Audi S5 TFSI - ride quality with drive select
Audi S5 TFSI - ride quality with drive select
Author
Discussion

handbraketurn

Original Poster:

1,397 posts

197 months

Sunday 16th March 2014
quotequote all
Quick question to S5 owners or those with experience of driving.

Historically reviewers have complained the ride quality is very harsh in the A5 in general, particularly sport models.

I note the new models with the 3.0 TFSI unit came with electronic suspension gismo 'drive select' with dynamic and comfort modes.

If in the latter mode, can you have a relaxing drive on longer journeys or around town? I'm still finding a few people suggesting it makes little difference.

I'm trying to find something with a nice balance between comfortable cruiser and sports car, I'm happy to compromise a bit on both and have a balance. But most of the time the car will be doing motorway and around town traffic jams so the comfort element is probably more key.

Thanks in advance,

Cheers,

HBT

Dr G

16,010 posts

273 months

Sunday 16th March 2014
quotequote all
When fitted with the optional magnetic dampers a lot of the jiggle from big wheels is gone; it's never a softly sprung car but in the comfort setting you get much better isolation from broken surfaces and vibration (albeit with quite a lot of body roll).

I tend to leave it in the auto setting as I don't find them overly firm anywhere but on the crumbly rounds around me it definitely adds composure where a conventionally damped car can start to feel a shade unsettled.

handbraketurn

Original Poster:

1,397 posts

197 months

Sunday 16th March 2014
quotequote all
Thanks Dr G.

How is it on the m/way?

Dr G said:
When fitted with the optional magnetic dampers a lot of the jiggle from big wheels is gone; it's never a softly sprung car but in the comfort setting you get much better isolation from broken surfaces and vibration (albeit with quite a lot of body roll).

I tend to leave it in the auto setting as I don't find them overly firm anywhere but on the crumbly rounds around me it definitely adds composure where a conventionally damped car can start to feel a shade unsettled.

rs4al

954 posts

196 months

Sunday 16th March 2014
quotequote all
Dr G said:
When fitted with the optional magnetic dampers a lot of the jiggle from big wheels is gone; it's never a softly sprung car but in the comfort setting you get much better isolation from broken surfaces and vibration (albeit with quite a lot of body roll).

I tend to leave it in the auto setting as I don't find them overly firm anywhere but on the crumbly rounds around me it definitely adds composure where a conventionally damped car can start to feel a shade unsettled.
I'm sure the S5 has the same dampers as the S4, they are not magnetic ones, they have a variable valve in them which is controlled by the drive select setting afaik and they wear out, mine are starting to feel a bit less tight even in the dynamic setting at 63k. The auto setting is the best, comfort is a bit boaty feeling.

handbraketurn

Original Poster:

1,397 posts

197 months

Sunday 16th March 2014
quotequote all
So are the journalists making a bit of a meal out of the ride comfort?

Dr G

16,010 posts

273 months

Monday 17th March 2014
quotequote all
A lot of motoring journalists make a lot of odd assumptions and comparisons as well as having very unrealistic bases for comparison.

An A/S5 on 20s with conventional dampers gets busy on broken surfaces. Is it catastrophically bad? No. Is it improved with magnetic dampers? Yes.

I've driven an S5 on 20" wheels (Dunlop tyres) with magnetic ride from Aberdeen to Iver in one hit and had zero complaints about comfort. I had it in the auto setting the whole way.

rs4al

954 posts

196 months

Monday 17th March 2014
quotequote all
They are not magnetic dampers...

Dr G

16,010 posts

273 months

Monday 17th March 2014
quotequote all
Apologies, 'damper control'; force of habit.

handbraketurn

Original Poster:

1,397 posts

197 months

Monday 17th March 2014
quotequote all
Thanks all for the feedback, really helpful.

I'll test drive one for sure.