How will they try to get out of this
How will they try to get out of this
Author
Discussion

flatsix3.6

Original Poster:

756 posts

212 months

Wednesday 11th December 2013
quotequote all
I have a 05 plate A4 Avant 2.0tdi and in August had a collision and damaged the front end, car went to insurers approved repairer, and this included the fitting of a cambelt set.

Forward 2 months and 2000 miles the car cuts out while my wife is driving and will not start, called out Green Flag who checked to see if fuel was getting to the engine, which it was. They then found that the cam belt tennsioner fixing bolt was a quarter of the way out and could be turned by hand, this of course caused the belt to go slack and skip on the pulley and throw out the timing.

This of course will have done damage or even cooked the engine, do you think they will even attempt to deny any negligence, anyone had this happen to them and what was the outcome.

gowmonster

2,471 posts

198 months

Wednesday 11th December 2013
quotequote all
blame it on engine vibrations no doubt.


Dr G

16,014 posts

273 months

Wednesday 11th December 2013
quotequote all
Step 1, approach the repairer in question directly; calmly and factually explain the situation. If they agree they were at fault and will resolve you're laughing.

If they dispute it you need to inform your insurance company that you suspect negligence on the part of their approved repairer and you will need to prove this. This would probably involve an Audi dealer diagnosis (particularly if genuine parts have been fitted). If genuine parts were used you will also need the invoice for these as if Audi were to diagnose a parts failure I believe subsequent damage would be covered by the Audi 2 year parts warranty.

That's a tricky one, good luck and do keep us updated.

RGambo

888 posts

200 months

Wednesday 11th December 2013
quotequote all
I would have thought, that an approved, reputable repair centre would warrant their work for a period of time. Probably your insurer would apply pressure to get it resolved.

Rich_W

12,548 posts

243 months

Wednesday 11th December 2013
quotequote all
Dr G said:
If they dispute it you need to inform your insurance company that you suspect negligence on the part of their approved repairer and you will need to prove this. This would probably involve an Audi dealer diagnosis (particularly if genuine parts have been fitted). If genuine parts were used you will also need the invoice for these as if Audi were to diagnose a parts failure I believe subsequent damage would be covered by the Audi 2 year parts warranty.
Given the tensioner nut (it's not a bolt, or at least it shouldn't be! laugh ) was loose this points towards fitter error. SAying that, how many independent garages would buy gen parts in this situation. They "probably" got it from Euro Cap Parts or similar

Dr G

16,014 posts

273 months

Thursday 12th December 2013
quotequote all
It does indeed imply a fitting error but 'because some bloke on a forum said so' isn't going to hold much sway.

My employer as an independent garage always uses genuine parts unless a customer asks us specifically to do otherwise. With important bits like cam belts its simply not worth scrimping.

flatsix3.6

Original Poster:

756 posts

212 months

Saturday 14th December 2013
quotequote all
Dr G said:
It does indeed imply a fitting error but 'because some bloke on a forum said so' isn't going to hold much sway.

My employer as an independent garage always uses genuine parts unless a customer asks us specifically to do otherwise. With important bits like cam belts its simply not worth scrimping.
I agree it does imply a fitting error or even a faulty part, which I would imagine is an Audi manufactured part as the repairer is approved by a large insurance company.

They have now had the car for 10 days and I have heard nothing from them, they said they would let me know their findings Wed or Thur just gone.

I can only assume they have some problems, will keep you updated.

Rich_W

12,548 posts

243 months

Saturday 14th December 2013
quotequote all
Unlikely a failed part. It would be broken in some way. Whether that was the tensioner coming apart or the locking part failing. The fact the nut was LOOSE sounds fairly Cut n Dried. It does happen, nobodies perfect.

For Audi to warrant the parts AND pay for consequential damage. The car would need to be examined by a Audi Dealer. Which then puts the onus on the body shop to PROVE they fitted it properly. TBH I would be amazed if Audi will pay out for this. Far less grief to just point at the fitter and say "your mistake, you sort it" IMO the delay suggests they are trying to source parts to repair it.

Hope it works out for you.

flatsix3.6

Original Poster:

756 posts

212 months

Wednesday 18th December 2013
quotequote all
So after 2 weeks of not hearing anything from the garage and not getting a reply to my email requesting an update I've just rang them.Seems they have been trying to ring me on the wrong number, not the one I gave them.

Anyway they have sent the head away to an engineering firm to be looked at after they got the engine running but were not happy with a slight noise the top end was making. I asked if any valves had been damaged and the said no and thought the problem was with the rockers.

Does this sound plauseable and what work would the engineering firm possibly carry out.

Dr G

16,014 posts

273 months

Wednesday 18th December 2013
quotequote all
The only way I can think of a rocker becoming damaged is because a valve has 'disagreed' with it after losing a fight with a piston.

flatsix3.6

Original Poster:

756 posts

212 months

Monday 23rd December 2013
quotequote all
Update so far, repairers contacted me today and told me that the cylinder head was done but when the head was pressure tested the engineering company doing the repair found a couple of airline cracks and said the head could last a couple of days or last for years.

The repairers said they don't think that this could have been caused by what as happened with the cam belt.

Is it possible for a cam belt slip to cause this.

Rich_W

12,548 posts

243 months

Monday 23rd December 2013
quotequote all
flatsix3.6 said:
Update so far, repairers contacted me today and told me that the cylinder head was done but when the head was pressure tested the engineering company doing the repair found a couple of airline cracks and said the head could last a couple of days or last for years.

The repairers said they don't think that this could have been caused by what as happened with the cam belt.

Is it possible for a cam belt slip to cause this.
Thinking about it objectively. The cylinder head has been shocked/hit in the process of the pistons hitting the valves. It's possible the hairline cracks were already there. (Depends on where they are and what they are near to) But sadly from their point of view. The car wasn't running badly before it went to them. So it's difficult for them to prove either way.

It may be the head will last the rest of the life of the car. But say it only lasts 6 months? What will they offer you then?

I'd also question why these cracks weren't picked up upon initial inspection of the head

Dr G

16,014 posts

273 months

Tuesday 24th December 2013
quotequote all
Could/would you offer the difference to an exchange head from Audi?

This is assuming no piston damage of course.

Edited by Dr G on Monday 30th December 14:32

flatsix3.6

Original Poster:

756 posts

212 months

Saturday 28th December 2013
quotequote all
Dr G said:
Could/would you offer the difference to an exchange head from Audi?

This is assuming to piston damage of course.
What would a new head roughly cost.

Dr G

16,014 posts

273 months

Monday 30th December 2013
quotequote all
If you email me your reg or chassis number I can look it up for you.

flatsix3.6

Original Poster:

756 posts

212 months

Monday 30th December 2013
quotequote all
Dr G said:
If you email me your reg or chassis number I can look it up for you.
You have mail.

flatsix3.6

Original Poster:

756 posts

212 months

Wednesday 15th January 2014
quotequote all
Garage informed me today that they are fitting a brand new head, £1200 at their cost.