Getting the best deal on a used VW
Discussion
I have looked at 2 used cars in VW dealers, both with a forecourt price of £17k and when it comes to trying to come up with a deal to buy them, and me starting at an offer of £1 under the forecourt price, both have said they brought the car for more than that, and they can only reduce the price by £200-300. Interesting both have said the cars are ones which have been single owners and have been taken in when a private owner has replaced prior to the end of a lease agreement. It all sounded very plausible the first time I hear the speech, but after hearing exactly the same thing twice it sounds like a parrot!!!
I have also seen the same car at dealers over 100 miles away priced at £1000 less, so I don't think my offer was ridiculous!
Both cars have been on forecourts for over a month and one has been there for in excess of 2 months!
Is a £1000 to much to ask off a £17k car, or am I surrounded by VW Dealers who are just expensive?
Will go and have a look at a 3rd car tomorrow, any advice on how to get the best deal?
I have also seen the same car at dealers over 100 miles away priced at £1000 less, so I don't think my offer was ridiculous!
Both cars have been on forecourts for over a month and one has been there for in excess of 2 months!
Is a £1000 to much to ask off a £17k car, or am I surrounded by VW Dealers who are just expensive?
Will go and have a look at a 3rd car tomorrow, any advice on how to get the best deal?
Most of the £1000 difference could be eroded by a set of tyres, fixing a scratch or set of discs.
Perhaps the cars you have seen are worth £1000 more?
Show the dealer the comparable car, make your offer, walk away, and if they don't come back drive to you ASAP then drive 100miles and buy the other one??
Perhaps you came across as a PITA, which they aren't keen on doing business with.
Perhaps the cars you have seen are worth £1000 more?
Show the dealer the comparable car, make your offer, walk away, and if they don't come back drive to you ASAP then drive 100miles and buy the other one??
Perhaps you came across as a PITA, which they aren't keen on doing business with.
Thanks for you very valuable and highly informative response! I will indeed check out prices of tyres and scratches and discs to make sure the cars are all comparable as being a member of this forum clearly means I have no idea about such things, and will hopefully ensure I am a valuable customer of VW dealers in the future and pay them a premium to avoid being a pita! Once again thanks for your input!
£1k off a £17k retail car should be do-able, unless its already the cheapest of its kind (which you've said its not). You'd expect that they'd have paid about £14 - £15k buying it in from the trade.
Easiest option is just to go and buy the one that's 100 miles away. Isn't really that far too go IMO, I've travelled further for a car before!
Easiest option is just to go and buy the one that's 100 miles away. Isn't really that far too go IMO, I've travelled further for a car before!
I would go and buy the one 100 miles away if the purchase is driven on price.
As you've said, they're over 30 days old so will have been reduced in price, although they may have some movement. As they have stated, £200-£300.
And FYI, just because a car is £1000 cheaper elsewhere, that has no relevance to how much this are being sold for. That dealer 100 miles away may have bought the car in for a cheaper price, and thus can sell it for less; these 2 other cars probably owe the dealer more money.
As you've said, they're over 30 days old so will have been reduced in price, although they may have some movement. As they have stated, £200-£300.
And FYI, just because a car is £1000 cheaper elsewhere, that has no relevance to how much this are being sold for. That dealer 100 miles away may have bought the car in for a cheaper price, and thus can sell it for less; these 2 other cars probably owe the dealer more money.
islander said:
Thanks for you very valuable and highly informative response! I will indeed check out prices of tyres and scratches and discs to make sure the cars are all comparable as being a member of this forum clearly means I have no idea about such things, and will hopefully ensure I am a valuable customer of VW dealers in the future and pay them a premium to avoid being a pita! Once again thanks for your input!
How old are you? 12?I think that if the local dealers will not negotiate to your satisfaction then I'd deal with those more distant dealers who are £1000 cheaper, particularly if they are main dealers and the cars are of the same model/spec that you've driven locally. Distance selling regulations should apply and protect you.
Me and my family have successfully bought four vehicles this way with no regrets.
Me and my family have successfully bought four vehicles this way with no regrets.
Margins on 'normal' cars are very, very skinny; a lot of main dealers rely on finance and extras to make any money at all.
If what you want is already available at a price you're prepared to pay go and grab it. It's at a VW main dealer so as long as the car is as described you can have any warranty issues resolved locally.
If what you want is already available at a price you're prepared to pay go and grab it. It's at a VW main dealer so as long as the car is as described you can have any warranty issues resolved locally.
There is a strange belief that the higher the price of a used car then there is more margin, this isn't always the case, I have cars for sale at £7000 and cars for sale for £15,000, the margins tend to be very similar, hell depending on how a car was purchased the lower priced car may have a higher margin.
The dealer is offering you £300 off, if you aren't happy with that then move on and buy the car that is 100 miles away however if you buy on price alone then don't come on her moaning about poor service if there is a problem, sure your local dealer may be able to help you if there is an issue however they won't bend over backwards to do so and the dealer 100 miles away may want the car that you purchased back with them if there is an issue, also these cheaper cars are most likely that much cheaper for a reason.
