thoughts on buying a 2nd hand golf GTI mk5
thoughts on buying a 2nd hand golf GTI mk5
Author
Discussion

pjfamilyguy1

Original Poster:

785 posts

163 months

Wednesday 14th May 2014
quotequote all
Hi all,

As the title states, I'm looking to buy a 2nd hand Golf GTI mk5, manual 5dr with the 17" monza's, I'm not too fussed about the leather as the tartan is pretty cool IMHO.

I'm thinking between an 05-07 plate with 60-70miles on the clock, from searching around there are cheaper ones around but with 110,000 + miles on the clock, so these could be an option depending on how strong the engine etc is. Would a warranty be a sensible purchase if I went for a 60,000 or 100,000 car ?

I'm no speed demon, I don't want it to be perfect and I want a standard one which I probably won't mod (famous last words). I also don't do that many miles a year (less than 7,000)

I would like thoughts on any pending maintenance or experience of a car this age/mileage and what to look out for. I've googled golf forums but not yet found a decent buying guide.

All helpful buying/running suggestions welcome.

idge

104 posts

196 months

Wednesday 14th May 2014
quotequote all
Wow, this comes up pretty often!

Rust on the front wings (which may or may not be covered by the warranty) and the air-con compressor are weak points. Both would be big bills to foot out of warranty.

They were the only problems I had with mine over two and a bit years.

I had the DSG, with 17s, which I really liked for commuting. Was a great car.

BlindandLost

216 posts

181 months

Wednesday 14th May 2014
quotequote all
pjfamilyguy1 said:
Hi all,

As the title states, I'm looking to buy a 2nd hand Golf GTI mk5, manual 5dr with the 17" monza's, I'm not too fussed about the leather as the tartan is pretty cool IMHO.

I'm thinking between an 05-07 plate with 60-70miles on the clock, from searching around there are cheaper ones around but with 110,000 + miles on the clock, so these could be an option depending on how strong the engine etc is. Would a warranty be a sensible purchase if I went for a 60,000 or 100,000 car ?

I'm no speed demon, I don't want it to be perfect and I want a standard one which I probably won't mod (famous last words). I also don't do that many miles a year (less than 7,000)

I would like thoughts on any pending maintenance or experience of a car this age/mileage and what to look out for. I've googled golf forums but not yet found a decent buying guide.

All helpful buying/running suggestions welcome.
Hi! I bought a 57 plate DSG last year with 55,000 on the clock. Not exactly the same as what you're after, but I'll share some of the things I looked out for when I bought mine and my experience so far...

For a 2007 with 60k - 70k miles, the cam belt and water pump should have been changed. Since the schedule is every 4 years or 40k miles, a 100k + car should have had it done at least twice. If you do consider DSG, the service interval is every 40k miles for an oil and filter change. I'm not 100% sure if that's 4 years as well as I do more than 10k miles a year so it won't make 4 years before it needs doing again tongue out. The VW dealer I took it too for its last service also said that spark plugs need replacing every 60k miles as well, which wasn't cheap! I moved mine from long-life servicing (20k or 2 years) to yearly as I prefer to get the oil and filter change yearly but the dealer said they use the long life oil regardless of what schedule it's on.

After doing a lot of research about the engine, I didn't see any major common problems with the engine reported. As mentioned before, the air conditioning compressor is a known weak point and is expensive to replace. Luckily (!) for me, mine got replaced along with quite a large bit of the front end of the car when someone turned right out of a side road right in front of me a little while back... Other than routine maintenance and 2 new tyres (about £125 each for Goodyear Eagle F1 AS2s for 18" wheels), the car hasn't cost me anything. I must admit the 18" wheels can be a bit crashy on dodgy surfaces, but it's not too bad and the ride is brilliant on a decent road.

I've really enjoyed the car in the last 15 months or so. I'm only averaging 31mpg with mostly A or B road driving, but I enjoy my trip to and from work every day! I don't know how well the manual's fuel economy compares with the DSG though...

Sorry for rambling a bit, but I hope that answers a few questions smile.

