Scirocco vs leon
Author
Discussion

cejsmith

Original Poster:

172 posts

287 months

Sunday 22nd December 2013
quotequote all
I'm looking at getting a new car to commute to work in and I've narrowed it down to a scirocco 170 dsg or a leon fr+ 170 dsg. My question is would people say the scirocco is worth a extra 4 to 5 k for the same spec.

I'm looking at a diesel dsg as I do 25k a year as I often spend time on the m25 car park.

decadent

2,572 posts

206 months

Sunday 22nd December 2013
quotequote all
Biased but no, I'd say it's not worth the extra £4/5k. I am very happy with my Leon 170 DSG. Leon is more practical too.

cuprabob

19,958 posts

245 months

Sunday 22nd December 2013
quotequote all
If we are talking about a MK3 Leon then I would say no purely on the fact that the Leon has the latest tech plus the MQB platform.

If it's the MK2 Leon then yes, as the interior is woeful.

I am biased.though as I have a 170 Rocco but have also owned.a number of Seats in my time,.as my username suggests:-)

cejsmith

Original Poster:

172 posts

287 months

Monday 23rd December 2013
quotequote all
cuprabob said:
If we are talking about a MK3 Leon then I would say no purely on the fact that the Leon has the latest tech plus the MQB platform.

If it's the MK2 Leon then yes, as the interior is woeful.

I am biased.though as I have a 170 Rocco but have also owned.a number of Seats in my time,.as my username suggests:-)
Interesting , I have one vote one way and one vote the other, as for the car I'm looking at a mark 2 as I refuse to buy a new car becuase they lose so much money and there are no 184 dsg's second hand yet.

cuprabob

19,958 posts

245 months

Monday 23rd December 2013
quotequote all
You might have to go Old Skool and make up your own mind:-)

decadent

2,572 posts

206 months

Monday 23rd December 2013
quotequote all
The dash will be the nicest to ever grace the Leon on the FR+ with the Sat Nav screen and newer Mk2 materials. I have the FR as the "+" didn't exist on my model year, but have the Sat Nav which improves things greatly. However it's still not that great as the Sat Nav is loacted too far down (unlike the VW) so isn't that user friendly and looks a bit of an after thought.

Sirocco dash is nicer and it's a nicer place to sit, however I guess it's question of value for money (it was for me) and practicality with the extra doors.

Resale values on the Leon are still pretty strong imo, I paid £14k in Jan '12 (approved used) when it was a year old with 7k on the odo and have been offered pex at 3 places of £10 to £10.5k @ 26k on the odo on mine. I'd expected to loose more than that in two years.





chris285

812 posts

163 months

Monday 23rd December 2013
quotequote all
The rocco will have a nice interior and be a better fitted, but you pay for that and its not as practical so depends if you think its worth the extra for that

decadent

2,572 posts

206 months

Monday 23rd December 2013
quotequote all
As it's my last day at work before x-mas and I really don't want to do any work I thought I'd post a few pictures of my interior to help you decide:









Seat's are comfortable and supportive, dash and interior fit out are excellent; I have no rattles, some materials are cheaper quality (door cards, central cup holders, below steering wheel and glovebox).

The car isn't much different to drive than my friends Mk6 Golf Gti, I do prefer his Mk6 dash though which I think is the same as the rocco. Also I think the Mk2 Leon is based on the Mk5 Golf so could be even older tech than the Sirocco, someone might be able to confirm.





Edited by decadent on Monday 23 December 12:45


Edited by decadent on Monday 23 December 12:54

adam85

1,264 posts

222 months

Monday 23rd December 2013
quotequote all
decadent said:
The dash will be the nicest to ever grace the Leon on the FR+ with the Sat Nav screen and newer Mk2 materials. I have the FR as the "+" didn't exist on my model year, but have the Sat Nav which improves things greatly. However it's still not that great as the Sat Nav is loacted too far down (unlike the VW) so isn't that user friendly and looks a bit of an after thought.

Sirocco dash is nicer and it's a nicer place to sit, however I guess it's question of value for money (it was for me) and practicality with the extra doors.

