Should I buy a C6 S6 Avant? Or E61 535d?
Should I buy a C6 S6 Avant? Or E61 535d?
Author
Discussion

The Stiglet

Original Poster:

2,063 posts

225 months

Monday 17th February 2014
quotequote all
Added this comment/thesis to the S6 V10 thread but not sure I'll get a fast enough response there and looking for opinions please.

I went and test drove one today and I think I'm very close to buying it but need to talk about it to be sure hehe

I'd only ever driven a C5 RS6 avant and been driven in a 2.7tdi C6 A6 avant, so didn't have a whole load to go on. My first thought was how good they look in the flesh especially with the carbon interior. Stepping out of my BMW E39 and into the S6 made me realise how far cars have moved on digitally; I wasn't aware it had keyless entry for example and I started it using the key! Took me 5 mins to work out how to open the glovebox too... It's definitely a nice place to sit and I love the electric boot - loads of space and the backseats were comfy too.

Started it up and it was louder than I expected after reading lots of threads saying how muted it was stock. Off I went on a test drive. Now the ride, people have complained - many people, about how stiff it is. Personally, I wouldn't call it stiff and leave it at that. What I noticed, probably because I only had the chance to drive on potted B roads, was the very powerful rebound. It wasn't uncomfortable as such but it was noticeable and surprising as I expected it to be stiffer, harder and less compliant based on the reviews.
What I experienced was the impression that the large alloys and low profile tyres made it feel stiff and introduced some road noise but actually the damping is pretty good. Perhaps the springs are a little heavy and the rate too high on poor roads?

Still, the ride was very comfortable and although I couldn't push on, I didn't experience any evidence of understeer from that massive engine in the snout. (Not saying it won't at higher speeds though) The gearbox is light-years ahead of my E39's and in Sport mode or with manual shifts, it certainly made progress! Across the rev range the S6 would demolish my 540i even if it is perhaps a tiny bit flat in D mode at very low revs. Once you're up and running, I would agree with everyone else that the exhaust is too muted but under load, it's very pleasing.

Once I'd gotten myself comfortable with things I realised that there was a rattle, not a loud rattle but it was annoying and it was coming from somewhere in the dashboard in front of me. There was also a major rattle from the rear loadcover over bumpier sections so I took it out and refitted at the end of the drive as well as opening and closing the backseats. I asked the dealer to check these as well as touch up some stone chips, t-cut a few scratches and look at one of the daytime running LEDs, which had condensation inside. He just bought two new Conti 3's for the front, the rears are pretty new but one is a Conti SP and the other a 2 - is that really a problem? On the last MOT it said front nearside ARB showed some signs of wear but not enough to fail. How much is that?

It's got a full Audi service history, which is complete although I'm not familiar with what they do on a longlife service? Is it oil each time?

Assuming all the above can be fixed, should I buy it or should I buy an E61 535d?
Thanks

The Stiglet

Original Poster:

2,063 posts

225 months

Monday 17th February 2014
quotequote all
Taken it off the market and it's going to Audi for a check. Hope to God I'm not mad!

RobbyJ

1,824 posts

253 months

Monday 17th February 2014
quotequote all
I had a similar mental crisis when I bought my C6 RS6, I'd say let your heart rule and get the C6. I had my C6 parked next to my mates 535d yesterday ad whilst I like and respect the 535d, especially its fuel economy but IMHO the C6 has so much more going for it as a machine.

1: Interior, the 535d has a bland textbook BMW interior that is so uninspired and sends me to sleep instantly. The C6 is far better, better look and feel, better layout, just better.

2: 4WD, real world every day grip, you can't beat it!

3: V10 petrol vs diesel, need I say more.

The fuel economy is really bad in the Audi so be ready for that. There are few cars of the 535d's age and size that do the blend of performance and economy so well, in my mind that's the really strong part of the BMW offering. It's simple, if you want performance and economy get the BMW, if not then get the Audi.

The Stiglet

Original Poster:

2,063 posts

225 months

Monday 17th February 2014
quotequote all
Thanks mate - yeah it is a dilemma! I started off going for a Z4MR and found a good one, was about to pull the trigger when SWMBO put a stop to my 'impractical' madness. I tried to justify getting a small runaround as well as the Z4 but no chance! So in a knee jerk reaction I went on the hunt for a FFRR S/C but not had much luck finding one at a price that I'd want to go and buy at. Running costs put me off that too. Then it was an E63 AMG estate and I think that would be brilliant apart from front discs costing £2k and air suspension struts known to fail. Can't find a good one under £20k at the moment either.

And so, I came back to the S6, when I'd first started thinking about one 2 years ago! Agree that the E60/1 are dull inside and to be fair, they don't look that great on the outside either. Good reputation though in 535/550i guise.

But you're right, the S6 did feel more special and I'm kind of excited about what it would feel and sound like roaring down a motorway slip road!

Edited by The Stiglet on Monday 17th February 12:09