequote all
Again, the mkiv has the better quality interior.

mkiv would be a lot cheaper to buy and certainly well within the budget. However, the cars are getting on now.

To be fair, servicing - on any car - is important. Components wear so any car 8-9 years old is going to need somethings.

The Stiglet

Original Poster:

2,063 posts

225 months

Monday 18th November 2013
quotequote all
mk1fan said:
mkiv would be a lot cheaper to buy and certainly well within the budget. However, the cars are getting on now.
I'd probably only keep it for a year and then trade up once she has the experience and no-claims bonus. Not too worried about the consumables on these as they are pretty cheap and won't be doing a huge amount of miles in 12 months.

I think it makes sense to get the MKIV.

zeduffman

4,335 posts

182 months

Monday 18th November 2013
quotequote all
The Mk4 has a better interior but common faults include leaky sills so you end up with a lot of moisture on the inside if you pick a bad example.

Mk5 interior has scratchier plastics, but it really is nothing to put you off buying one, plus the leaks are much less common.

The Stiglet

Original Poster:

2,063 posts

225 months

Monday 18th November 2013
quotequote all
zeduffman said:
The Mk4 has a better interior but common faults include leaky sills so you end up with a lot of moisture on the inside if you pick a bad example.

Mk5 interior has scratchier plastics, but it really is nothing to put you off buying one, plus the leaks are much less common.
Thanks for that, I wasn't aware.

va1o

16,118 posts

238 months

Monday 18th November 2013
quotequote all
Definitely Mk5 on that budget, its a much more modern car in every way. Although its nearing 10 years old a lot of the technology that made its debut with the Golf Mk5 is still used today, and its the same PQ35 platform as some current VAG cars (like the Scirocco and Altea). £3k is enough to get a good one

The Mk4 is only really worth bothering with these days as a £1k-ish purchase. Looks and feels quite old now.

Maracus

4,553 posts

199 months

Monday 18th November 2013
quotequote all
va1o said:
Definitely Mk5 on that budget, its a much more modern car in every way. Although its nearing 10 years old a lot of the technology that made its debut with the Golf Mk5 is still used today, and its the same PQ35 platform as some current VAG cars (like the Scirocco and Altea). £3k is enough to get a good one

The Mk4 is only really worth bothering with these days as a £1k-ish purchase. Looks and feels quite old now.
Have to agree with you. Having owned numerous MK4 Golfs (1.6, GTI, TDI150) and a MK5 GTI, the MK5 was better in every way, except the aircon compressor went in my MK5 grumpy. A common fault.

chris285

812 posts

163 months

Monday 18th November 2013
quotequote all
Have to disagree on the interior as the mk4 is v dated now looks wise imo, and i have a mk1 leon interior which is not exactly a stunner wink

the-photographer

5,214 posts

207 months

Tuesday 19th November 2013
quotequote all
Simply use the rule, buy on condition?