ManOpener

12,467 posts

200 months

Wednesday 14th May 2014
quotequote all
Common issues:

Front wing rust- VW offer goodwill AFAIK.
A/C compressor- if it's seized, budget £500 for replacement incl. fitting.
Diverter vale- sounds like a boost leak, might trigger CEL. £35 for a new piston type one, plus an hour to fit if you don't have ramps.
PCV- poor MPG, rough on cold starts. Part is about £30 from VW, easy to fit.
Carbon buildup on valves- only really a problem if it has done lots of short journeys or been run with the wrong grade oil.
Cambelts every 60k/5 years.
Sensitive to rear tyres and alignment, if it's loud and the rear tramines it's probably this.
Make sure the coilpack replacement warranty work was done. Can still be done FOC AFAIK.

5-door manual in dark blue or red with leather, xenons and 17"s is basically perfect spec for me, but it's quiet a subjective thing.

va1o

16,118 posts

238 months

Wednesday 14th May 2014
quotequote all
Mines just hit 97k miles last week and still in top form. It's a 5dr DSG with 17s and cloth seats. I looked at some with leather and 18s but found they appeared more worn. I've added cruise control and sat nav along with mk6 chrome interior switches to update it inside a bit.

It's had a bit of work done on it in the past 6 months including the PCV, cambelt, DSG oil change and most recently the AC compressor. One of the arches is starting to bubble slightly so that's next on my to do list.

On the whole I like it a lot and find it to be an excellent all rounder, would reccomend for sure thumbup

the-photographer

5,209 posts

207 months

Thursday 15th May 2014
quotequote all
ManOpener said:
Common issues:

Front wing rust- VW offer goodwill AFAIK.
A/C compressor- if it's seized, budget £500 for replacement incl. fitting.
Diverter vale- sounds like a boost leak, might trigger CEL. £35 for a new piston type one, plus an hour to fit if you don't have ramps.
PCV- poor MPG, rough on cold starts. Part is about £30 from VW, easy to fit.
Carbon buildup on valves- only really a problem if it has done lots of short journeys or been run with the wrong grade oil.
Cambelts every 60k/5 years.
Sensitive to rear tyres and alignment, if it's loud and the rear tramines it's probably this.
Make sure the coilpack replacement warranty work was done. Can still be done FOC AFAIK.

5-door manual in dark blue or red with leather, xenons and 17"s is basically perfect spec for me, but it's quiet a subjective thing.
All agreed, compressor replacement AT THE DEALER will be nearer to £800 and £1000 if you just say yes. You'll need a dryer unit if the compressor exploded.

the-photographer

5,209 posts

207 months

Thursday 15th May 2014
quotequote all
BlindandLost said:
pjfamilyguy1 said:
Hi all,

As the title states, I'm looking to buy a 2nd hand Golf GTI mk5, manual 5dr with the 17" monza's, I'm not too fussed about the leather as the tartan is pretty cool IMHO.

I'm thinking between an 05-07 plate with 60-70miles on the clock, from searching around there are cheaper ones around but with 110,000 + miles on the clock, so these could be an option depending on how strong the engine etc is. Would a warranty be a sensible purchase if I went for a 60,000 or 100,000 car ?

I'm no speed demon, I don't want it to be perfect and I want a standard one which I probably won't mod (famous last words). I also don't do that many miles a year (less than 7,000)

I would like thoughts on any pending maintenance or experience of a car this age/mileage and what to look out for. I've googled golf forums but not yet found a decent buying guide.

All helpful buying/running suggestions welcome.
For a 2007 with 60k - 70k miles, the cam belt and water pump should have been changed. Since the schedule is every 4 years or 40k miles, a 100k + car should have had it done at least twice. If you do consider DSG, the service interval is every 40k miles for an oil and filter change. I'm not 100% sure if that's 4 years as well as I do more than 10k miles a year so it won't make 4 years before it needs doing again tongue out. The VW dealer I took it too for its last service also said that spark plugs need replacing every 60k miles as well, which wasn't cheap! I moved mine from long-life servicing (20k or 2 years) to yearly as I prefer to get the oil and filter change yearly but the dealer said they use the long life oil regardless of what schedule it's on.
You get spark plugs with a fixed price major service (£299 I think)

http://www.sinclairvolkswagen.co.uk/aftersales/fix...

