A8 D3, 4.2 TDi, S8 or W12, which is King?
Discussion
To avoid completely de-railing RGambo's A6 Bi-Turbo thread, I thought I'd best start a new one. I like my A8 a lot. It's a 2003 D3 petrol 4.2, with a decent turn of speed, a nice exhaust note and the ability to crush continents without breaking into a sweat. It's a decade old now, still going strong and it's hard to believe that there are actually 3 engine derivatives that I could upgrade to, if I wanted to continue on the A8 D3 theme. Part of me wonders why I would ever bother. Mine is probably worth less than £4k now and to get a meaningful update I would probably end up spending treble and if it was the same colour, most people wouldn't even notice I'd changed my car.
So, am I missing out on anything really special by sticking with what I've got? I've only experienced the W12 in a Bentley and I have to say that although it was powerful, it wasn't a particularly charismatic engine. Dr G reckons that the 4.2 TDi is 'a sofa that takes away your licence', so that sounds interesting! Then there's the lure of a howling V10 in the S8 (un-resonated Milltek perhaps or would I regret that?
). The S8 certainly looks sharp, with its subtle body styling and quad exhausts.
Oh I dunno!
So, am I missing out on anything really special by sticking with what I've got? I've only experienced the W12 in a Bentley and I have to say that although it was powerful, it wasn't a particularly charismatic engine. Dr G reckons that the 4.2 TDi is 'a sofa that takes away your licence', so that sounds interesting! Then there's the lure of a howling V10 in the S8 (un-resonated Milltek perhaps or would I regret that?
). The S8 certainly looks sharp, with its subtle body styling and quad exhausts.Oh I dunno!

I'd discount the W12. They drink like absolutely nothing else and don't offer any appreciable performance advantage for it. Sounds weird too. It's not the King, it's not even a lady in waiting. They depreciated at a terrifying rate even by A8 standards simply because there's no market for them.
4.2 TDI makes a sort of power boat noise and there's so much torque on tap it's a case of choosing just how hard you want your arse pressed into the cow hide. Tunable too, map on a 4.2 TDI gives it pace feeling very much like a C5 RS6 but with 35MPG still doable.
S8 is slightly strange; Audi fettled the 5.2 for torque in this installation but jumping in to one you won't be impressed immediately. The motor needs winding up before it feels quick (the 4.2 TDI 'feels' quite considerably faster) and when the damn thing is finally on song you're A) going naughty fast B) wondering if there is actually a V10 in there because it's so quiet C) Looking at a 15MPG average unless you drive like your granny. Hilarious with naughty pipes on but A8s need accessible torque.
4.2 TDI makes a sort of power boat noise and there's so much torque on tap it's a case of choosing just how hard you want your arse pressed into the cow hide. Tunable too, map on a 4.2 TDI gives it pace feeling very much like a C5 RS6 but with 35MPG still doable.
S8 is slightly strange; Audi fettled the 5.2 for torque in this installation but jumping in to one you won't be impressed immediately. The motor needs winding up before it feels quick (the 4.2 TDI 'feels' quite considerably faster) and when the damn thing is finally on song you're A) going naughty fast B) wondering if there is actually a V10 in there because it's so quiet C) Looking at a 15MPG average unless you drive like your granny. Hilarious with naughty pipes on but A8s need accessible torque.
Hmmm, as I suspected then. Does the 4.2TDi have a DPF, as a I don't do as many long runs as I used to. Fuel economy not really too much of a consideration, although it's obviously nice to have a bit if frugality
, but I actually quite like the thought of the 'hand of God' shove that the big oil burner might give. Is the newer shape, which are still at £25k+ much quicker, or does the re-mapped D3 make them pretty much the same?
, but I actually quite like the thought of the 'hand of God' shove that the big oil burner might give. Is the newer shape, which are still at £25k+ much quicker, or does the re-mapped D3 make them pretty much the same? I think the S8 is a must have. Utterly awesome machine. Mine is non res miltek and is just the best sound I have heard from a road car. I wanted something good after a number of TVR's and the S8 exceeds this by quite some margin. Can be quiet so non headachey when you want it to be which is great.
