Seat Leon - Are they all this bad?
Seat Leon - Are they all this bad?
Author
Discussion

BGarside

Original Poster:

1,568 posts

168 months

Tuesday 4th March 2014
quotequote all
So back in 2011 I bought a 2004 Seat leon FR TDI. Having had a diesel Focus before, I wanted another diesel but without a DPF and so I bought an older car. It had 53k miles on the clock with FSH so seemed a safe enough buy.

The car has been a pain since day 1. The list of failures includes:

Both aircon fans
Alternator clutch pulley
Passenger door lock module
Wheel paint bubbling / corrosion
Paint lacquer peeling off all over the roof, and paint fading. Looks horrendous.
Rear washer not working, never has.
Underbonnet Metal fuel pipes corroded.
Aircon needed regassing
Leaking turbo pressure pipework - worn unions
Corroded front ARB
Perished front wishbone bushes
Slipping clutch
Leaking door panel (inner panel seal)allowing water into footwell.

OK, some of these are wear and tear but in total, the car cost £6.5k, has had around £4k spent on it over the last few years and now, thanks to the peeling / faded paint, is worth maybe £1-1.5k. I can't think of any other recentish car that has suffered catastrophic paint failure within 10 years either, discounting 90s-00s Mercs perhaps.

Has anyone else experienced this sort of grief with a Leon? I had thought they were better built cars than the Ford Focus but my experiences suggest otherwise. The VW diesel engine is OK but the rest of the car seems designed to fall apart...

GurneyFlap

19 posts

167 months

Tuesday 4th March 2014
quotequote all
What colour is the car, out of interest?
The slipping clutch could have been due to the previous owner's driving style too.

BGarside

Original Poster:

1,568 posts

168 months

Tuesday 4th March 2014
quotequote all
Yellow. Apparently lacquer fade is common with this colour which gives the appearance of faded paint. My lacquer is falling off all over the roof and in some patches on other panels as well.

Clutch admittedly is a wear item and if the original lasted 53k miles it's not too bad I guess.

james_tigerwoods

16,347 posts

228 months

Tuesday 4th March 2014
quotequote all
Mine was beyond appalling - Absolutely hated it. It was my second Leon too, but my 1.9 tdi 110 was a nicer car in all aspects.

This link: http://bit.ly/1fEMKVu (pistonheads link) shows a photo and more detail too.

Sketchy service history
Ride was horrendous - think of the worst car you've seen bumping down the road - that was the Leon
Dodgy handling - Oversteer, aquaplaning
A break-in - the alarm didn't go off....
Road/Cabin noise
Off camber at the rear (Never got round to sorting that)
Not very economic - averaged 42mpg over 10,000 miles
Smoky, very smoky
Creaky front dash
Squeaky pedals
Leaky boot (Apparently)
Leak around the driver's sill
Leak in the front passenger footwell
The bonnet wasn't on quite right
Not sure where the second key went - I never got it (Got one cut though)
Sounded awful at idle/low/mid/high revs



Edited by james_tigerwoods on Tuesday 4th March 15:44

GurneyFlap

19 posts

167 months

Tuesday 4th March 2014
quotequote all
I think the solid VW colours from that era are pretty bad - I have a Tornado Red Passat which is losing clearcoat like crazy.

As for the other stuff - so much for the bargain Spanish Golf frown

james_tigerwoods

16,347 posts

228 months

Tuesday 4th March 2014
quotequote all
My Leon 1.9tdi 110 SE was a far nicer car - slower, but SO much nicer.

Saying that, when I got rid of the aforementioned POS, I got a 55 plate B6 Passat with leather which was infinitely nicer...

I understand the new owner of the Leon spent a LOT of time and effort making it work properly - even taking the dash to bits to find the rattle. Which I don't think he did - I'll try to find a link to the thread.

ETA:

http://www.seatcupra.net/forums/showthread.php?t=1...



Edited by james_tigerwoods on Tuesday 4th March 17:51

Dr G

16,012 posts

273 months

Wednesday 5th March 2014
quotequote all
A lot of cars on that platform have their share of common issues. A/S3, TT & MKIV Golf inclusive.

chris285

812 posts

163 months

Wednesday 5th March 2014
quotequote all
Right I own a 05 plate FR TDi myself, now done 77k and had very few problems with the car

to answer some of your questions:

Rear washer - common fault it's simply popped off inside the boot trim, mine has done it twice but i just don't use it
door lock - again common fault with the mk4 golf platform
aircon - yes it needs re gassing every few years the same as any car
leaking boost pipes - it's possible to happen after time as the turbo runs higher pressure than other models obviously
door seals - again a common mk4 golf platform issue

The rest of it no idea but simply no telling how well it's been looked after before you have bought it.