Regarding distance selling regs, as mentioned, they are only applicable if you have never set foot in the showroom; go up and see the car which is 100 miles away, which is really not that far away, purchase it over the phone after you have decided it is the car for you if you haven't made the decision there and then in person then DSR doesn't apply.
The dealer is offering you £300 off, if you aren't happy with that then move on and buy the car that is 100 miles away however if you buy on price alone then don't come on her moaning about poor service if there is a problem, sure your local dealer may be able to help you if there is an issue however they won't bend over backwards to do so and the dealer 100 miles away may want the car that you purchased back with them if there is an issue, also these cheaper cars are most likely that much cheaper for a reason.
Regarding distance selling regs, as mentioned, they are only applicable if you have never set foot in the showroom; go up and see the car which is 100 miles away, which is really not that far away, purchase it over the phone after you have decided it is the car for you if you haven't made the decision there and then in person then DSR doesn't apply.
I doubt very much that the dealers have only £300 wiggle room. If that's the case then they're s
t at negotiating deals on part-ex.
Bear in mind that we're talking main dealers here, not some side of the road outfit.
They beat you down when buying yours and f
k you over when selling. Someone has to pay for those big shiny showrooms after all.
I'm not blaming them for this btw, it's a business. But if you could buy a car privately for 16k, then in my experience, dealers will buy at about 1.5k less and try and sell at 1.5k more.
t at negotiating deals on part-ex. Bear in mind that we're talking main dealers here, not some side of the road outfit.
They beat you down when buying yours and f
k you over when selling. Someone has to pay for those big shiny showrooms after all.I'm not blaming them for this btw, it's a business. But if you could buy a car privately for 16k, then in my experience, dealers will buy at about 1.5k less and try and sell at 1.5k more.
Edited by Kell on Thursday 8th May 14:53
Kell said:
I doubt very much that the dealers have only £300 wiggle room. If that's the case then they're s
t at negotiating deals on part-ex.
Bear in mind that we're talking main dealers here, not some side of the road outfit.
They beat you down when buying yours and f
k you over when selling. Someone has to pay for those big shiny showrooms after all.
I'm not blaming them for this btw, it's a business. But if you could buy a car privately for 16k, then in my experience, dealers will buy at about 1.5k less and try and sell at 1.5k more.
Couldn't be more wrong.
t at negotiating deals on part-ex. Bear in mind that we're talking main dealers here, not some side of the road outfit.
They beat you down when buying yours and f
k you over when selling. Someone has to pay for those big shiny showrooms after all.I'm not blaming them for this btw, it's a business. But if you could buy a car privately for 16k, then in my experience, dealers will buy at about 1.5k less and try and sell at 1.5k more.
Obviously they will try and max out profit, but if a car has been in stock for a while, it will be sold at what it costs the dealership so there genuinely might be no wiggle room. If a car has only been in stock 2 days, clearly there will be more money it, and more wiggle room
And FYI, most shinny new dealerships are subsidised from the Manufacture at usually around a minimum of 75%.
There is a new BMW being built in Reading for £23 million; the dealer group is only paying around £2 million of that, if that.
Edited by Phil117 on Thursday 8th May 21:43
Is there an index of dealers who are regular, long-standing contributors to this forum?! I dunno whether it's 'the done thing' on PH as I'm still a noob here? The question is prompted by what appears to be the Holy Grail-like qualities of the elusive 'trustworthy' car dealer?
Apologies to OP if this constitutes a hijacking of the thread - it seemed at least somewhat germaine to me... My sense after 2 months of car hunting is that at least 70% of car dealers should not be trusted to confirm that rain is wet, let alone what they claim about the vehicles they sell!
Apologies to OP if this constitutes a hijacking of the thread - it seemed at least somewhat germaine to me... My sense after 2 months of car hunting is that at least 70% of car dealers should not be trusted to confirm that rain is wet, let alone what they claim about the vehicles they sell!
islander said:
Thanks for you very valuable and highly informative response! I will indeed check out prices of tyres and scratches and discs to make sure the cars are all comparable as being a member of this forum clearly means I have no idea about such things, and will hopefully ensure I am a valuable customer of VW dealers in the future and pay them a premium to avoid being a pita! Once again thanks for your input!
Starting to see why they havent really been bothered to negotiate with you....islander said:
I have looked at 2 used cars in VW dealers, both with a forecourt price of £17k and when it comes to trying to come up with a deal to buy them, and me starting at an offer of £1 under the forecourt price, both have said they brought the car for more than that, and they can only reduce the price by £200-300. Interesting both have said the cars are ones which have been single owners and have been taken in when a private owner has replaced prior to the end of a lease agreement. It all sounded very plausible the first time I hear the speech, but after hearing exactly the same thing twice it sounds like a parrot!!!
I have also seen the same car at dealers over 100 miles away priced at £1000 less, so I don't think my offer was ridiculous!
Both cars have been on forecourts for over a month and one has been there for in excess of 2 months!
Is a £1000 to much to ask off a £17k car, or am I surrounded by VW Dealers who are just expensive?
Will go and have a look at a 3rd car tomorrow, any advice on how to get the best deal?
