New Polo 1.2 Match Edition
Discussion
Daughter soon to turn 17 and went to look at a secondhand (2008) Polo in the local VW Garage. Salesman slickly whisks us inside to look at lovely cherry red brand new Polo not yet registered and available at £1 down and £149 per month for 48 months. For the first time in my life I am seriously considering a PCP in the knowledge that the car should be safe and covered by warranty and free services. Am I mad?
At those sort of prices they make a lot of sense. Its because the residual value is very high so it keeps the cost of finance down to the minimum. Gives you fixed price motoring as it just simply becomes a monthly outgoing with no worries of things like tyres, brakes or the clutch needing doing like on a used car. You might find it also includes free servicing.
For even cheaper look to the VW Up/ Skoda Citigo/ SEAT Mii. I actually think they drive better than the Polo as its a newer chassis and engine. On lease/ PCP the monthly rental will be comfortably under £100.
For even cheaper look to the VW Up/ Skoda Citigo/ SEAT Mii. I actually think they drive better than the Polo as its a newer chassis and engine. On lease/ PCP the monthly rental will be comfortably under £100.
I genuinely dont see the point in a new car for a new driver. Every new driver I know in the end ruin their first car one way or another (including myself), whether its a crash, minor bumps and scrapes or mates damaging the interior as they dont give a toss. (or in my case id ragged it and it was generally falling to bits) Its much better buying a car for 2 grand tops as at the most its ever going to lose is 2k minus scrap value. Once she is a couple years down the line a newer car makes more sense.
SteBrown91 said:
I genuinely dont see the point in a new car for a new driver. Every new driver I know in the end ruin their first car one way or another (including myself), whether its a crash, minor bumps and scrapes or mates damaging the interior as they dont give a toss. (or in my case id ragged it and it was generally falling to bits) Its much better buying a car for 2 grand tops as at the most its ever going to lose is 2k minus scrap value. Once she is a couple years down the line a newer car makes more sense.
Agreed. Remember that the PCP car will need to be returned in good condition. A massive scrape across the bumper that would blow the insurance excess and ncb is much easier to live with on an older car which is bought and paid for.oldmanbm said:
Daughter soon to turn 17 and went to look at a secondhand (2008) Polo in the local VW Garage. Salesman slickly whisks us inside to look at lovely cherry red brand new Polo not yet registered and available at £1 down and £149 per month for 48 months. For the first time in my life I am seriously considering a PCP in the knowledge that the car should be safe and covered by warranty and free services. Am I mad?
Worst car I ever bought. Do not touch.oldmanbm said:
Daughter soon to turn 17 and went to look at a secondhand (2008) Polo in the local VW Garage. Salesman slickly whisks us inside to look at lovely cherry red brand new Polo not yet registered and available at £1 down and £149 per month for 48 months. For the first time in my life I am seriously considering a PCP in the knowledge that the car should be safe and covered by warranty and free services. Am I mad?
So, £7153 over four years. You're a generous dad!How much was the 2008 Polo you were looking at?
For all of the reasons above I'd be tempted by a slightly older, basic used car for a year or two.
If junior turns out to be a careful, considerate and observant driver then by all means go brand new/PCP but for a new and unknown driver there would be a cloud of liability hanging over my head there.
If junior turns out to be a careful, considerate and observant driver then by all means go brand new/PCP but for a new and unknown driver there would be a cloud of liability hanging over my head there.
oldmanbm said:
Wow! What was wrong with it? I hired one from Gatwick last year and thought it was ok. Certainly better than the Corsa I had on another day outing in the South of England.
They are a little basic and the 3-cylinder engine is a bit rough and slow but as a first car perfectly adequate. Yes the 1.2 TSI is significantly better etc but for the money this costs you wouldn't do any better.My wife loves her Polo, she's on her 4th now. While they're not standard fare for a petrol head, they're a nice, solid little car. Actually, they're not so little nowadays, arguably MK3/4 Golf sized.
We've just taken delivery of a 1.4 match edition, which replaced a 1.6 diesel SE. Differences are: Smooth, quiet petrol engine that isn't too bad on fuel, slightly better level of kit inside, and VW seem to have tightened up the handling, it turns in a lot better than the previous car, despite ostensibly being the same generation car.
It's no sports car, but in my experience, it's a perfectly good car, and will do what you need quite happily. Whether a brand new one is suitable for a new driver is another question, but that's a decision for you to work out.
We've just taken delivery of a 1.4 match edition, which replaced a 1.6 diesel SE. Differences are: Smooth, quiet petrol engine that isn't too bad on fuel, slightly better level of kit inside, and VW seem to have tightened up the handling, it turns in a lot better than the previous car, despite ostensibly being the same generation car.
It's no sports car, but in my experience, it's a perfectly good car, and will do what you need quite happily. Whether a brand new one is suitable for a new driver is another question, but that's a decision for you to work out.
We must have been lucky, our 3 door 1.2 match is great. Approaching a year old 10k miles. Second family car. We will be letting our 17 year old have it and buy a 6 door Golf as the second car.
Why? Yes it is a more expensive option than we would ideally choose but the car is modern with good safety features and 60bhp can only get you into so much trouble!
Granted we Need a 5 door second car anyway and it makes little sense being killed with trade in offers on the Polo.
To date the car has been totally reliable
Why? Yes it is a more expensive option than we would ideally choose but the car is modern with good safety features and 60bhp can only get you into so much trouble!
Granted we Need a 5 door second car anyway and it makes little sense being killed with trade in offers on the Polo.
To date the car has been totally reliable
Well the Clio was a disappointment with a few scrapes and scratches. Cheap enough car but the owner was a smoker so a definite no no. Think I will go back to the VW garage this morning and finish the deal on the Polo. When I was 17 (a long time ago) my first car was new (a Fiesta) and I looked after it with great care selling it after 5 years to buy a new Polo ...
Gassing Station | Audi, Seat, Skoda & VW | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