I've had mine since Nov 2008, it's had a remap to 200bhp and 320+llbft of torque since sep 2009 and hasn't missed a beat for me. The clutch started slipping after a while on mine for obvious reasons, but i just drove around it which is easy due to turbo lag on this engine so treated it more like a petrol and only replaced the clutch to an uprated one last year. I've also had the turbo refurbished as well last year, not a clue if the map brought it on but high pitched siren noise was the clue it was on the way out so got it sorted.

I cannot complain about my car one bit, i've thought about changing it as it's getting on and I don't do the miles and it would probably still be worth around 2.5-3k I would think. But I still love it, 200+bhp and returns 50+mpg and 60 if I am on a good run driving like miss daisy which is very good and I love the way it looks from the outside as well.

It simply sounds like you have been unlucky with your car I am afraid, happens to every make as you can't know the full history on a used car and unfortunately being a 'performance' diesel it may have been abused more and it's also going to be a bit more strung than other model's as all the diesels used the same engines so wear on some parts may occur sooner than others

BGarside

Original Poster:

1,568 posts

168 months

Wednesday 5th March 2014
quotequote all
james_tigerwoods said:
Mine was beyond appalling - Absolutely hated it. It was my second Leon too, but my 1.9 tdi 110 was a nicer car in all aspects.

This link: http://bit.ly/1fEMKVu (pistonheads link) shows a photo and more detail too.

Sketchy service history
Ride was horrendous - think of the worst car you've seen bumping down the road - that was the Leon
Dodgy handling - Oversteer, aquaplaning
A break-in - the alarm didn't go off....
Road/Cabin noise
Off camber at the rear (Never got round to sorting that)
Not very economic - averaged 42mpg over 10,000 miles
Smoky, very smoky
Creaky front dash
Squeaky pedals
Leaky boot (Apparently)
Leak around the driver's sill
Leak in the front passenger footwell
The bonnet wasn't on quite right
Not sure where the second key went - I never got it (Got one cut though)
Sounded awful at idle/low/mid/high revs



Edited by james_tigerwoods on Tuesday 4th March 15:44
Sounds like there was definitely something wrong with yours if it was oversteering with that big heavy diesel lump up-front, assuming you didn't have ditchfinders on the back. Also mine averages at least 45mpg on short trips and 52-55 on motorway journeys. Smoke and poor economy could mean a boost leak - the standard hoses tend to leak at the joints.

I wash I'd known the paint lacquer was going to fall off though, as I'm now left with a car worth maybe £1-1.5k that I've sunk over £10k into (purchase & repairs). It'd probably be worth more as an engine donor...

james_tigerwoods

16,347 posts

228 months

Wednesday 5th March 2014
quotequote all
BGarside said:
james_tigerwoods said:
Mine was beyond appalling - Absolutely hated it. It was my second Leon too, but my 1.9 tdi 110 was a nicer car in all aspects.

This link: http://bit.ly/1fEMKVu (pistonheads link) shows a photo and more detail too.

Sketchy service history
Ride was horrendous - think of the worst car you've seen bumping down the road - that was the Leon
Dodgy handling - Oversteer, aquaplaning
A break-in - the alarm didn't go off....
Road/Cabin noise
Off camber at the rear (Never got round to sorting that)
Not very economic - averaged 42mpg over 10,000 miles
Smoky, very smoky
Creaky front dash
Squeaky pedals
Leaky boot (Apparently)
Leak around the driver's sill
Leak in the front passenger footwell
The bonnet wasn't on quite right
Not sure where the second key went - I never got it (Got one cut though)
Sounded awful at idle/low/mid/high revs



Edited by james_tigerwoods on Tuesday 4th March 15:44
Sounds like there was definitely something wrong with yours if it was oversteering with that big heavy diesel lump up-front, assuming you didn't have ditchfinders on the back. Also mine averages at least 45mpg on short trips and 52-55 on motorway journeys. Smoke and poor economy could mean a boost leak - the standard hoses tend to leak at the joints.

I wash I'd known the paint lacquer was going to fall off though, as I'm now left with a car worth maybe £1-1.5k that I've sunk over £10k into (purchase & repairs). It'd probably be worth more as an engine donor...
Yeh, it was horrendous - I was lucky to not lose the farm on it really and only lost £2k (apart from cost of service and new tyres) on it in 6 months. I would have accepted a far bigger loss just to get rid of it....

I did opt for decent tyres which made no difference - The trader I bought it from didn't care and just kept saying it was still covered by Seat warranty (which it was) even though he didn't supply me with FSH details - it was only with the involvement of trading standards that I got the history and the key cut...

The trader was at fault too...