Audi Q5 2.0D: needs a new engine
Audi Q5 2.0D: needs a new engine
Author
Discussion

Cider Andy

Original Poster:

1,889 posts

256 months

Sunday 11th May 2014
quotequote all
Now, please bear with me as all the details are secondhand to me (and some thirdhand), but here's a little story.

My mate has a 2010 Q5 which died while idling in roadworks on the motorway. Symptoms were an awful rattle appeared whilst stationary, he pulled into the coned area of the roadworks and the engine stopped. It wouldn't restart and the rattle was evident during cranking.

So, the car was recovered to his local franchised dealer. He's been told the auxiliary belt tensioner has collapsed which, in turn, shredded the auxiliary belt. The shredded belt then got caught up in the cambelt which also shredded. I don't know this particular engine: first of all, is this feasible?

They have gone on to say the engine is beyond repair. I'm very dubious about this but again, I don't know this engine. But I was thinking the most likely damage would be snapped cam followers or bent valves. I suppose if it was more extreme, a wrecked cylinder head or holed pistons?

My feeling is he's being ripped off but maybe I'm being too cynical? Is it possible the engine really is wrecked beyond repair?

blueg33

46,949 posts

255 months

Sunday 11th May 2014
quotequote all
With Audi main dealer labour rates it could be un-economical to repair.

The car must only be a max of 12 months out of warranty, I would be on the phone to Audi customer service

gizlaroc

17,251 posts

255 months

Sunday 11th May 2014
quotequote all
And don't Audi recommened 4 years or 80,000 miles before changing all these belts? Has the car reached that yet?
If not I would definitely be claiming.

Cider Andy

Original Poster:

1,889 posts

256 months

Sunday 11th May 2014
quotequote all
It's a company car, he's had it from new, it's done 140,000 miles and has always been serviced by the same dealer. Basically it's wanted for nothing. The company has already agreed to let the dealer go ahead and replace the engine but I'm urging him to retain the engine and faulty ancillary parts to have it independently inspected and assessed. I just have a feeling it could be repaired for far less than the cost of fitting a new motor, and that really the worst it could need is a new cylinder head, if not just a few cam followers and/or valves.

RammyMP

7,750 posts

184 months

Sunday 11th May 2014
quotequote all
If it's a company car why worry?

va1o

16,118 posts

238 months

Sunday 11th May 2014
quotequote all
RammyMP said:
If it's a company car why worry?
I'm inclined to agree with this, wouldn't worry unles he is personally footing the bill. The 2.0 TDI CR is usually quite a solid engine but 140k is very high mileage, not many others will have done so many miles.

Sheepshanks

41,371 posts

150 months

Sunday 11th May 2014
quotequote all
RammyMP said:
If it's a company car why worry?
Exactly. A big part of having a company car is that you don't have to worry about it - to worry on behalf of someone else's company is getting close to insanity.

The company took a chance by running the car up to 140k miles instead of leasing for 3yr/90k like everyone else does. But they're still probably quids in, even after buying a new engine. The company is probably, rightly, more focused on its own business than concerning itself over cars.

y2blade

56,322 posts

246 months

Sunday 11th May 2014
quotequote all
va1o said:
RammyMP said:
If it's a company car why worry?
I'm inclined to agree with this, wouldn't worry unles he is personally footing the bill. The 2.0 TDI CR is usually quite a solid engine but 140k is very high mileage, not many others will have done so many miles.
+1 for why worry, it is a company car!


140k "very high mileage"....you have gotta love PH at times hehe

Cider Andy

Original Poster:

1,889 posts

256 months

Sunday 11th May 2014
quotequote all
RammyMP said:
If it's a company car why worry?
My suspicion is based on a feeling the dealer will have the same attitude towards it as you! Every customer, private or corporate, should be treated the same.

HumbleJim

29,101 posts

214 months

Sunday 11th May 2014
quotequote all
Cider Andy said:
RammyMP said:
If it's a company car why worry?
My suspicion is based on a feeling the dealer will have the same attitude towards it as you! Every customer, private or corporate, should be treated the same.
Good point, I would carry out a mystery shop just to be on the safe side.

nerd

Sheepshanks

41,371 posts

150 months

Sunday 11th May 2014
quotequote all
Cider Andy said:
My suspicion is based on a feeling the dealer will have the same attitude towards it as you! Every customer, private or corporate, should be treated the same.
I'd prefer it that they ripped everyone else off so they can afford to give me a discount. wink

va1o

16,118 posts

238 months

Sunday 11th May 2014
quotequote all
y2blade said:
140k "very high mileage"....you have gotta love PH at times hehe
laugh I take that back but it's certainly on the high side for a 2010, that's an average of over 35k per year. What I was getting is given the 2.0 TDI CR is still a relatively new engine it's somewhat unknown how they cope with with that level of mileage. Might be they all start going pop at 140k in a few years time!