Was the other car from a main VW dealer or an indy?I have also seen the same car at dealers over 100 miles away priced at £1000 less, so I don't think my offer was ridiculous!
Both cars have been on forecourts for over a month and one has been there for in excess of 2 months!
Is a £1000 to much to ask off a £17k car, or am I surrounded by VW Dealers who are just expensive?
Will go and have a look at a 3rd car tomorrow, any advice on how to get the best deal?
Were you getting a full years warranty with the cheaper car?
Dealers tend not to get too hung up on getting "rid" of the car until its been there 3 months. They are running a business so its in their interests to get as close to asking price as possible, bearing in mind their final net profit is only going to be £500-1000 anyway, they're not going to give away a huge chunk of that if they dont have to.
Also, it used to be dealers put up full retail prices, allowing an extra grand in the price for discount or trade in allowance and they simply knocked that off as your "discount" so you thought you were getting a deal. These days people are more price focused so they tend to have close to their best price on the screen already.
If you can get it cheap enough elsewhere to warrant the journey to view / question mark over how you get it back to them when something goes wrong AND its a direct comparison like for like in terms of miles / condition / warranty then i'd say go for it, however i dont think you can hold it against your local dealer for not accepting an offer that falls below what they want to sell the car for.
Kell said:
I doubt very much that the dealers have only £300 wiggle room. If that's the case then they're s
t at negotiating deals on part-ex.
Bear in mind that we're talking main dealers here, not some side of the road outfit.
They beat you down when buying yours and f
k you over when selling. Someone has to pay for those big shiny showrooms after all.
I'm not blaming them for this btw, it's a business. But if you could buy a car privately for 16k, then in my experience, dealers will buy at about 1.5k less and try and sell at 1.5k more.
Why give away profit when you dont have to? If the car stands them £16,000 after they've factored in reparatory work, overheads, warranty, VAT, etc, why would they possibly want to give away all of their net profit for no good reason?
t at negotiating deals on part-ex. Bear in mind that we're talking main dealers here, not some side of the road outfit.
They beat you down when buying yours and f
k you over when selling. Someone has to pay for those big shiny showrooms after all.I'm not blaming them for this btw, it's a business. But if you could buy a car privately for 16k, then in my experience, dealers will buy at about 1.5k less and try and sell at 1.5k more.
Edited by Kell on Thursday 8th May 14:53
If a business is not making money then it wont be in business long.
There is a commonly held belief that a dealer *has* to sell you a car at your price as theres "so few customers out there". This is a myth. It is harder to find good stock than find good customers. If a dealer has went to the trouble of stocking say, a good well spec'd Golf diesel, why give it away to someone just because they "think" they're entitled to £1000 off?
Kell said:
I'm not blaming them for this btw, it's a business. But if you could buy a car privately for 16k, then in my experience, dealers will buy at about 1.5k less and try and sell at 1.5k more.
Just homing in on this. You're probably not that far wrong with this, however its worth bearing in mind for that £14.5K purchase they have to service it, valet it, perhaps a couple of tyres, a couple of SMART repairs, pay towards their overheads (house charge), pay the salesmans commission, advertising, VAT (which on a £3K gross margin will take £500 alone), pay for a warranty AND on top of that make some profit. So their £14.5K purchase might stand them £16,000. On top of that, whilst they might "like" to £17495 it, to get the phone to ring they maybe have to £16,995 it. So its not hard to see why a dealer isnt getting exciting about knocking ££££'s off what is already a very narrow marginSnowyQuattro said:
Is there an index of dealers who are regular, long-standing contributors to this forum?! I dunno whether it's 'the done thing' on PH as I'm still a noob here? The question is prompted by what appears to be the Holy Grail-like qualities of the elusive 'trustworthy' car dealer?
Apologies to OP if this constitutes a hijacking of the thread - it seemed at least somewhat germaine to me... My sense after 2 months of car hunting is that at least 70% of car dealers should not be trusted to confirm that rain is wet, let alone what they claim about the vehicles they sell!
One thing i would say is statistically you are more likely to get a better car that the dealer WILL stand over if you use a franchised dealer. Typically the smaller the trader the less chance you have of getting a quality car with a comprehensive warranty. There are clearly exceptions to this and its only a broad rule of thumb.Apologies to OP if this constitutes a hijacking of the thread - it seemed at least somewhat germaine to me... My sense after 2 months of car hunting is that at least 70% of car dealers should not be trusted to confirm that rain is wet, let alone what they claim about the vehicles they sell!
Personally, when i was buying a year old golf last year i found the following :-
(a) the franchised dealers were little or no more expensive than the indies / supermarkets
(b) the franchised dealers cars were of a higher quality - less scuffs, less miles
(c) there wasnt a massive amount of discount to be had - i got the car down from £12995 to £12495 instantly, but could only get another £100 off, though they did throw in mats and flaps.
(d) the franchised dealers were better set up to deal with problems
My brother found the same when buying a year old SEAT Leon diesel - the only diffentiator between the main dealer and the local indy with the same car was the colour of the cars, so it came down to a choice on colour rather than on price.
The older the car you are looking at i guess the less the above is likely to apply.
Gassing Station | Audi, Seat, Skoda & VW | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


