1.9 PD TDI 150 - how much of a risk is it?
Discussion
I'm very tempted to trade my 130 PD TDI Passat in for a 150 GT TDI Golf.
I don't need the space of the passat estate anymore.
I'll get better fuel economy, and have much better power to weight and handling. And a better looking car!
But reading about the so called 'chocolate camshaft issue' and the failing turbos puts me off a little.
I'd have 2500 to spend realistically...
How much would I need to budget for these going wrong? If its £1000 then there is little point in buying one, as it could cost nearly half the value of the car to repair it.
Sure clutch/flywheel etc are maintenance items but these are not!
I don't need the space of the passat estate anymore.
I'll get better fuel economy, and have much better power to weight and handling. And a better looking car!
But reading about the so called 'chocolate camshaft issue' and the failing turbos puts me off a little.
I'd have 2500 to spend realistically...
How much would I need to budget for these going wrong? If its £1000 then there is little point in buying one, as it could cost nearly half the value of the car to repair it.
Sure clutch/flywheel etc are maintenance items but these are not!
I'd look for one with it already done , that's what I did, mine has had the new hardened cams , new turbo , intercooler, dmf etc. Sure, I paid a bit over the top , but now I know that I have a reliable car that is with the spec I wanted and should keep going for a while yet.
Fuel wise by the way I average about 45-48 mpg , what does your passat do?
Fuel wise by the way I average about 45-48 mpg , what does your passat do?
Kidkola,
I,m on my 3rd one now and all the cars that I have purchased have had a FVWSH. A lot of turbo problems occur due to the fact, that people don't allow the engine to idle for 1 minute after running HOT. Hence the turbo housing could possibly crack due to excessive heat generation and sudden switch off, not allowing the oil circulating to cool the turbo down.
Cam shaft wear is possibly due to a lack of servicing (dirty contaminated old engine aligned with clogged up oil filters!).
It's not a sales pitch but I may be selling mine soon.
Happy hunting, they are a GREAT car, good performance with economy and cheap ROAD TAX. Not many good ones left out there now.
I,m on my 3rd one now and all the cars that I have purchased have had a FVWSH. A lot of turbo problems occur due to the fact, that people don't allow the engine to idle for 1 minute after running HOT. Hence the turbo housing could possibly crack due to excessive heat generation and sudden switch off, not allowing the oil circulating to cool the turbo down.
Cam shaft wear is possibly due to a lack of servicing (dirty contaminated old engine aligned with clogged up oil filters!).
It's not a sales pitch but I may be selling mine soon.
Happy hunting, they are a GREAT car, good performance with economy and cheap ROAD TAX. Not many good ones left out there now.
The camshaft problems were on the earlier pd150 lumps from what I have been told by vag tuners, problem being a golf will be one of the earlier ones compared to my 05 plate leon FR tdi with the same engine.
As a brief over view i've had mine over 5 years now, been mapped for over 4 on a stage 1 revo map which isn't the best I have to say. Only in the last few months have I had any non wear and tear issues, i've had an uprated clutch and SMF fitted back in march and then had to have the turbo done a couple of months later.
However thats after 4years of owning, mostly the car does short journeys now due to being close to work so it's probably not helped on my side plus i haven't always treated her as well as I do now so i can't say for certain what part is me and if any the common issues. Other than this the car owes me nothing as it's cost me just usual wear and tear over the time i have owned it, you will find more turbo lag if you haven't already driven a pd150.
Could be tough trying to find a good non abused example, just do the usual checks for used cars and check the 1.9 specifics such as clutch and turbo but as with any used car there is an element of unknown.
I would maybe suggest looking for a mk1 leon cupra or FR around late 2004/2005 if you can, the golf ended it's run with that engine earlier and if later engines are better then really a leon is the only way to get a later engine and it should have fewer miles which should help. For reference my 05 plate FR has done 77k
As a brief over view i've had mine over 5 years now, been mapped for over 4 on a stage 1 revo map which isn't the best I have to say. Only in the last few months have I had any non wear and tear issues, i've had an uprated clutch and SMF fitted back in march and then had to have the turbo done a couple of months later.
However thats after 4years of owning, mostly the car does short journeys now due to being close to work so it's probably not helped on my side plus i haven't always treated her as well as I do now so i can't say for certain what part is me and if any the common issues. Other than this the car owes me nothing as it's cost me just usual wear and tear over the time i have owned it, you will find more turbo lag if you haven't already driven a pd150.
Could be tough trying to find a good non abused example, just do the usual checks for used cars and check the 1.9 specifics such as clutch and turbo but as with any used car there is an element of unknown.
I would maybe suggest looking for a mk1 leon cupra or FR around late 2004/2005 if you can, the golf ended it's run with that engine earlier and if later engines are better then really a leon is the only way to get a later engine and it should have fewer miles which should help. For reference my 05 plate FR has done 77k
Gassing Station | Audi, Seat, Skoda & VW | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


