Thoughts on the RS Q3 ??
Author
Discussion

mch

Original Poster:

26 posts

182 months

Thursday 16th January 2014
quotequote all
Has anyone driven the new Audi RS Q3 ?? My Subaru Forester XTE is up for replacement, and I'm looking at either the RS Q3, Porsche Macan, Volvo XC60, or BMW X3 Msport 35. All are about the same price & performance...

I've never owned an Audi before, would appreciate any comments.

Mike

worsy

6,627 posts

206 months

Thursday 16th January 2014
quotequote all
If you are going as large as an X3 then also consider the SQ5.

RammyMP

7,752 posts

184 months

Thursday 16th January 2014
quotequote all
worsy said:
If you are going as large as an X3 then also consider the SQ5.
+1 I'd have the SQ5 over the RSQ3

anonymous-user

85 months

Thursday 16th January 2014
quotequote all
RammyMP said:
+1 I'd have the SQ5 over the RSQ3
The SQ5 is quicker than the diesel Porsche, probably not as good a steer though! then again its an SUV so maybe not as much as concern as when choosing a hot hatch or sports saloon.

AudiWurst

4,826 posts

258 months

Friday 17th January 2014
quotequote all
MonkeyMatt said:
RammyMP said:
+1 I'd have the SQ5 over the RSQ3
The SQ5 is quicker than the diesel Porsche, probably not as good a steer though! then again its an SUV so maybe not as much as concern as when choosing a hot hatch or sports saloon.
Surprised there is not more love for the RS Q3 here on PH. If I didn't need the space, I'd definitely choose one over an SQ5.

The RS Q3 has the 306bhp 5-cyl petrol engine from the RS3, much nicer than the SQ5.

Edited by AudiWurst on Friday 17th January 09:34

anonymous-user

85 months

Friday 17th January 2014
quotequote all
AudiWurst said:
MonkeyMatt said:
RammyMP said:
+1 I'd have the SQ5 over the RSQ3
The SQ5 is quicker than the diesel Porsche, probably not as good a steer though! then again its an SUV so maybe not as much as concern as when choosing a hot hatch or sports saloon.
Surprised there is not more love for the RS Q3 here on PH. If I didn't need the space, I'd definitely choose one over an SQ5.

The RS Q3 has the 306bhp 5-cyl petrol engine from the RS3, much nicer than the SQ5.

Edited by AudiWurst on Friday 17th January 09:34
The problem with the RSQ3 is it just isnt as fast as an RS should be! the SQ5 is quicker and has arguably one of the best diesels available.

mch

Original Poster:

26 posts

182 months

Friday 17th January 2014
quotequote all
Thanks for the input everyone. I'll definitely test drive both the RS Q3 and the SQ5. I have a test drive of the Macan booked for April, but it looks like deliveries are stretching out to the year-end and I don't want to wait that long.
Cheers
Mike

anonymous-user

85 months

Friday 17th January 2014
quotequote all
This is the one you really want!



Luke.

12,052 posts

281 months

Friday 17th January 2014
quotequote all
MonkeyMatt said:
This is the one you really want!


Isn't that an ML in drag?

richatnort

3,204 posts

162 months

Friday 17th January 2014
quotequote all
My parents have a xc60 D5 R design. Lovely lovely car. It's the auto version which is pretty smooth with it's gear changes. The build quality i think is excellent and the suspension is superb on the crappy pot hole road in Sheffield (which if you haven't ever been is every road). They were surprised with the amount of added goodies you get standard and how little the extras were!

I've driven it a few times and if you put your foot down you get a decent pace from the engine (for a diesel). The best bit i think is i can have all the windows down and be on the phone and the other person says it sounds like you have it to your ear and can't hear a single bit of road noise and when i speak it's really clear.

Never drive any of the others so can't compare but it's definitely worth a test drive i think. Plus it doesn't look too bad either.

anonymous-user

85 months

Friday 17th January 2014
quotequote all
Luke. said:
MonkeyMatt said:
This is the one you really want!


Isn't that an ML in drag?
I think they are related to the latest Grand Cherokee rather than any Mercedes

Ranger 6

7,736 posts

280 months

Friday 17th January 2014
quotequote all
AudiWurst said:
Surprised there is not more love for the RS Q3 here on PH. If I didn't need the space, I'd definitely choose one over an SQ5.

