VAG 170 tdi manual vs DSG?
VAG 170 tdi manual vs DSG?
Author
Discussion

gixermark

Original Poster:

752 posts

218 months

Monday 10th February 2014
quotequote all
Hi guys,

I've driven a petrol DSG passat (2.0T) rental car for a week or so on the past... And recently test drove a 2010 Octavia VRS 170 tdi manual....

I've pretty much decided that a 2.0 tdi Octavia VRS estate is what I am buying.... Interested to hear from folk that have had good miles in both manual and Dsg to compare?

Driving through the week, short journeys.. School runs.. Gym etc... Wk end longer runs with bikes etc... And will tow occasionally

One thing I didn't like about the dsg is the way they hold revs when you accelerate hard and then lift off... Bike like any auto box really.. Hard to describe, but just not as 'connected' as a direct manual... But may be easier to live with 90% of the time?

Moley RUFC

3,673 posts

220 months

Tuesday 11th February 2014
quotequote all
I've done nearly 85k in my vRS DSG (face lift mk2) and it hasn't missed a beat. Perfect in auto mode for 90% of the time then great with the paddles when I spot a nice B road.

Dr G

16,013 posts

273 months

Tuesday 11th February 2014
quotequote all
DSG - better suited to the fairly narrow diesel power band.

As already pointed out (and comes up in every man/auto thread) the paddles are your friends smile

AGK

1,605 posts

186 months

Tuesday 11th February 2014
quotequote all
DSG.

It's a rather good combo to be honest, great for my morning rush hour driving and then pop it in sport/use the paddles for a back road blast.

Not sure what you mean about holding revs after you let off? DSG will learn your driving style so if it's a 2010 then chances are it wasn't adjusted to you yet.

gixermark

Original Poster:

752 posts

218 months

Tuesday 11th February 2014
quotequote all
thanks guys... interesting on learning driving style - wasn't aware of that.

one thing that pissed me off in the passat 2.0T hire car with DSG was that when parallel reverse parking (up slight hill) when in reverse... letting off the brake it sat there.. needed throttle to move.. it wasn't steep - and in my last auto car (A6 3.0 Tdi) it effortlessly moved back as soon as you would release the brake.

it made for a very awkward driving experience nudging back inch by inch into a tight spot...

maybe something you'd get a feel for ?

Pugster

460 posts

212 months

Tuesday 11th February 2014
quotequote all
That might be the auto hill-hold kicking in. When that's engaged it won't move until you give it a little bit of throttle.

I've never had a problem manoeuvring and I've found the creep has always been enough to get the car moving. On steeper hills you need to give it a little bit of gas to get moving sometimes but it's something you get a feel for.

gixermark

Original Poster:

752 posts

218 months

Tuesday 11th February 2014
quotequote all
thanks....... ultimately need to drive one with the 2.0 tdi CR engine to know for sure i guess...

overall there don't seem too many horror stories about the DSG... oil change at 40K intervals and seem pretty solid..

need a drive to satisfy my curiosity before i pull the pin....

va1o

16,118 posts

238 months

Tuesday 11th February 2014
quotequote all
Another vote for the DSG from me, suits the CR TDI well.

missing the VR6

2,540 posts

220 months

Wednesday 12th February 2014
quotequote all
My last MK2.5 Octavia VRS TDI demonstrator, and the only DSG one I had was probably one of my all time favorite company cars, that list includes RX8's, MX5's Focus ST 2.5Ts and Mazda MPS 3&6's. Just a great all round package of performance and everyday useability. The DSG just gave it that easy to live with ability for the commute, and the paddles for fun.

gixermark

Original Poster:

752 posts

218 months

Wednesday 12th February 2014
quotequote all
thanks guys........ seems unanimous !!

will hopefully test drive one later on this morning and go from there..... maybe i just had a bad DSG experience... or possibly just takes a little bit to get used to them

Fourmotion

1,032 posts

251 months

Thursday 13th February 2014
quotequote all
Seems I'm on my own here, but I chose the manual.

I've never really liked or needed a manual, I like to feel more in control of the car. No real advantage, I drive it normally, I just don't like a second brain in the car dictating my gearing! I also found on the test drive that it didn't appear to pick up as well as the manual when you put your foot down. It was only momentary, but I still felt like there was a delay.

The manual has been great, I've not had any problems with it. Economy is meant to be better, but who knows, it's totally dependent on your driving style. It was certainly cheaper to spec!. I think they're both good enough for a diesel estate!

sumo69

2,164 posts

251 months

Thursday 13th February 2014
quotequote all
I am currently looking at a Tiguan as the new family hack - decided on the tdi and drove both manual and DSG.

I marginally preferred the manual but what swings it is that the contract hire rates for a DSG are significantly lower than for a manual and it is a £1200 option!

Go figure.

David