'05 A4 Avant 2.0 TFSI Suspension Upgrade
'05 A4 Avant 2.0 TFSI Suspension Upgrade
Author
Discussion

Mutt

Original Poster:

1,115 posts

222 months

Monday 3rd March 2014
quotequote all
Hello,

One of the rear springs on my A4 Avant has broken. It's a 2005 S-line 2.0 TFSI FWD in Daytona Grey. The previous owner remapped the car to circa 250 bhp. I'd like to take the opportunity to upgrade the suspension, hopefully to improve the handling and ride quality whilst retaining it's Q-car look and load carrying ability.

I've had a look around but to be honest I am clueless. Does anyone have any recommendations, either for a kit or for an outfit who will be able to help? The car was remapped at Jabbasport so I have left a message with them as a starting point.

The car is worth around £5k, so I would not want to spend much more than £800. If it's relevant, the car is on it's OEM 17" wheels.

I live in North Herts.

Thanks!

Dr G

16,012 posts

273 months

Monday 3rd March 2014
quotequote all
The multi link setup on the front of these cars is reasonably complex and they are somewhat prone to bushes going squishy without actually getting MOT fail bad. The car may well not be handling as it should even as standard.

I'd have someone that knows the cars go over the suspension very carefully looking for any wear and replacing as necessary. You can buy a kit to renew the front end without spending a fortune.

That would be my first port of call; you could add an Eibach spring kit at the same time. RS4 anti roll bar is a popular upgrade for the S4 but I don't know if these would fit onto a 2WD car.

Obviously after any work on suspension £100 on a proper camber/castor/toe alignment would be essential.

Mutt

Original Poster:

1,115 posts

222 months

Monday 3rd March 2014
quotequote all
Thanks, that's interesting. I know Audis are definitely not the last word in front-wheel drive handling, but this A4 handles OK but it has always felt like there is a mismatch between the fairly firm suspension and loose damping. The car has covered 93,000 miles so there will certainly be a lot of wear. "Squishy" would be a good word.

Any recommendations for a specialist who knows these cars? I've used main dealer for routine stuff (Hitchin Audi) as they are very close by, but don't mind limping a bit further afield for a good outfit.

blade7

11,311 posts

247 months

Monday 3rd March 2014
quotequote all
Probably not what you want to hear but I'd sell it and buy the quattro version.

Mutt

Original Poster:

1,115 posts

222 months

Monday 3rd March 2014
quotequote all
Thanks, but it doesn't really answer the question, does it? How do you expect me to sell it with broken suspension?

Anyway, that aside, if I were to sell it and replace it with another estate it would be probably be for a facelifted B8 S4. The current car was intended to be a temporary load carrier whilst we did our house up. I'm now quite attached to it so wouldn't want to replace it for a while yet anyway.

Andy JB

1,321 posts

250 months

Monday 3rd March 2014
quotequote all
I also own one of these with O/E 18" wheels and S line suspension +10% firmer on my version - it does ride firm but also handles very well for a FWD saloon.

In view of its age/value i would be looking at replacing with original o/e springs (pair) and updating bushes etc plus alignment - you are not radicalliy going to change the handling with aftermarket springs/dampers on a budget but you could improve what you have at a fraction of the cost of full suspension upgrade.

All IMO of course

blade7

11,311 posts

247 months

Tuesday 4th March 2014
quotequote all
Mutt said:
Thanks, but it doesn't really answer the question, does it? How do you expect me to sell it with broken suspension?
By buying a spring from a breaker for a few quid. I gave you an option based around your £800 budget, £20k+ on an S4 isn't really the same thing is it ?

AudiSport

1,499 posts

247 months

Tuesday 4th March 2014
quotequote all
^ This. Get your car fixed and sell it. Then buy a 2.0T Quattro and have some Revo software and RS4 bushes fitted as per Dr G's comments. Or, buy an S4.

Mutt

Original Poster:

1,115 posts

222 months

Tuesday 4th March 2014
quotequote all
OK, yes, a spring from a breakers yard would fix the car, thanks for pointing that out. My comment about an S4 was about the same relevance as your point - both are orthogonal to the question asked.

I remain slightly perplexed as to why I desperately need to sell my second car for the four-wheel drive variant, so let's go with it for a second. Why do I want to sell a perfectly good (broken spring accepted), one former keeper car for a heavier and probably slightly slower variant when all's I use this car is for going to the tip and boring motorway journeys? I have a Boxster sat in the garage for more interesting drives.

