Golf GTD clutch slip
Author
Discussion

SteBrown91

Original Poster:

3,169 posts

160 months

Saturday 14th December 2013
quotequote all
Hi Guys got a 2011 Golf GTD 170 with 23k on the clock

When under load up a not particularly steep hill, 6th gear approx 40mph the clutch seems to start to slip, bite then slip, bite etc causing the car to be quite jumpy. Also you can hear what sounds like the clutch/flywheel rattle when changing gear. Me thinks failing clutch or a wonky DMF

I know under warranty they will just shout wear and tear, but surely a clutch/DMF combo should last longer than 2.5 years and 23k? Do I have a leg to stand on? Also, will is it expected they will change both or just one of the items?

Thanks

SavanP

179 posts

173 months

Saturday 14th December 2013
quotequote all
Regardless on a slight hill downhill or uphill, you should not be in 6th at 40mph!! This is the reason why your clutch is behaving in this way.

Stop doing this and drive in the appropriate gear for the engine speed, do not labour the engine and gearbox, it will eventually cause catastrophic damage.

I am not at all suprised it is rattling and slipping at this speed in 6th.

SteBrown91

Original Poster:

3,169 posts

160 months

Saturday 14th December 2013
quotequote all
I know i know i try not to do it but the gear selection display sits there lit til you change up and i sometimes do it without thinking, which is how i discovered the issue

Regardless i know it may struggle but it shouldnt slip? Ive only had the car for 2 months so its possible the previous owner drove everywhere in high gears?

SavanP

179 posts

173 months

Saturday 14th December 2013
quotequote all
Yeah it shouldn't slip, so if it is under the garage warranty get it seen to quickly.

Try putting it in 2nd and flooring it and revving it right round - if it doesn't slip at all then it might be another issue.

Drive Blind

5,801 posts

208 months

Saturday 14th December 2013
quotequote all
these gear change indicators are a sure fire way of wrecking your car IMO.

I recently had a go in an Ibiza TDi and it was telling me to change up at 1400rpm and the change down indicator didn't illuminate until the motor was seriously labouring.

They are only there to get low co2 ratings and not for the good or longevity of your engine/transmission.

lengster

215 posts

190 months

Sunday 15th December 2013
quotequote all
Sure its not been mapped? I did a fair bit of research into these with a view to running one,most guys suffered slip intermittently after re mapping.

SteBrown91

Original Poster:

3,169 posts

160 months

Sunday 15th December 2013
quotequote all
lengster said:
Sure its not been mapped? I did a fair bit of research into these with a view to running one,most guys suffered slip intermittently after re mapping.
99% sure it hasnt, as drives the same as other GTD's I test drove at the time

Drive Blind said:
these gear change indicators are a sure fire way of wrecking your car IMO.

I recently had a go in an Ibiza TDi and it was telling me to change up at 1400rpm and the change down indicator didn't illuminate until the motor was seriously labouring.

They are only there to get low co2 ratings and not for the good or longevity of your engine/transmission.
It is a stupid system but sometimes i just do it to stop it lighting up at me - might get it disabled with vagcom...

SavanP said:
Yeah it shouldn't slip, so if it is under the garage warranty get it seen to quickly.

Try putting it in 2nd and flooring it and revving it right round - if it doesn't slip at all then it might be another issue.
Booted it in 2nd and theres no noticable slipping. The DMF also sometimes makes a right noise when trundling round carparks (ie low speed) in 1st/2nd so if VW won't do owt Ive seen darkside developments in Barnsley do a Sachs DMF/clutch kit for the PD/CR170s for 615 fitted, which I could almost live with :/

cuprabob

19,967 posts

245 months

Sunday 15th December 2013
quotequote all
I dob't think you can disable the gear indicator using VCDS. I know a few Scirocco owners have tried with little success so I don't imagine the Golf will be different. Just learn to ignore it:-)

chris285

812 posts

163 months

Tuesday 17th December 2013
quotequote all
I know with my pd150 leon it did slip, but it was more at 60-70 on dual carriageway when i was in 6th and put my foot down but then i'd be in 5th probably at 40 in mine. It's probably to do with load on the clutch as the power delivery may be a little different on the newer engines, but i found where rev's were low as it had to build it never had it slip it was when at peak torque levels and putting my foot down to overtake it slipped

NotBenny

3,920 posts

211 months

Tuesday 17th December 2013
quotequote all
Clutch slip will occur when the engine is making maximum torque, this just sounds like an oscilation in the drive line caused by exciting a resonant frequency of the DMF. I used to have this in my 1.9 tdi, went away when I changed to a solid flywheel.

To tell if it is clutch slip get the car rolling at a speed so that you're doing about 1600-1800 rpm in 3rd gear. Floor the throttle. If the car accelerates the clutch is fine, if the revs rise and the car doesn't particularly accelerate then the clutch is slipping (you'll soon smell it...).

This just doesn't sound like clutch slip to me as many clutches have a decreasing coefficient of friction with increasing slip speed, so once they start slipping either clamp load needs increasing or torque delivery needs to reduce to allow it to grip again - this gives nicer closing behaviour (i.e. the clutch grips better as it approaches being closed) than a coefficient of friction that decreases with decreasing slip speed.