Octavia vRS MKII - Thoughts/Advice
Octavia vRS MKII - Thoughts/Advice
Author
Discussion

bildo

Original Poster:

11 posts

180 months

Monday 10th February 2014
quotequote all
Hi chaps,
After spending several months saving for a 335D I've had a bit of a financial blow and since my current car is to be sold in just over a weeks time I've decided it's time to start looking at alternatives.

I've always liked the MKII vRS's, the more I read up the more decent they seem for the money. For about £7k I can get a local one with good mileage, FSH and warranty which is massively tempting.

I do 10 miles to work each day (so 20 miles) occasional driving in the evenings during the week and then normally about 150 miles every other weekend. I'm pretty stuck with deciding whether I should stick with petrol or buy my first diesel. I'm assuming that these journeys aren't too short for the DPF to start becoming an issue and things? I've read that the diesel is a little soul-less and that unless you're doing silly miles then the petrol is the one to have?

Any advice, ownership experiences, other car recommendations on a similar line etc are welcomed. Whilst seeing better MPG is always a temptation I don't want to be utterly bored out of my brain in the process!

ManOpener

12,467 posts

200 months

Monday 10th February 2014
quotequote all
I've got a Seat Leon TFSI, which is basically a petrol vRS with a different body. I can't say a great deal for the diesels unfortunately but can about the petrol.

There are a few issues with the TFSI petrol engines which are widely catalogued, you can usually do a pretty good job of diagnosing on a test drive. Generally:
Sluggish mid-range performance = Diverter valve seal gone
Audible boost leak (whistle on WOT) = Diverter valve seal really gone or split in pipework
Sluggish low-end performance = Leaky PCV
Hesitation on full throttle = Throttle body position needs resetting
Rough start when cold = Manifold runner flaps or low oil (they get very dieselly-sounding when the oil level is low)
Poor MPG = Possibly PCV, possibly diverter valve
Combination of the above = Carbon build-up on intake valves

Only the last of those is costly to fix in any way.

The 2.0 TFSI is a lovely engine when it's all running well, very versatile and even makes a good noise for a 4-pot turbo petrol. Expect around 35mpg on a run. Some of them like a bit of oil, some don't. They need a good 5W30 fully synthetic really. They tend to run much better on Super than they do on normal 95 octane.

The Mk5 GTI/Leon TFSI+FR/vRS chassis is quite adjustable and good fun, but the suspension on the Golf and Seat is quite firm. It's very sensitive to tyres, the best I've found on mine so far are Goodyear Eagle F1 Asymmetric 2's. Loud rear tyres are a sign of poor rear wheel alignment, something lots of garages seem to get wrong with chassis.

If anything the Octavias are a bit better built than the Golfs.

bildo

Original Poster:

11 posts

180 months

Monday 10th February 2014
quotequote all
ManOpener said:
I've got a Seat Leon TFSI, which is basically a petrol vRS with a different body. I can't say a great deal for the diesels unfortunately but can about the petrol.

There are a few issues with the TFSI petrol engines which are widely catalogued, you can usually do a pretty good job of diagnosing on a test drive. Generally:
Sluggish mid-range performance = Diverter valve seal gone
Audible boost leak (whistle on WOT) = Diverter valve seal really gone or split in pipework
Sluggish low-end performance = Leaky PCV
Hesitation on full throttle = Throttle body position needs resetting
Rough start when cold = Manifold runner flaps or low oil (they get very dieselly-sounding when the oil level is low)
Poor MPG = Possibly PCV, possibly diverter valve
Combination of the above = Carbon build-up on intake valves

Only the last of those is costly to fix in any way.

The 2.0 TFSI is a lovely engine when it's all running well, very versatile and even makes a good noise for a 4-pot turbo petrol. Expect around 35mpg on a run. Some of them like a bit of oil, some don't. They need a good 5W30 fully synthetic really. They tend to run much better on Super than they do on normal 95 octane.

The Mk5 GTI/Leon TFSI+FR/vRS chassis is quite adjustable and good fun, but the suspension on the Golf and Seat is quite firm. It's very sensitive to tyres, the best I've found on mine so far are Goodyear Eagle F1 Asymmetric 2's. Loud rear tyres are a sign of poor rear wheel alignment, something lots of garages seem to get wrong with chassis.

If anything the Octavias are a bit better built than the Golfs.
Great reply mate, thank you.

The problems you mentioned sound like pretty easy fixes, part of the thing that makes me want to go with these is the wealth of knowledge available.

I do wonder just how much of a disadvantage I'd see going for petrol over the obvious MPG gains of the petrol.

35mpg on a run is decent, but when the figures like the TDI are being thrown about and I'm doing quite a few long journeys, the temptation is there. Prices don't vary too wildly for either model either it seems.

My last few cars have been:
Starlet Glanza V (Coilovered), Leon Cupra R (lowered), E46 M3 (lowered), currently got an MX5 lowered as a runaround so doubt the ride will be too harsh for me haha.

Surprised to hear the Octavia's are better built than the Golf's!

Thanks for the help buddy, much appreciated.

ManOpener

12,467 posts

200 months

Monday 10th February 2014
quotequote all
What's your 10-mile commute like? If it's stop-start or town driving heavy I doubt you'd see as large a difference between petrol and diesel as the combined figures might suggest. The only experience I have with the 170 PD unit is in an A4- it's a bit agricultural compared to the newer CRs but they're also more reliable too. Early ones had issues with the oil pumps but I think these were only on the longitudinal fitments.

The 2.0 TFSI is a nicer engine, though.