Admittedly, the suggested S4 would be 4WD but the main motivation there would be more power, nicer interior and a dual-clutch box, with all-wheel drive being a nice bonus.

Anyway, back on topic, thank you for all the comments so far: I think the suggestion of having the suspension refreshed is the most sensible. The local dealer has quoted in the region of £6-700 for just the rear springs so I am now looking for a specialist in the area.





Edited by Mutt on Tuesday 4th March 08:40

AudiSport

1,499 posts

247 months

Tuesday 4th March 2014
quotequote all
Understood, just suggestions based on experience of modifying cars from their original spec.


Mutt

Original Poster:

1,115 posts

222 months

Tuesday 4th March 2014
quotequote all
Sure, perhaps I should have been clearer that this was my second car for snotter/workhorse duties. The desire for better ride/handling stems from the fact it still has 250 bhp, so it is a quick car and it would be nice if it handled a little bit better. The suspension is now clearly rather worn, so it seemed a good time to investigate doing so for similar cost to a main dealer repair of the OEM set up.

I should have perhaps also said that I didn't set out to buy an A4 Avant. It came up for sale through a trusted channel and, whilst more than I wanted to spend at the time, it was very good value for a one-owner car that has been very well looked after. The fact it was stealth grey and packing decent power figure was definitely a bonus.

Consequently, it has rather wormed it's way into our affections hence the desire to hang on to it until makes sense to replace it and the Boxster (read: kids).

blade7

11,311 posts

247 months

Tuesday 4th March 2014
quotequote all
Mutt said:
OK, yes, a spring from a breakers yard would fix the car, thanks for pointing that out. My comment about an S4 was about the same relevance as your point - both are orthogonal to the question asked.

I remain slightly perplexed as to why I desperately need to sell my second car for the four-wheel drive variant, so let's go with it for a second. Why do I want to sell a perfectly good (broken spring accepted), one former keeper car for a heavier and probably slightly slower variant when all's I use this car is for going to the tip and boring motorway journeys?
Who said anything about being desperate ? The majority of people that have driven the FWD and 4WD car agree the quattro is a much better car. I took the time to offer you some advice based on this, ultimately it's of no consequence to me what you drive.

Mutt

Original Poster:

1,115 posts

222 months

Tuesday 4th March 2014
quotequote all
blade7 said:
Mutt said:
OK, yes, a spring from a breakers yard would fix the car, thanks for pointing that out. My comment about an S4 was about the same relevance as your point - both are orthogonal to the question asked.

I remain slightly perplexed as to why I desperately need to sell my second car for the four-wheel drive variant, so let's go with it for a second. Why do I want to sell a perfectly good (broken spring accepted), one former keeper car for a heavier and probably slightly slower variant when all's I use this car is for going to the tip and boring motorway journeys?
Who said anything about being desperate ? The majority of people that have driven the FWD and 4WD car agree the quattro is a much better car. I took the time to offer you some advice based on this, ultimately it's of no consequence to me what you drive.
In my opinion replacing a perfectly good car with another car would be a desperate thing to do.

I'm sure they agree the quattro has better traction but I am also sure they would agree that the FWD version was equally capacious.

There was clearly scope for misinterpretation in my OP. For the avoidance of doubt, I am not interested in changing the car in pursuit of improved handling, I merely want to fix the existing car having investigated the possibility of improving it.

DodgeeDave

513 posts

226 months

Tuesday 4th March 2014
quotequote all
I've recently bought a 2005 A4 2.0 TFSI and I'm really happy with it. I thought long & hard about getting a quattro but decided I'd rather have the better fuel consumption. Probably a bit un-PH!

ETA: It's also an SE version rather than S-line so even more of a Q car.

Edited by DodgeeDave on Tuesday 4th March 19:04

Andy JB

1,321 posts

250 months

Wednesday 5th March 2014
quotequote all
DodgeeDave said:
I've recently bought a 2005 A4 2.0 TFSI and I'm really happy with it. I thought long & hard about getting a quattro but decided I'd rather have the better fuel consumption. Probably a bit un-PH!

ETA: It's also an SE version rather than S-line so even more of a Q car.

Edited by DodgeeDave on Tuesday 4th March 19:04
IMO the FWD variants are more fun & lighter than the Quattro & do well to resist understeer - i have both so easier to compare. I think this was also a conclusion of the TT road tests fwd v Q4

FWIW the SE has softer dampers with higher spring rates than S line cars, so handling will be compromised to some extent. Having said that SE variants are probably better for everyday use.