Audi S4 (B6) engine note
Discussion
What do people think of it?
Having got more familiar with it, not as nice as I would have hoped. And it seems to have a very strong 'woosh' to it at around 2500 revs which drowns out everything else. I'm almost wondering if there's a hole in the intake system.
I almost want to listen to another to check whether ours is typical.
Having got more familiar with it, not as nice as I would have hoped. And it seems to have a very strong 'woosh' to it at around 2500 revs which drowns out everything else. I'm almost wondering if there's a hole in the intake system.
I almost want to listen to another to check whether ours is typical.
Vehicle of that age I've seen collapsed cats and knackered (no baffles left) back boxes cause odd noises from the exhaust.
The whoosh you describe certainly doesn't sound normal either.
The standard exhaust on those isn't exactly inspirational even when in good order; treat it as an excuse to upgrade?
The whoosh you describe certainly doesn't sound normal either.
The standard exhaust on those isn't exactly inspirational even when in good order; treat it as an excuse to upgrade?
I have a B6 S4 owned from new and if there's one thing it doesn't do is 'whoosh'! With the standard exhaust you might get a slight growl at full chat but that's it. It's what I like about the car although I might be tempted to go for something a little more 'interesting' when replacement comes around.
It would seem there's something not right with yours.
It would seem there's something not right with yours.
bazzabear said:
I have had a local independant Ausi specialist have a listen to it, and he's OKed it - but still a bit paranoid!
Will be going to the local main dealer at the weekend, so I'll see if one of their mechs can come have a quick listen too.
Where in Cheshire are you? I'm in Warrington & have a 2004 S4 cab with milltek cat back system on & it sounds fantastic. Your welcome to hear the difference. Will be going to the local main dealer at the weekend, so I'll see if one of their mechs can come have a quick listen too.
Hey Kippax
Thanks for the offer - what I really need to hear at the moment though is a standard one.
Hopefully the main dealer will be able to sort me out, presuming someone there has a decent amount of experience of this car.
I'm not sure that I've used the right word with 'woosh'. But there's certainly something in the background - and it comes to the fore at 2500, but then dies off again a few hundred higher - which puts me in mind of air being sucked in.
The mechanic I did ask to listen to it did say that they're all a 'bit whistley'.
Thanks for the offer - what I really need to hear at the moment though is a standard one.
Hopefully the main dealer will be able to sort me out, presuming someone there has a decent amount of experience of this car.
I'm not sure that I've used the right word with 'woosh'. But there's certainly something in the background - and it comes to the fore at 2500, but then dies off again a few hundred higher - which puts me in mind of air being sucked in.
The mechanic I did ask to listen to it did say that they're all a 'bit whistley'.
OK, listened more carefully, and also had the Audi dealer mechanics have a look.
It isn't a woosh - the sound was kind of combining with the engine noise and confusing matters.
So the sound is actually a resonant buzz coming from somewhere in the engine bay. The mechanics couldn't say for sure where from - but one of them used to have the same model S4, and had the same noise at the same revs. From that experience, they think that it is a bolt worked loose from the alternator.
Having thought further about my options since speaking to them - I do have a warranty as supplied by the dealer. Given that I bought it from quite a way away I think using that might be my best option. Think getting to the alternator and checking bolts (and possibly surrounding ancillaries if the loose thing is something else) is likely to cost me more than the £1000 limit of the warranty?
It isn't a woosh - the sound was kind of combining with the engine noise and confusing matters.
So the sound is actually a resonant buzz coming from somewhere in the engine bay. The mechanics couldn't say for sure where from - but one of them used to have the same model S4, and had the same noise at the same revs. From that experience, they think that it is a bolt worked loose from the alternator.
Having thought further about my options since speaking to them - I do have a warranty as supplied by the dealer. Given that I bought it from quite a way away I think using that might be my best option. Think getting to the alternator and checking bolts (and possibly surrounding ancillaries if the loose thing is something else) is likely to cost me more than the £1000 limit of the warranty?
OK, an update on this incase anyone is interested.
Confirmation the noise issue is a resonant buzz coming from the front left (looking back along the car from the front) of the engine.
Confirmation that it's going to mean removal of the front of the car to get at that area and confirm exactly what is causing the issue.
On the upside, confirmation also that taking the front off this car is nowhere near as big a deal as that sounds.
So, having spoken to the dealer I bought the car from about the issue, and about the warranty they supplied, they are sure that it will cover this, and that the cover will include the work to get at the issue. (Some wording in the document had me worried that I'd have to pay for the removal of the front to get at the area.)
It'll go into my local specialist on Monday to get it sorted.
