2010 2.0l (140) tdi V 2004 1.9tdi (130) V 1.6tdi (105)
2010 2.0l (140) tdi V 2004 1.9tdi (130) V 1.6tdi (105)
Author
Discussion

seatdriver357

Original Poster:

20 posts

156 months

Sunday 2nd March 2014
quotequote all
Ive drove all three and can say VW are going backwards with engines.

I drive about 400 miles per week and recently drove the follow vehicles;

1.9TDi (130) Seat Toledo 2004
Perfectly matched engine gearbox combination, returned 65mpg daily, very torquey with little need to change gears, 6th was a treat, you could lift off well before junctions and with no engine braking greatly increased fuel economy.
extras, auto wipers, auto dip mirror, auto radio volume,

2.0TDi (140) Seat Exeo 2010
Found bumps on the road I didn't know existed in the 2004 Toledo, cats eyes feel like pot holes, More frequent gear changes returns 56mpg, would be greatly increased if there was less engine braking but you have to hold throttle on for longer approaching junctions etc.
extras, none, Radio is total rubbish, no rear speakers, this is horrific in a 2010 car, no auto wipers, no auto dip mirrors

1.6TDi (105) Seat Toledo 2013
Feels very budget, i was expecting great mpg, however the best i could get was 59mpg, could not get 60mpg for any length of period, car was nippy and 105 bhp engine works well but why did they not add the 6th gear?
Extras, none.

The newer models wouldn't put a patch on the older 2004 model for extras, comfort, economy.

SteBrown91

3,168 posts

160 months

Sunday 2nd March 2014
quotequote all
So you are comparing a top spec Toledo against newer base model Toledos/exeo. The top spec exeos (sport tech) have more kit than you will ever need. The new Toledo is a polo platform so not comparible to the others. Pointless rant.

seatdriver357

Original Poster:

20 posts

156 months

Sunday 2nd March 2014
quotequote all
Sorry for side tracking, I was commenting more on drivability and economy

Dr G

16,012 posts

273 months

Monday 3rd March 2014
quotequote all
Not really apples/apples comparisons there.

In 2004 the PD130 was the top of the tree four cylinder diesel. In terms of position in the range you'd now be looking at a comparison with a CR170.

BGarside

1,568 posts

168 months

Tuesday 4th March 2014
quotequote all
Old PD engine is supposedly more reliable than the newer CR engines but rougher and noisier. Also I believe it is considered to have a narrower power band.

Still, a very tunable engine without some of the issues affecting the CR engines or later model PD piezo-electric injectors.

Top of the tree PD motor was the 150, not the 130, unless you count the 160hp version fitted to the Seat Ibiza Cupra TDI.

Drive Blind

5,800 posts

208 months

Tuesday 4th March 2014
quotequote all
How you can say they are going backwards is beyond me.

The CR engine is light years ahead of the PD with regards to refinement and driveability.

va1o

16,118 posts

238 months

Tuesday 4th March 2014
quotequote all
seatdriver357 said:
1.9TDi (130) Seat Toledo 2004
Perfectly matched engine gearbox combination, returned 65mpg daily, very torquey with little need to change gears, 6th was a treat, you could lift off well before junctions and with no engine braking greatly increased fuel economy.
extras, auto wipers, auto dip mirror, auto radio volume,
Back in the early 00s that was the pretty much the best diesel engine on the market. It was also before SEAT started the silly cost cutting so you genuinely were getting a VW/ Audi quality product just at a lower price.

seatdriver357 said:
2.0TDi (140) Seat Exeo 2010
Found bumps on the road I didn't know existed in the 2004 Toledo, cats eyes feel like pot holes, More frequent gear changes returns 56mpg, would be greatly increased if there was less engine braking but you have to hold throttle on for longer approaching junctions etc.
extras, none, Radio is total rubbish, no rear speakers, this is horrific in a 2010 car, no auto wipers, no auto dip mirrors
Well clearly that was a low spec example of the Exeo, but at the end of the day its based on an old Audi A4 and as above was built down to a price. Nothing wrong with that engine though, try it in a better car next time.

seatdriver357 said:
1.6TDi (105) Seat Toledo 2013
Feels very budget, i was expecting great mpg, however the best i could get was 59mpg, could not get 60mpg for any length of period, car was nippy and 105 bhp engine works well but why did they not add the 6th gear?
Extras, none.
The new Toledo is an extreme budget car, really a heavily cost cut and enlarged version of the VW Polo. The 1.6 TDI seems engineered purely to achieve good paper MPG figures. Only more expensive cars get the 6th gear.

seatdriver357 said:
The newer models wouldn't put a patch on the older 2004 model for extras, comfort, economy.
Try comparing like for like next time. I think really you should be looking at an A3/ Golf 2.0 TDI or maybe a Passat/ Superb with a bit of kit. Stuff that was on the options list in 2004 or only standard on top of the range models will be the same today.

seatdriver357

Original Poster:

20 posts

156 months

Tuesday 4th March 2014
quotequote all
Drive Blind said:
How you can say they are going backwards is beyond me.

The CR engine is light years ahead of the PD with regards to refinement and driveability.
If the CR engine was miles ahead why isn't it more economical? The 130 PD had great low end torque which mentioned it was great to drive

anonymous-user

85 months

Tuesday 4th March 2014
quotequote all
Well I went from a PD130 Passat daily to a Golf GT140 diesel. PD only ever did 56mpg max on a 65 mile journey, GT140 can do 62mpg.
So it's opposite for me and I don't think the Golf being smaller is the whole reason.

BTW the Golf will do better mpg at 75mph than at 56!!!

Drive Blind

5,800 posts

208 months

Tuesday 4th March 2014
quotequote all
seatdriver357 said:
Drive Blind said:
How you can say they are going backwards is beyond me.

The CR engine is light years ahead of the PD with regards to refinement and driveability.
If the CR engine was miles ahead why isn't it more economical? The 130 PD had great low end torque which mentioned it was great to drive
I've owned a PD130 and a CR140 and the economy is much the same.

I will admit the PD had a bigger torque hit at 1800rpm but either side of that 500rpm wide sweet spot it was poor. CR is alot more linear.

Like I say I've owned both and would much, much rather have the CR.

P-Jay

11,427 posts

222 months

Wednesday 5th March 2014
quotequote all
Love my Exeo, try a better spec one - no speakers in the back? try one with the Bose system, it's lovely. Ride depends on the wheels of course, I think you can go up to 19s with an Exeo, it's firm enough with 17s!

Ultimately it's a refined old shape A4 with A6 spec suspension and current gen engines - it's not 'bad' they just made it too firm, like all current VAG cars IMO. Mine doesn't seems to suffer with too much engine breaking?

Mine has got pretty much everything you could ever want, bar heated seats, but they're not an expensive option - £300 I think, and the dealer at least promises me they can be retro-fitted.

Edited by P-Jay on Wednesday 5th March 15:46