Resale values on the Leon are still pretty strong imo, I paid £14k in Jan '12 (approved used) when it was a year old with 7k on the odo and have been offered pex at 3 places of £10 to £10.5k @ 26k on the odo on mine. I'd expected to loose more than that in two years.
Agreed, the interiors seem to get blasted on here often. I can't see why, the facelift interior (particularly with the sat nav) is perfectly fine especially considering it's price point.
Also, the optional leather arm rest is a nice addition.

chris285

812 posts

163 months

Monday 23rd December 2013
quotequote all
mk6 interior is better than the rocco imo from what i have seen, rocco seems based more on a mk5 but more inbetween that and the mk6

not seen a facelift leon interior up close so i can't comment on how much better than the pre facelift it will be

decadent

2,572 posts

206 months

Monday 23rd December 2013
quotequote all
Oh if the rocco has something similar to the Mk5 then personally I'd say the Leon post FL is a much nicer place to sit.


va1o

16,118 posts

238 months

Monday 23rd December 2013
quotequote all
Scirocco has a much nicer interior and is arguably a more desirable car. Whether that's worth £4 - £5 k depends how much value you place on the benefits. I'm surprised the difference is quite that much as I wouldn't have thought it'd be more than about £2.5k on the used market.

What would be worth the extra is something on the MQB platform as both the above are based on the old Golf Mk5. Then you're talking about a car which is not only better quality and more modern but also noticeably nicer to drive and spend time in. If you're budget will stretch to £20k you could get a new Leon FR TDI 184 DSG (same as a Golf GTD) - http://www.nationwide-cars.co.uk/cars/seat_leon_di...

cejsmith

Original Poster:

172 posts

287 months

Monday 23rd December 2013
quotequote all
I was thinking of up to 20k, but I could save 5k on a fr +

va1o

16,118 posts

238 months

Monday 23rd December 2013
quotequote all
cejsmith said:
I was thinking of up to 20k, but I could save 5k on a fr +
If you can do £20k I would 100% recommend going for the new Leon as in my link above. Its such a complete package with the new 184PS 2.0 TDI and DSG 'box. Will be cheaper to run than either the used Scirocco or Mk2 Leon as its more economical, 119g/ km co2 so £30 road tax and should retain its value well. Also very well equipped with FR Technology Pack models including Sat Nav, DAB, LED headlights and Dual Zone climate control to list a few. Faster too! driving

aka_kerrly

12,506 posts

241 months

Monday 23rd December 2013
quotequote all
Isn't there a new Scirocco due out early next year that (like the latest Leon) is based on the new VW platform? Could mean some outstanding deals on late mk3 models or on the other hand waiting a few months to confirm pricing/availability?

cejsmith

Original Poster:

172 posts

287 months

Monday 23rd December 2013
quotequote all
va1o said:
If you can do £20k I would 100% recommend going for the new Leon as in my link above. Its such a complete package with the new 184PS 2.0 TDI and DSG 'box. Will be cheaper to run than either the used Scirocco or Mk2 Leon as its more economical, 119g/ km co2 so £30 road tax and should retain its value well. Also very well equipped with FR Technology Pack models including Sat Nav, DAB, LED headlights and Dual Zone climate control to list a few. Faster too! driving
I've emailed them, so we shall see

cuprabob

19,958 posts

245 months

Monday 23rd December 2013
quotequote all
Some of the earlier Sciroccos have interiors similar to the MK5 Golf but after 2009 they were updated to be dimilar to the MK6 Golf. All 170 TDI Sciroccos have the newer MK6 type interuor.

The Scirocco will be facelifted next year but I'm pretty sure it's using the existing platform and not the MQB platform.

kso524

30 posts

211 months

Friday 10th January 2014
quotequote all
Hi there, i must say the scirocco 170 DSG as i am on my third car now in 10 months? the reason is i sold my M3 v8 dct and needed a car to get me around but one with style!! i bought this 2.0 Tdi dsg and loved it but it was a 140bhp Gt i then sold that and bought a 170 GT loved it full spec with 9k miles, loved it until i saw my latest R line 170 Dsg with EVERY EXTRA you can get from vw, I bloody love it and im nearly 50 lol its stylish,and unlike my Bmw's Porsche's & Bentleys ive owned its Classless.
you will not be disappointed i have had mine remapped and its 240BHP now and only £140 rfl
just buy one you will not be disappointed i promise.

oldnbold

1,280 posts

177 months

Friday 10th January 2014
quotequote all
Currently run a Rocco with DSG that is due for replacement very soon so have been looking at and test driving a few options including the Leon FR with Tech Pack.

My 2 pennies worth is that SEAT are still the poor relations of VAG. Compared to my 3 year old Rocco I found the Leon's interior to be very low rent with cheap plastics and flimsy fittings, and can certainly see why its so cheap, because it feels cheap.

I also had a look at Skoda who now match VW/Audi in terms of quality.