Pace wise it is rapid. It is big so may not feel quick but I would put it up against my old 4 litre Tuscan quite happily. Dr G mentions winding up the beast but I don't find that, I think it just feels slower.
Pace wise it is rapid. It is big so may not feel quick but I would put it up against my old 4 litre Tuscan quite happily. Dr G mentions winding up the beast but I don't find that, I think it just feels slower.
Do you get any headache inducing drone at motorway (or other) speeds? I had a Walkinshaw Supercar system on my old VXR8. It sounded glorious from outside, but after 12000 miles I wimped out and downgraded it to the performance version. AMG seem to have it really right. Cracking sound outside and enough inside to let you know it's there without being too invasive. I think that's what I'd be looking for if I went for an S8. It's got to keep the cruising ability that I really like about the A8 I already have.
slippery said:
Do you get any headache inducing drone at motorway (or other) speeds? I had a Walkinshaw Supercar system on my old VXR8. It sounded glorious from outside, but after 12000 miles I wimped out and downgraded it to the performance version. AMG seem to have it really right. Cracking sound outside and enough inside to let you know it's there without being too invasive. I think that's what I'd be looking for if I went for an S8. It's got to keep the cruising ability that I really like about the A8 I already have.
Not really the car is very well sound proofed with double glazing etc. If you're on the motorway and settle to cruise control the engine just potters along and the exhaust tones right down. It rumbles under strain going up hills say but it is not massively intrusive so is generally fine.Balls, wish I hadn't read this, heart set on a D3 W12 within the next 12 months!
In sensible moments I sometimes wonder about the 4.2 petrol or the 4.0 diesel, as they crop up at sensible money (under £10k without minicab mileage). The 4.2TDi is off my shortlist as they're too new (pre-2006 stuff tops out at £270 VED) and hold value to well, but how does the older 4.0 compare?
(Still want a W12 though. Not necessarily rational, I just want one!)
In sensible moments I sometimes wonder about the 4.2 petrol or the 4.0 diesel, as they crop up at sensible money (under £10k without minicab mileage). The 4.2TDi is off my shortlist as they're too new (pre-2006 stuff tops out at £270 VED) and hold value to well, but how does the older 4.0 compare?
(Still want a W12 though. Not necessarily rational, I just want one!)
Jonny_ said:
Balls, wish I hadn't read this, heart set on a D3 W12 within the next 12 months!
In sensible moments I sometimes wonder about the 4.2 petrol or the 4.0 diesel, as they crop up at sensible money (under £10k without minicab mileage). The 4.2TDi is off my shortlist as they're too new (pre-2006 stuff tops out at £270 VED) and hold value to well, but how does the older 4.0 compare?
(Still want a W12 though. Not necessarily rational, I just want one!)
The 4.0 Diesel is a bit of a dog compared to the rest of the range. My 4.2 petrol is a lovely thing, but after 50k miles in it, I am starting to get itchy feet for the sake of a change. Very hard to find a replacement though. Mine's probably worth £4k on a good day and there's not much to compare without spending an awful lot more A8 wise.In sensible moments I sometimes wonder about the 4.2 petrol or the 4.0 diesel, as they crop up at sensible money (under £10k without minicab mileage). The 4.2TDi is off my shortlist as they're too new (pre-2006 stuff tops out at £270 VED) and hold value to well, but how does the older 4.0 compare?
(Still want a W12 though. Not necessarily rational, I just want one!)
colossus8 said:
I am after an A8 myself, in particular the 4.2 petrol. Finding one which ticks all the boxes is proving near impossible, looking to pay upto 6k. Preferably in black or dark blue, dark silver, black leather, bose, sports seats.
They are out there, you just have to be patient or compromise on your spec. I got a grey leather interior which wasn't my first choice, but I've got used to it and everything else was right about it. Yes patience is not a strong point of mine been looking for 4 months. Grey leather could sway me. The diesels seem to be well priced pre 2007, wouldnt like to take a gamble on one prior to 07 with the injector and chain issues that can rear there ugly head. Have some experience of this with the A6 i used to have.
Gassing Station | Audi, Seat, Skoda & VW | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