Dr G

16,007 posts

273 months

Monday 12th May 2014
quotequote all
I have seen a couple of aux belt tensioners go on 3.0 TDIs lately although they haven't failed in quite such a spectacular manner.

Any idea if this belt has been changed?

Audi almost always quote replacement engines for internal issues like this. It's the best 'fit and forget' approach; you don't want to get 10 hours deep into a problem (well over a grand of labour) to find a bent rod or damaged bore.

The new engine will be on an exchange basis from Audi so keeping the old one will be expensive.

vanordinaire

3,701 posts

193 months

Monday 12th May 2014
quotequote all
[quote=Dr G]Audi almost always quote replacement engines for internal issues like this. It's the best 'fit and forget' approach; you don't want to get 10 hours deep into a problem (well over a grand of labour) to find a bent rod or damaged bore.

quote]

This, I rebuilt the top end of my 1.9 tdi Passat engine (holed piston, bent valve, knackered camshaft etc) only to find a crankshaft bearing was knackered too the first time I put it under load. Cut my losses, fitted a replacement engine and sold off the refurbished top end and the bottom end fro spares.

Cider Andy

Original Poster:

1,889 posts

256 months

Monday 12th May 2014
quotequote all
Dr G said:
...Any idea if this belt has been changed?
I can't say for certain, except that if it was a service item within the 140,000 miles the car's done then it would have been.

Dr G said:
Audi almost always quote replacement engines for internal issues like this. It's the best 'fit and forget' approach...The new engine will be on an exchange basis from Audi so keeping the old one will be expensive.
Wow! I'm a bit old-fashioned for these throwaway times! I suppose that explains their approach.

One of the things I was trying to find out is whether their explanation of the demise of the engine is feasible (my not knowing this particular engine)?

mnkiboy

4,409 posts

197 months

Monday 12th May 2014
quotequote all
Cider Andy said:
One of the things I was trying to find out is whether their explanation of the demise of the engine is feasible (my not knowing this particular engine)?
I'm not familiar with this particular model, but it is known to happen on other makes. Exactly as you described - the belt tensioner fails, aux belt gets ripped apart and the flailing pieces get tangled up with the cambelt.

Kell

1,708 posts

239 months

Tuesday 13th May 2014
quotequote all
Its no surprise that modern dealers would rather fit something new than attempt a repair.

I was quoted £3,700 from BMW because I had a faulty connector on my old 5-series.

Rather than snip it off and solder a new one in place, they wanted me to buy a whole new wiring loom, then agree to the 20+ hours of labour involved in stripping out the entire interior, reaplacing full loom and replacing the lot.

I took it to an indy and got it done for about £200.

But as it's a company car... just let them get on with it.

Dr G

16,007 posts

273 months

Tuesday 13th May 2014
quotequote all
When you're charging £140/hour, pay your staff on time efficiency and already have two week lead times for routine work you take the simplest and most direct option.

An independent can often save a lot of cash on these as their costs and priorities can be quite markedly different.

Cider Andy

Original Poster:

1,889 posts

256 months

Tuesday 13th May 2014
quotequote all
The price of the repair is over £7500 and it's been accepted, it's going ahead. As it's probably an exchange engine (and I don't know whether or not it is) it's interesting that they didn't offer a reconditioned engine, given the mileage on (and therefore the market value of) the car.

Kell

1,708 posts

239 months

Wednesday 14th May 2014
quotequote all
Cider Andy said:
The price of the repair is over £7500 and it's been accepted, it's going ahead. As it's probably an exchange engine (and I don't know whether or not it is) it's interesting that they didn't offer a reconditioned engine, given the mileage on (and therefore the market value of) the car.
I'm still surprised that there's no goodwill from Audi. A car that's four yuears' old and has had every service in the book ticked, should not have an engine failure - even if it's got more than average miles.