New Golf or A3 Sportback
Discussion
The wife and I need a petrol automatic hatchback. The main requirements are good ride quality and space for 4 six footers yet needs to have relatively small exterior dimensions.
We drove a Golf 1.4 SE and an A3 1.4 S-Line. Both seemed great but I can only fault them both for being a bit dull to drive and the Golf seemed to have excessive road noise on the motorway.
The list price seems to be almost the same althought the Golf has more kit like Adaptive Cruise Control and a ski-hatch/arm rest thing.
Any own either of these? Opinions welcome.
We drove a Golf 1.4 SE and an A3 1.4 S-Line. Both seemed great but I can only fault them both for being a bit dull to drive and the Golf seemed to have excessive road noise on the motorway.
The list price seems to be almost the same althought the Golf has more kit like Adaptive Cruise Control and a ski-hatch/arm rest thing.
Any own either of these? Opinions welcome.
From what I have heard the ride is certainly improved on the new A3 (wich susspension option you looking at?) How exciting does it meed to be as comfortable auto hatchback doesnt always sit with sporty and exciting! Giulietta may be worth a look for an interesting alternative or maybe a Volvo V40!
LeoSayer said:
The list price seems to be almost the same althought the Golf has more kit like Adaptive Cruise Control and a ski-hatch/arm rest thing.
Honestly, if these are the only things you can find to differentiate the two cars (along with slightly less road noise in the A3) then just buy the car from the dealer that is most convenient for you, or the salesman you get on with best.Both the A3 and Golf are excellent cars.
LeoSayer said:
It will be an SE on the standard suspension.
It doesn't need to be exciting, just easy to drive, comfortable and quiet.
What other critera are you looking at, as if that is honestly all that really matters you should be looking at a Kia Ceed! Very good cars indeed and quite a bit cheaper (designed by ex VAG man, Peter Schreyer.It doesn't need to be exciting, just easy to drive, comfortable and quiet.
Audi seems to be better value for money given there is relatively little between them in list price and the A3 has stronger residuals. Might be worth looking at the 1.4 TFSI COD version too, as it feels noticeably more responsive to drive and offers improved CO2 and MPG. In the Golf that engine is limited to the GT model but Audi offer it on all trims of the A3.
On the equipment front one nice feature the A3 has is Sat Nav preparation on all models. The GPS and necessary computers are effectively standard and you only need to buy an SD card to add Nav which can be done at any time after purchase. VW don't offer that system and require an expensive factory option instead.
On the equipment front one nice feature the A3 has is Sat Nav preparation on all models. The GPS and necessary computers are effectively standard and you only need to buy an SD card to add Nav which can be done at any time after purchase. VW don't offer that system and require an expensive factory option instead.
I looked at both of these and went for the A3 (2.0 tdi SE) - Nicer and bigger inside, but I don't like the handling of the SE as I find it pretty soft, wheelspin happy and lots of understeer (but then again I did used to have Mk6 GT so maybe it's me).
On the subject of the Nav, I find it brilliant - the pop up screen is perfectly in the line of sight and unobtrusive.
I think kit level is higher in the Golf, but I found the A3 a nicer place to be.
On the subject of the Nav, I find it brilliant - the pop up screen is perfectly in the line of sight and unobtrusive.
I think kit level is higher in the Golf, but I found the A3 a nicer place to be.
Gassing Station | Audi, Seat, Skoda & VW | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