Now I've a better recognition of what this noise is, it's easier to separate it from the actual engine note, if you see what I mean. This has made me realise that the engine sound is a lot better than it had seemed, so really looking forward to getting it right!
Confirmation the noise issue is a resonant buzz coming from the front left (looking back along the car from the front) of the engine.
Confirmation that it's going to mean removal of the front of the car to get at that area and confirm exactly what is causing the issue.
On the upside, confirmation also that taking the front off this car is nowhere near as big a deal as that sounds.
So, having spoken to the dealer I bought the car from about the issue, and about the warranty they supplied, they are sure that it will cover this, and that the cover will include the work to get at the issue. (Some wording in the document had me worried that I'd have to pay for the removal of the front to get at the area.)
It'll go into my local specialist on Monday to get it sorted.
Now I've a better recognition of what this noise is, it's easier to separate it from the actual engine note, if you see what I mean. This has made me realise that the engine sound is a lot better than it had seemed, so really looking forward to getting it right!
Further update:
Car is now fixed. It was indeed a sheared bolt on the alternator.
So if anyone finds this thread because they're doing a search for a buzz at 2500rpm, looks like that's a good bet!
Engine note is a lot sweeter now. While the buzz was only noticeable at 2500rpm, I think it was effecting the overall engine note throughout the range.
SO the car is sorted. Unfortunately, the financial aspect is more complicated. Warranty company, Auto Protect, are claiming that the alternator starting to fall off is not a mechanical failure - bolts don't count apparently. Given that their terms and conditions make no mention of this exclusion, I have put in a complaint. Fingers crossed.
I'm also speaking to the dealer about them either helping to convince the warranty company of their responsibility, or covering the cost themselves.
Car is now fixed. It was indeed a sheared bolt on the alternator.
So if anyone finds this thread because they're doing a search for a buzz at 2500rpm, looks like that's a good bet!
Engine note is a lot sweeter now. While the buzz was only noticeable at 2500rpm, I think it was effecting the overall engine note throughout the range.
SO the car is sorted. Unfortunately, the financial aspect is more complicated. Warranty company, Auto Protect, are claiming that the alternator starting to fall off is not a mechanical failure - bolts don't count apparently. Given that their terms and conditions make no mention of this exclusion, I have put in a complaint. Fingers crossed.
I'm also speaking to the dealer about them either helping to convince the warranty company of their responsibility, or covering the cost themselves.
MacD1 said:
How do you find performance. Owned a B5 S4 for nearly 4.5 yrs and test drove a couple of B6's with intention of buying, found them to be quite slow with not much torque, interior didn't seem put together that great either...still tempted maybe just found wrong ones...
They are very heavy up front and you can feel it in the fact they are not that quick, 5.5 seconds to 60 on a good day. Plenty quick enough, but I swapped for a 335i that was mapped and that was like a rocket in comparison. But you have to get to higher rev range to compared to the B5.
Well it's my wife's car strictly speaking, and my own is an Alfa 156 GTA.
The GTA feels faster to me, despite the 0-60 of the S4 being stated as slightly better (I think simply down to it reaching 60 in 2nd, while you have to snatch 3rd in the GTA).
I would have to disagree about the torque though, it's very nice in the S4 that you can put your foot down in pretty much any gear and feel a real push in the back.
In fact, the characteristics of the S4 are pretty much perfect for what my wife would want. It's quick, but in a very relaxed way, while the GTA is a much more involving drive, which is my preference.
The GTA feels faster to me, despite the 0-60 of the S4 being stated as slightly better (I think simply down to it reaching 60 in 2nd, while you have to snatch 3rd in the GTA).
I would have to disagree about the torque though, it's very nice in the S4 that you can put your foot down in pretty much any gear and feel a real push in the back.
In fact, the characteristics of the S4 are pretty much perfect for what my wife would want. It's quick, but in a very relaxed way, while the GTA is a much more involving drive, which is my preference.
gizlaroc said:
They are very heavy up front and you can feel it in the fact they are not that quick, 5.5 seconds to 60 on a good day. Plenty quick enough, but I swapped for a 335i that was mapped and that was like a rocket in comparison.
But you have to get to higher rev range to compared to the B5.
Yeah mine is mapped to 320bhp and it does feel much lighter up front, I just got no buzz from driving whatsoever. The guy who owned it came out in mine and was a bit embarrassed, he said keep yours:-) 335i is very popular at the minute, lots of good reports, think I would miss the 4WD though..But you have to get to higher rev range to compared to the B5.
Gassing Station | Audi, Seat, Skoda & VW | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff



