Polo 6N GTI - Gearbox Rebuild Question
Polo 6N GTI - Gearbox Rebuild Question
Author
Discussion

BeirutTaxi

Original Poster:

6,636 posts

245 months

Friday 28th March 2014
quotequote all
Hi all,

I'm tempted by a Polo GTI that has been offered to me. I have a question about the gearbox though.

It was rebuilt about 15,000 miles ago. However, is it likely to fail again after a rebuild? Or do most specialists uprate the rivets/bearings to ensure it doesn't happen again?


Many thanks,

Matt

Polome

597 posts

156 months

Monday 31st March 2014
quotequote all
Fwiw ...Had our gearbox rebuilt at 100k miles as bearings were becoming noisy . Was done by recommended local gearbox specialist but not sure if " rivets " were needed/done. After overhaul box was very quiet with a light smooth feel when changing gear . This done three years ago ( 20k done since ) and still perfect when car sold last week. Didn't expect any future problems ,if at all until another 100k at least. Regards.

BeirutTaxi

Original Poster:

6,636 posts

245 months

Monday 31st March 2014
quotequote all
Thanks for the reply smile


What do these cars drive like? Are they fun in the corners?


Also, 100k isn't too bad between rebuilds - what sort of driving style do you have? e.g. do you do trackdays, or is that car a shopping trolley?


Many thanks,


Matt

Polome

597 posts

156 months

Monday 31st March 2014
quotequote all
Had our car from new as family hack. Well used but well maintained. Not a manic driver and never tracked it( have 911 for speed) but car was always driven swiftly where possible......in quality of parts it didn't feel lacking ,even in comparison to porker. Nice engine that happily lumbers along in town without the need for continuos gear changing. It does have a nice racy feel at high revs( which you need to use to get good speed) almost Honda like. May have 125 bhp in light body but most small diesels are faster on acceleration nowadays ,handling / braking likewise. Car interior a bit cramped for 4 adults ....so been left behind a bit but still a good driving experience .Happily cruises at 90 and can still return 40 mpg ( not at same time) I think still a smart looking wee car ,simple and easy to work on , not many on roads now in original condition. We just sold ours to buy another with 100k less on clock and if blindfolded I would be hard pressed to say which car I was in...if anything the old car was faster. Good luck with search if looking...our old car would have been a good one for you but sold with first viewer .....Ian

Polome

597 posts

156 months

Monday 31st March 2014
quotequote all
In reply to driving style..just checked history file......22 tyres in 122k miles.... Ian

BeirutTaxi

Original Poster:

6,636 posts

245 months

Monday 31st March 2014
quotequote all
Ah that's useful info thanks. If you had said that you were driving like a bit of a granny with sets of tyres lasting 20k then I would wonder how the gearbox would last under harsher conditions. If you've used it properly and given the engine some revs then it gives me some confidence.

There are some stories I've heard of gearboxes lasting 20k in these cars, but I'm suspecting that this could be down to abuse. On the other hand, some people have suggested changing the gearbox oil every 6k which is quite frankly an expensive and pointless waste.

Polome

597 posts

156 months

Monday 31st March 2014
quotequote all
I agree ,changing box oil at low miles would seam pointless. Ours was changed once ,approx 50k @ six years old and the bearings were definately noisy by 100k. Can't really see how changing oil would stop rivets loosening if that was the fault . For your info our box o/ haul cost approx £ 850 including removal from car and refitting with genuine VW clutch. Ian

BeirutTaxi

Original Poster:

6,636 posts

245 months

Tuesday 1st April 2014
quotequote all
Polome said:
I agree ,changing box oil at low miles would seam pointless. Ours was changed once ,approx 50k @ six years old and the bearings were definately noisy by 100k. Can't really see how changing oil would stop rivets loosening if that was the fault . For your info our box o/ haul cost approx £ 850 including removal from car and refitting with genuine VW clutch. Ian
Thanks for your help Ian smile