Mk5 Golf GTI
Author
Discussion

Garett

Original Poster:

1,689 posts

223 months

Monday 20th January 2014
quotequote all
I'm looking at one of these as my new daily, I rack up quite a few miles p.a (20k approx) and currently have a diesel Volvo! Comfy as the Volvo is its getting on a bit and I need some excitement in my life, whilst still remaining reasonably economical and comfortable enough for an 80 mile commute each day (80% dual carriageway/motorway).

I'll be looking to spend around £6k-£7k which gives me plenty of choice. I'm not too fussy on spec or colour, condition is paramount but Xenons, cruise, heated seats and a sunroof would be nice and 17s are a must. However the one biggy is DSG or not?

How does the DSG fair with higher miles once it creeps over the often fabled but psychological 100k mile mark, I know oil changes to the box are crucial every 40k (2 years in my case so an extra £200 every 2 years).

Do the clutches need replacing on the DSG and if so how much?
Is £1500 still the going rate for a new mechatronic unit?
How much for a clutch change on a manual? I believe they have a DMF also, so another potential cost to consider with the manual.

Any other major flaws to look out for with these? I believe the AC compressor can also be a weak point.

Many thanks

Flibble

6,538 posts

212 months

Tuesday 21st January 2014
quotequote all
Audi dealers do a manual clutch for £750 so I'd expect a VW dealer to be no more than that and probably cheaper.

The engine is pretty thirsty, don't expect great mileage - think 30-35 mpg for mostly motorway journeys.

qureshia

4,773 posts

237 months

Tuesday 21st January 2014
quotequote all

Maracus

4,553 posts

199 months

Tuesday 21st January 2014
quotequote all
I sold my 2006 GTI a year ago. It had 85K on it. No rattles or wear.

The spec was spot on for me - Xenons, 18" Monzas (IMO they look better than the 17s), heated seats, cruise and Highline computer. I only sold it due to me changing jobs and catching the train to work.

NM06 UBH where are you cry

I'd check for suspension rattles, failed air con compressor (mine failed and cost £600 to fix), cambelt/pump at 75k/5yrs, oil changes at 10K preferably, coil packs (these are subject to a workshop action/recall).

On a light footed drive to work in 60mph traffic, then high 30s is relatively easy. Hooning will see low 30s.


ManOpener

12,467 posts

200 months

Tuesday 21st January 2014
quotequote all
I had the A/C compressor done last summer, £509 including labour at my local specialist.

RadoVR6

1,210 posts

237 months

Tuesday 21st January 2014
quotequote all
ABS pumps can go but should be covered by good will from the dealers.

Rust on the front arches and near the boot handle, again should be covered by warranty.

I get mid to high 30's on a run.

This was my diverter valve a few moths ago which is common and the car will be right down on power.



Apart from an ABS niggle I have at the moment I love the car.

ManOpener

12,467 posts

200 months

Tuesday 21st January 2014
quotequote all
My diverter valve had split about 1/3 of the way around the seal, replaced with a new piston-type one. £40-odd for the OEM ones.
Should be DIY if you have ramps, bit of a pain to do without them.

RadoVR6

1,210 posts

237 months

Tuesday 21st January 2014
quotequote all
ManOpener said:
My diverter valve had split about 1/3 of the way around the seal, replaced with a new piston-type one. £40-odd for the OEM ones.
Should be DIY if you have ramps, bit of a pain to do without them.
Mine was split like that all the way round.

I did mine without ramps and it was a pain.

Felt like a rocket after though!

ManOpener

12,467 posts

200 months

Tuesday 21st January 2014
quotequote all
RadoVR6 said:
ManOpener said:
My diverter valve had split about 1/3 of the way around the seal, replaced with a new piston-type one. £40-odd for the OEM ones.
Should be DIY if you have ramps, bit of a pain to do without them.
Mine was split like that all the way round.

I did mine without ramps and it was a pain.

