TTS (at a good price) vs cayman (s)
TTS (at a good price) vs cayman (s)
Author
Discussion

PorkRind

Original Poster:

3,053 posts

236 months

Thursday 30th January 2014
quotequote all
So i'm in quite a fortunate position to have been offered a 09 tts with 40k with adaptive suspension for 15.5 from my boss,. However, i'm very keen on the cayman s (987) which would probably cost nearer 18k for such a milage 06 example.

I know the cayman will eat the tts in terms of handling, interaction & fun and will probably cost a fair bit more to run also, along with the dreaded but rarer ims issue.. But the TTS is supposed to be one of the best tt's produced and handles well ish for a haldex car and goes well.. I was thinking considering most of the tts' of this era are going for 16/5-17 i could run the tts for sometime, if it bores me change and get more for it than i paid and get the cayman.. Some other viewpoints would be most gratefully received.

cerb4.5lee

45,336 posts

211 months

Thursday 30th January 2014
quotequote all
You seem pretty balanced with your evaluation of the TTS & we have had ours from new since july 2012 & covered just over 45k miles in it now so have got to know it well & I agree dynamically its never going to set the world on fire but it is rewarding when you get used to it.

It offers good grip & surefooted handling & we love the looks & interior quality & for a 4 pot it does sound sweet I think, my only advice would be to get it remapped as they are very laggy low down & many on here have said a remap helps reduce the lag but they do feel lovely & nimble to drive.

I think its worth a punt at the price you can get it for.


160

239 posts

176 months

Friday 31st January 2014
quotequote all
Could you not buy the TTS see how you get on with it if its not for you from a quick browse of autotrader you shouldnt lose any money on it as similar ones are at about £17K (I know they are trade but gives an idea)

http://tinyurl.com/npcvcmf
http://tinyurl.com/ne2ckx5
http://tinyurl.com/nbsswsm

Jim909

207 posts

162 months

Friday 31st January 2014
quotequote all
I have had a TTS for a couple of years now, its a great daily use car, its pretty quick, interior is a nice place to be, as well known the steering is a little numb, but this is a trade off as it does everything else so well.

Both cars are great, just different, tough but nice choice you have to make.

p1tse

1,412 posts

223 months

Friday 31st January 2014
quotequote all
I would usually say just go for the cayman a as suppose to be an excellent car, better than the TTs, and usually hard to trade down in later years

So I would get the tts as sounds a good buy and then when you're bored get the cayman s, then you'll have the pleasure of having tried both

In my position it would have to be the tts for back seats for the kids, so unless you're going to be having kids and using it as a second car I would reverse it and get the cayman now smile

Dr G

16,014 posts

273 months

Friday 31st January 2014
quotequote all
I'd go for the TT with my own money; they're quick little things and remarkably good when thrown around a little.

S-Tronic version downright naughty int he traffic light grand prix. Just for your info the TTS gets magnetic ride as standard (weirdly).

blank

3,767 posts

219 months

Friday 31st January 2014
quotequote all
Dr G said:
Just for your info the TTS gets magnetic ride as standard (weirdly).
And I'm glad it does!!



I have a TTS and a mate has a Cayman S.

I've not driven his but he has driven mine.


I think the TTS is a teeny bit quicker but I imagine (based on driving boxsters) that the cayman will have more involving handling and much nicer steering.

TTS definitely has lower running costs!!

p1tse

1,412 posts

223 months

Friday 31st January 2014
quotequote all
Another thing I forgot to say is look at the new cayman

Drive the TTS and then go for the current crop of cayman several years down the line

Sticks.

9,726 posts

282 months

Tuesday 4th February 2014
quotequote all
Comparison report here from 2009 FWIW http://www.autoexpress.co.uk/car-reviews/14140/por...

I suspect the Porsche is a more rewarding drive, but then I suspect it's running costs are greater too.

