Cam belt / waterpump
Author
Discussion

flatsix3.6

Original Poster:

756 posts

212 months

Thursday 5th December 2013
quotequote all
I have a 05 plate Audi A4 2.0 Tdi and wondered if it is standard practice to replace the water pump when doing a cam belt change.

Cupramax

11,007 posts

283 months

Thursday 5th December 2013
quotequote all
Yes, because the factory ones have impellars made of cheese. OEM replacements have metal impellars which dont dissolve in water.

flatsix3.6

Original Poster:

756 posts

212 months

Thursday 5th December 2013
quotequote all
Cupramax said:
Yes, because the factory ones have impellars made of cheese. OEM replacements have metal impellars which dont dissolve in water.
Sorry what I mean is it standard practice for a main dealer or a Audi recommendation to do this when the cam belt is changed even if it is before the recommended mileage is reached.

cuprabob

19,967 posts

245 months

Thursday 5th December 2013
quotequote all
It's standard practice to recommend it's done when a cambelt is being changed. The reason being as Cupramax says the plastic impellor is a weakness and if it fails, although the part is cheap the labour is expensive becauae it involves the same amount of work to change the cambelt.

Basically it's false economy not to get it done. Tensioner should also be replaced.

FamilyDub

3,587 posts

196 months

Thursday 5th December 2013
quotequote all
Makes sense to do water pump when all the other gubbins are out and the labour is paid for...

Rich_W

12,548 posts

243 months

Thursday 5th December 2013
quotequote all
flatsix3.6 said:
Cupramax said:
Yes, because the factory ones have impellars made of cheese. OEM replacements have metal impellars which dont dissolve in water.
Sorry what I mean is it standard practice for a main dealer or a Audi recommendation to do this when the cam belt is changed even if it is before the recommended mileage is reached.
How far away are you? If it's 60k. Then I wouldn't bother. If it's on age rather than mileage then I would. As above though for another £40 ish you don't have to pay out again for the same labour "if" it goes wrong.

JB!

5,255 posts

211 months

Friday 6th December 2013
quotequote all
Just change it. they are crap and barely last 40k.

Dclarke

4 posts

193 months

Friday 6th December 2013
quotequote all
Best to use only genuine parts in this area and that means the plastic impeller. I've seen two engine write offs where the bearing has failed, the metal impeller detaches itself and the heat welds it to the inside of the block which in turn locked water pump, one jumped cambelt, damaged block, new top end. VAG use metal in some of their engines (some touregs, 1.4 petrol etc) but if it's fitted with plastic from the factory it's done for a reason. A broken plastic impeller is used as the space it sits in is so tight that when it does fail it remains safe for the engine.

flatsix3.6

Original Poster:

756 posts

212 months

Sunday 8th December 2013
quotequote all
Thanks for the replies, but what I am trying to find out is that if the car was in the garage for a cam belt change be it the 1st or 2nd cam belt change on the car, would it be standard practice for a garage to replace the water pump at the same time.

Is this something Audi recommend.

JB!

5,255 posts

211 months

Monday 9th December 2013
quotequote all
flatsix3.6 said:
Thanks for the replies, but what I am trying to find out is that if the car was in the garage for a cam belt change be it the 1st or 2nd cam belt change on the car, would it be standard practice for a garage to replace the water pump at the same time.

Is this something Audi recommend.
YES.

VAG KNOW their water pumps are a weak link, unofficially. Get a genuine belt kit and revised plastic impellor pump fitted as they have changed the plastic to make them stronger.

if your pump fails, you'll have to pay out again to get a new cambelt kit with tensioners and a new waterpump, and thats if you catch it before the headgasket goes...