Felt like a rocket after though!
I tried to do mine in the work car park.
At midday.
During my lunch break.
On the hottest day of the year.


Got the wheel off, arch liner out (what a ball-ache), finally summoned up enough courage to stick my entire torso underneath the front end to get to the bd thing and then realise I didn't have a tool capable of removing it- I had a torque wrench which I couldn't get into the space properly because the handle was too long, and a driver which just wouldn't exert enough force to remove the bolts, which were Loctited in place.

Gave up and paid my local specialist half an hour's labour to do it and put my wheel arch back together. Took them all of 15 minutes to do it on the ramps.

Garett

Original Poster:

1,689 posts

223 months

Tuesday 21st January 2014
quotequote all
I was planning on keeping the Volvo for work and getting a toy for weekends. I don't have a garage and only road parking and after doing the sums properly it actually worked out cheaper to just have a more interesting daily, hence my choice with the Golf GTI. For me it seems the perfect blend of fun/comfort/economy whilst still remaining petrol powered.
I expect to get mid to high 30s on my commute (85% Motorway/15% town), which isn't too optimistic judging from what I've read on here and elsewhere. The Volvo is currently managing low to mid 40s so it won't be a horrific difference, and with petrol at a 3 year low I have yet another reason to go for the Golf!
Insurance is also strangely exactly the same for the Volvo as it is for the quicker, more desirable, less invisible GTI! Thankfully the insurance lottery has worked in my favour this time.

Is anyone a member on mk5golfgti.co.uk? They're currently not accepting new members for some reason?


Manicminer

12,719 posts

228 months

Wednesday 22nd January 2014
quotequote all
I'm looking at these too, have got £10k to spend so loads of choice.

I'd be interested to hear any thoughts on the DSG boxed version over the manual.

Juicetin1

647 posts

221 months

Wednesday 22nd January 2014
quotequote all
I have a 55 plate at 60k miles.
Its a great drive. DV and PCV replaced a couple of years ago.
ABS/ESP fault was fixed just before the warranty expired, thankfully.
Touch wood no aircon issues.
Bonnet catch seizes up and is a common repair (I'm on my 3rd!)
Coil packs replaced under warranty.
18inch wheels corrode like hell, mine have all been refurbished and have started to corrode again!
On early cars look for rust around the front arches, they are virtually all affected, mine are fairly bad. VW are now NOT coughing up as warranty claims (lots of info on the web about this) but will offer 50% contribution as a goodwill gesture.
Mine is manual which I like, however my wife has a DSG mk 7 and I have to say it is impressive.

Another Fluffer

3,888 posts

196 months

Wednesday 22nd January 2014
quotequote all
Garett said:
I was planning on keeping the Volvo for work and getting a toy for weekends. I don't have a garage and only road parking and after doing the sums properly it actually worked out cheaper to just have a more interesting daily, hence my choice with the Golf GTI. For me it seems the perfect blend of fun/comfort/economy whilst still remaining petrol powered.
I expect to get mid to high 30s on my commute (85% Motorway/15% town), which isn't too optimistic judging from what I've read on here and elsewhere. The Volvo is currently managing low to mid 40s so it won't be a horrific difference, and with petrol at a 3 year low I have yet another reason to go for the Golf!
Insurance is also strangely exactly the same for the Volvo as it is for the quicker, more desirable, less invisible GTI! Thankfully the insurance lottery has worked in my favour this time.

Is anyone a member on mk5golfgti.co.uk? They're currently not accepting new members for some reason?
I'm a member on mk5golfgti.co.uk, site sometimes goes down for whatever reason.

My car is currently for sale on there... wink

Garett

Original Poster:

1,689 posts

223 months

Wednesday 22nd January 2014
quotequote all
Yeah I did see it, I recognise your name. Its looks a good example, I noticed you're nw based like myself, where abouts are you based exactly?

Another Fluffer

3,888 posts

196 months

Wednesday 22nd January 2014
quotequote all
Sorry for the late reply, live in Chester but I work in Stockport