The TT is surprisingly practical than you might think, despite not having useable rear seats - well all-but. I've still got my 3.2 5 years on as it's difficult to find something which is not too big, reasonably fun and reasonably practical, and not FWD (well, not quite FWD). I'll probably end up with another TT though 4 pot turbo not quite my thing.

p1tse

1,412 posts

223 months

Tuesday 4th February 2014
quotequote all
I had a loan TT coupe and managed to fit two car seats in the back for my then 15 month old and 4 year old

menousername

2,526 posts

173 months

Thursday 6th February 2014
quotequote all

any more feedback on the TTS would be really appreciated, think it could be my next choice

current car is an 06 R32 manual

how would it compare going from that to the TTS

Is the s-tronic to be avoided?

Is it haldex?? Thought they were front wheel driven

My input - although not having driven any, keep mulling over the boxter and the cayman and the thing thats offputting is I would not be comfortable leaving them on the street overnight. Whereas the TT is quite common and unless people really know or are looking, they will not know its a TTS so I feel it is a bit understated, which I like






Jim909

207 posts

162 months

Thursday 6th February 2014
quotequote all
Slightly off topic but...

I purchased a 50" Samsung smart TV last week, put the back seats down in my TTS and the box slotted in nicely, the guy who took the TV from the shop to my car on a sack truck could not believe it !

ontopic:

I have S tronic and its great, normal drive mode is just good all round, sport mode is a bit more on it.

I have not driven the Golf.


PorkRind

Original Poster:

3,053 posts

236 months

Thursday 6th February 2014
quotequote all
Took a CS out at the weekend and was treated to a pretty decent 15 mile test drive by the OPC.. The car seems fantastic, 2 year OPC warranty on an 8 year old car - seems they're confident in its mechanicals?! Was quite highly priced at 20k for a 37k mile 06 plate car though.. I'm mulling it over but am thinking that given the roads in my area, theyre unbelievably terrible, would it be a bit unfair, not to mention expensive annihilating the shocks/wheels.. Maybe ill get a forrester wink!

Sticks.

9,726 posts

282 months

Thursday 6th February 2014
quotequote all
Jim909 said:
Slightly off topic but...

I purchased a 50" Samsung smart TV last week, put the back seats down in my TTS and the box slotted in nicely, the guy who took the TV from the shop to my car on a sack truck could not believe it !
Similarly, had a fridge in the back of mine, though had to abandon the box. Couple of metal garden chairs and bistro table once too, without dismantling. That did surprise me.

Yes, I think they are haldex. I'm not a fan of FWD but I quite like the way it drives.

Whether it'd be more noticeable than the Porsche is hard to say. Afaik the spoiler on the TTS is fixed and while the retractable one is a bit gimmickly, the car looks better/less obvious when it's down. Imo smile

PorkRind

Original Poster:

3,053 posts

236 months

Thursday 6th February 2014
quotequote all
Back on topic, i'll be getting the CS.

p1tse

1,412 posts

223 months

Thursday 6th February 2014
quotequote all
What swung it for you towards CS

cerb4.5lee

45,336 posts

211 months

Thursday 6th February 2014
quotequote all
p1tse said:
What swung it for you towards CS
The TTS coming last in the group test probably didnt help much! hehe

cuprabob

19,949 posts

245 months

Thursday 6th February 2014
quotequote all
menousername said:
Is it haldex?? Thought they were front wheel driven
The majority of the TTs have Haldex including the diesel ones. Only the lower power models are FWD

PorkRind

Original Poster:

3,053 posts

236 months

Friday 7th February 2014
quotequote all
p1tse said:
What swung it for you towards CS
The CS inspired more confidence in terms of handling, it felt better balanced. I've dealt with for the past 2 cars and have been hankering after a proper 4wd/rwd car for a while.
Build quality on the Porsche, it feels, sounds and looks a lot better built, the interior is less glitsy, didnt really like the 2 tone Audi leather. The CS also looks and sounds better IMO.

Jim909

207 posts

162 months

Friday 7th February 2014
quotequote all
Enjoy your new CS.

Interesting you say you thought the build quality was better on the Cayman, i test drove a 2.9 and thought the interior and build quality was a lot below the standard inside the TTS.

The 981 Cayman interior is very nice and imo now upto Audi standard, i am yet to test drive a new Cayman, but in the next year it will be time for a new car and a 981 is definately on my list.