New Golf R vs S3
Author
Discussion

Gio G

Original Poster:

2,995 posts

240 months

Thursday 27th March 2014
quotequote all
Has anyone done any back to back test with these cars? They do not seem to be put against each other for tests and I know they are practically the same car and from what I can see, roughly the same price and performance.

Still waiting to test drive a Golf R in DSG, having driven a manual. I have a 1 day test drive in the S3 in a few weeks. I think from styling perspective, the Golf seems to look more aggressive, better wheel choices and interior well laid out. S3 is maybe a little more conservative, not looked around one properly.

Is there anything obvious that I am missing to split the pair apart?

Thanks G

Actus Reus

4,312 posts

186 months

Thursday 27th March 2014
quotequote all
All of the German tests tested the R against the S3 and xdrive M135i - S3 came second in one and last in the other two. The R won all three (and was considerably quicker around the handling circuit they used for performance figures).

I've driven both, though not back to back. Audi seems less overtly sporting to me, though didn't ride any better (or, subjectively, go any worse). The cabin in the Audi is more minimal and you can spot the better class materials. It's not to all tastes though. Rear leg room and boot space slightly better I think in the Golf. The big difference is when you start to spec the cars - the standard spec in the Audi has leather, Golf doesn't, but Golf does have stuff like radar cruise and LED adaptive lights, which are expensive on the Audi. In terms of lease prices, which is what I've done, the Audi was waaaaaay more which more or less settled it.

On a test drive, with a salesman next to me, it's difficult to really separate them. On the road I suspect the Golf will be the slightly better drive, and with a moderate spec a bit cheaper when you factor the respective cars' standard options. Both are lovely motors and in terms of showroom appeal, both beat the BM I'd say - which, lovely engine aside, was a very hard sell to my wife.


Gio G

Original Poster:

2,995 posts

240 months

Thursday 27th March 2014
quotequote all
Actus Reus said:
All of the German tests tested the R against the S3 and xdrive M135i - S3 came second in one and last in the other two. The R won all three (and was considerably quicker around the handling circuit they used for performance figures).

I've driven both, though not back to back. Audi seems less overtly sporting to me, though didn't ride any better (or, subjectively, go any worse). The cabin in the Audi is more minimal and you can spot the better class materials. It's not to all tastes though. Rear leg room and boot space slightly better I think in the Golf. The big difference is when you start to spec the cars - the standard spec in the Audi has leather, Golf doesn't, but Golf does have stuff like radar cruise and LED adaptive lights, which are expensive on the Audi. In terms of lease prices, which is what I've done, the Audi was waaaaaay more which more or less settled it.

On a test drive, with a salesman next to me, it's difficult to really separate them. On the road I suspect the Golf will be the slightly better drive, and with a moderate spec a bit cheaper when you factor the respective cars' standard options. Both are lovely motors and in terms of showroom appeal, both beat the BM I'd say - which, lovely engine aside, was a very hard sell to my wife.
Thanks for the feedback AR. Shame I was not ready for those lease prices, was a bit too early for me. I will probably go down the PCP route.

AGK

1,605 posts

186 months

Thursday 27th March 2014
quotequote all
I do really like the Golf R but the S3 is also growing on me. The S3 has better residual values than the Golf so it works out cheaper over the term.

Off to see about one on Monday for my old man and I'll probably end up ordering one too.

I was in a similar position with the leasing - a little too early for me.

Actus Reus

4,312 posts

186 months

Thursday 27th March 2014
quotequote all
S3 saloon must also be worthy of consideration - though it's a good few grand more. Nice car though.

As I said, as an object the Audi just feels more subtle and grown-up and oozes the kind of appeal the wife likes. The R is more hot-hatch. I could cheerfully own either - just about I prefer the Golf I think, though I suspect my missus would go with the S3. I thus conclude that the Audi is for girls. wink

Martin_M

2,071 posts

258 months

Thursday 27th March 2014
quotequote all
I have yet to see an R in the metal but a new S3 was behind me yesterday and it looked very nice indeed. It doesn't make me want to chop in my M135i for one but I would definitely give it some consideration in a couple of years!

Edited by Martin_M on Thursday 27th March 19:38

AGK

1,605 posts

186 months

Thursday 27th March 2014
quotequote all
There's a Riviera Blue S3 on the Audi site - it looks amazing.

Actus Reus

4,312 posts

186 months

Thursday 27th March 2014
quotequote all
It's quite understated in the flesh in more subtle tones - very classy, and a very cohesive bit of design.

Martin_M

2,071 posts

258 months

Thursday 27th March 2014
quotequote all
AGK said:
There's a Riviera Blue S3 on the Audi site - it looks amazing.
Stunning...but £43k - you'd need to be mad!

http://www.audi.co.uk/used-cars/used-car-locator/a...

anonymous-user

85 months

Thursday 27th March 2014
quotequote all
I personally think that is vile.

RammyMP

7,752 posts

184 months

Thursday 27th March 2014
quotequote all
andrewparker said:
I personally think that is vile.
+1

Martin_M

2,071 posts

258 months

Thursday 27th March 2014
quotequote all
Smurf blue lol - I took a lot of abuse when I resprayed my old boxster lime green - I love all the crazy colours though!

AGK

1,605 posts

186 months

Friday 28th March 2014
quotequote all
Martin_M said:
Stunning...but £43k - you'd need to be mad!

http://www.audi.co.uk/used-cars/used-car-locator/a...
They have definitely gone wild with the options!

p1tse

1,412 posts

223 months

Friday 28th March 2014
quotequote all
the R's have been more purposefull in looks

R for me

S is just a bit bland (although owning an S of some sort at the moment LOL)

MiseryStreak

2,929 posts

238 months

Friday 28th March 2014
quotequote all
Evo just rated the Golf R as one of the best hatches of all time in their hot hatch megatest, it pipped the Mégane 265, which has long been an evo favourite.

Whereas the S3 got three and a half stars...

Quite how Audi manages to fk things up so monumentally is anyone's guess, I'm sure their engineers are paid just as much as VW's or SEAT's, if not more.

AGK

1,605 posts

186 months

Friday 28th March 2014
quotequote all
If they're based on the same chassis etc then how can they be so different? confused

snorkel sucker

2,726 posts

234 months

Friday 28th March 2014
quotequote all
RammyMP said:
+1
+2

looks like any other A3 just in a brighter (horrible) colour.

having seen the Golf R in the metal it looks much more special.

£42k is insane though for a 4 pot turbo!

Actus Reus

4,312 posts

186 months

Friday 28th March 2014
quotequote all
AGK said:
If they're based on the same chassis etc then how can they be so different? confused
Good question - and I presume down to the chassis tuning. Audi, IIRC, is heavier too, which surely can't help. As I mentioned before, on the Auto Motor und Sport test (or maybe Auto Bild, I forget), round a short-ish track there was under 0.25s between the BM M135i and the Golf R, but the S3 was 1.5s or so off the pace which they described along the lines of 'on this track, that's worlds apart'.

Martin_M

2,071 posts

258 months

Friday 28th March 2014
quotequote all
Another review here:

http://www.evo.co.uk/carreviews/evocarreviews/2916...

I thought the R had a sub 5 0-60?

Talk of a more potent version here:

http://www.autoexpress.co.uk/volkswagen/golf/86372...

Edited by Martin_M on Friday 28th March 19:04

Actus Reus

4,312 posts

186 months

Friday 28th March 2014
quotequote all
Have seen a vbox reading of 4.7 for a DSG R using launch control.