Golf mk6/7 diesel - which engine?
Golf mk6/7 diesel - which engine?
Author
Discussion

matt-ITR

Original Poster:

892 posts

220 months

Thursday 20th March 2014
quotequote all
I'm looking to get some real world opinions of the 1.6 105PS, 2.0 150PS and 2.0 170PS engines.
The 105 is OK, faster than I was expecting. I haven't had long in the 150 and no time in a 170.

What are the real world MPG figures like? The 105 has a claimed 75, but I would expect to get more like 50? Or less?
Is there a big drop in higher powered engines?

The 150 is only one tax bracket higher, so that seems like the best all round option?

chrisp84

409 posts

244 months

Thursday 20th March 2014
quotequote all
The 105 (in the mk6) is fine, not that quick but enough torque for comfortable motorway cruising in which it usually sits at 60mpg, but can go up a bit or down a bit depending on how far over or under 70mph you are.

It's fine around town too but not too sure what town only driving would return.

In short, it's ok, certainly won't set your motoring world alight and does get good economy.

va1o

16,118 posts

238 months

Thursday 20th March 2014
quotequote all
Problem with the 105 is it only has a 5-speed gearbox, which means in practice economy isn't that much better than the 2.0 TDI as its working harder.

matt-ITR

Original Poster:

892 posts

220 months

Thursday 20th March 2014
quotequote all
Yes, that is something that concerned me, although not that much of the time will be spent on motorways.
I've decided to rule out the 170 and the 184 is too expensive.

Hopefully I can have an extended drive in a 150 and go from there.

SteBrown91

3,168 posts

160 months

Thursday 20th March 2014
quotequote all
Ive never driven the 1.6, but I have driven a mk6 140, I own a GTD (170) and have driven a Leon 150 (new shape)

My 170. It shifts, but it does have some lag and mpg isn't the best. I struggle to get more than 47mpg.

The 140 really is the better allrounder. Its pretty quick (feels quicker than it is because turbo spins up quickly), gets good mpg and is pretty reliable.

I
The Leon 150 I drove I was bitterly disappointed with. It wsnt slow, but it just didn't feel like you were going anywhere, there was no diesel shove. In the Leon, maybe it isn't insulated as well but derv rattle was obvious in it. Of actually made me think I'd rather have the 1.4 tsi with the active cylinder tech

va1o

16,118 posts

238 months

Friday 21st March 2014
quotequote all
^ I've experienced similar. The 140 CR is by far the nicest of the recent VW diesels particularly when paired up with the excellent DSG 'box. However in the new Leon the 1.4 TSI 140 petrol seems the best suited offering very responsive performance along with good economy and a slick 6-speed manual 'box.

matt-ITR

Original Poster:

892 posts

220 months

Friday 21st March 2014
quotequote all
The 1.4 petrol might be great, but financially it does stack up because the residuals on the diesels are so much better.

dave7692

683 posts

160 months

Friday 21st March 2014
quotequote all
I get 50mpg out of my MK5 140 2.0L so I'd imagine the MPG of a newer one should be a bit better, I'd hope they've improved a bit in the 8 years since mine rolled off the factory floor.