The RS Q3 has the 306bhp 5-cyl petrol engine from the RS3, much nicer than the SQ5.
Because the SQ5 and X3 xdrive35d are fractionally more powerful and quicker. The extra torque of the diesel gives a greater perception of performance and I'm sure the extra space appeals to a greater audience.

Also, judging by the vitriol directed at SUVs those PHers who can afford an RS Q3 would spend the money elsewhere I guess.

scherzkeks

4,460 posts

165 months

Friday 17th January 2014
quotequote all
AudiWurst said:
Surprised there is not more love for the RS Q3 here on PH. If I didn't need the space, I'd definitely choose one over an SQ5.

The RS Q3 has the 306bhp 5-cyl petrol engine from the RS3, much nicer than the SQ5.

Edited by AudiWurst on Friday 17th January 09:34
I initially disliked it from a conceptual standpoint, and still think it's kind of pointless, but at least the looks have grown on me. The one large oval exhaust is also a nice break from the "I've-got-more-pipes-than-you" trend.

mch

Original Poster:

26 posts

182 months

Friday 17th January 2014
quotequote all
richatnort said:
My parents have a xc60 D5 R design. Lovely lovely car. It's the auto version which is pretty smooth with it's gear changes. The build quality i think is excellent and the suspension is superb on the crappy pot hole road in Sheffield (which if you haven't ever been is every road). They were surprised with the amount of added goodies you get standard and how little the extras were!

I've driven it a few times and if you put your foot down you get a decent pace from the engine (for a diesel). The best bit i think is i can have all the windows down and be on the phone and the other person says it sounds like you have it to your ear and can't hear a single bit of road noise and when i speak it's really clear.

Never drive any of the others so can't compare but it's definitely worth a test drive i think. Plus it doesn't look too bad either.
I thought about the XC60, especially the T6 model which has equivalent performance to the RS Q3, SQ5 etc. I was rather put off by the depreciation: Typical on-the-road price for the XC60 T6 is £45,000. But if you look on PH and Autotrader etc. there are plenty of 2013 cars with only 5000 miles or so selling for £32,000 or less!
yikes
Good value as a used buy, I s'pose...
Mike

anonymous-user

85 months

Friday 17th January 2014
quotequote all
mch said:
I thought about the XC60, especially the T6 model which has equivalent performance to the RS Q3, SQ5 etc. I was rather put off by the depreciation: Typical on-the-road price for the XC60 T6 is £45,000. But if you look on PH and Autotrader etc. there are plenty of 2013 cars with only 5000 miles or so selling for £32,000 or less!
yikes
Good value as a used buy, I s'pose...
Mike
The XC60 T6, as good as it may be, is not even close on performance of the Audis or the Maccan

mch

Original Poster:

26 posts

182 months

Tuesday 4th February 2014
quotequote all
So I test drove the RS Q3 today at Colborne Audi in Basingstoke. My overall impressions were rather good - it was a nice driving experience, the suspension felt taught and responsive when hussling the car around some (very wet) county lanes. I liked the 7-speed auto when on the move, flappy-paddling up and down, throttle response was generally quite good for an auto. However I found the initial take-up from stationary was rather jerky and unrefined, especially when asking for a quick launch. The car was also very quiet inside - It would have been nice to hear a bit more of the engine working for its living!

At the end of the test drive I parked up alongside the SQ5 to compare the two, and was surprised that the 5 seemed to be a lot larger in the flesh than the figures on paper suggest. The rear seat leg room seems about the same as the 3, but there is obviously a lot more space in the cargo area of the 5. I have to say that the 5 also came across as a lot more "bling" than the 3, which may have just been the model on show - the chrome trim everywhere and black & red seats are not my kinda thing at all...

Anyway, I'm going to work on the specs for the two cars and see what the dealer can do for me. 4 month wait for the RS Q3 though...

Cheers

Mike

CraigV6

348 posts

162 months

Wednesday 5th February 2014
quotequote all
Better off with a new S3 Sportback over a RSQ3.
Save yourself around £10k and have a quicker, better looking car that has as good as the same practicalities.