Major Service includes:

Oil & filter change
Replace pollen filter
Wash and vacuum
Replace air filter
Spark plugs (petrol engine) or fuel filter (diesel engine)
Remove wheels and check brakes
Check/adjust tension on all drive belts
Check gearbox oil level
Check final drive oil level
Full vehicle road test
Diagnostic check
Re-set service interval display
Volkswagen stamp in service book
Price includes parts, oil, labour and VAT (20%)


BlindandLost

216 posts

181 months

Thursday 15th May 2014
quotequote all
the-photographer said:
You get spark plugs with a fixed price major service (£299 I think)

http://www.sinclairvolkswagen.co.uk/aftersales/fix...

Major Service includes:

Oil & filter change
Replace pollen filter
Wash and vacuum
Replace air filter
Spark plugs (petrol engine) or fuel filter (diesel engine)
Remove wheels and check brakes
Check/adjust tension on all drive belts
Check gearbox oil level
Check final drive oil level
Full vehicle road test
Diagnostic check
Re-set service interval display
Volkswagen stamp in service book
Price includes parts, oil, labour and VAT (20%)
That's most upsetting as I had a major service when I moved onto the yearly schedule. I'm going to do a bit of digging... Cheers for the heads up smile

the-photographer

5,209 posts

207 months

Thursday 15th May 2014
quotequote all
Fixed price is pretty competitive

gashead1105

626 posts

184 months

Thursday 15th May 2014
quotequote all
I've just bought an edition 30 (off here).

It's lovely but I'd echo all of the above. Especially the air conditioning as I've just been stung for a bill of over a grand - there was a whistle coming from the engine bay, which as narrowed down to the bearing in the compressor failing. It's a very common fault which causes swarf in the air conditioning system. The only cure is a new compressor, new condenser and a full system flush and re-gas. I spoke to the local specialist and he wasn't really interested in sorting it out, so had to have it done by the dealer. A 2 year warranty is small consolation.

Car's still great even so.

the-photographer

5,209 posts

207 months

Thursday 15th May 2014
quotequote all
gashead1105 said:
I've just bought an edition 30 (off here).

It's lovely but I'd echo all of the above. Especially the air conditioning as I've just been stung for a bill of over a grand - there was a whistle coming from the engine bay, which as narrowed down to the bearing in the compressor failing. It's a very common fault which causes swarf in the air conditioning system. The only cure is a new compressor, new condenser and a full system flush and re-gas. I spoke to the local specialist and he wasn't really interested in sorting it out, so had to have it done by the dealer. A 2 year warranty is small consolation.

Car's still great even so.
The Sanden unit they fitted should last the lifetime of the car (assuming its always "gassed").

You can ask for goodwill from the factory, the dealer SHOULD contact the factory, who will say NO (too old) but still offer 10%.

The dealer should then add 10%, so I managed £200 off the original £1000 bill.

va1o

16,118 posts

238 months

Thursday 15th May 2014
quotequote all
It is quite a frustration problem given they all seem to be affected by this and it's so expensive to fix relative to the cars value for a 'comfort' feature. VW UK pissed me off when I rang them up complaining about it and denied been aware of it as a common issue. That along with the front wings corrosion and ESP pump failure are the major Mk5 annoyances.

pjfamilyguy1

Original Poster:

785 posts

163 months

Thursday 15th May 2014
quotequote all
Thanks guys, this is really helpful, I have been starting to think about an Octavia Vrs, which is a bigger car, but guess would be affected by some of the similar issues mentioned above.


gashead1105

626 posts

184 months

Thursday 15th May 2014
quotequote all
the-photographer said:
gashead1105 said:
I've just bought an edition 30 (off here).

It's lovely but I'd echo all of the above. Especially the air conditioning as I've just been stung for a bill of over a grand - there was a whistle coming from the engine bay, which as narrowed down to the bearing in the compressor failing. It's a very common fault which causes swarf in the air conditioning system. The only cure is a new compressor, new condenser and a full system flush and re-gas. I spoke to the local specialist and he wasn't really interested in sorting it out, so had to have it done by the dealer. A 2 year warranty is small consolation.

Car's still great even so.
The Sanden unit they fitted should last the lifetime of the car (assuming its always "gassed").

You can ask for goodwill from the factory, the dealer SHOULD contact the factory, who will say NO (too old) but still offer 10%.

The dealer should then add 10%, so I managed £200 off the original £1000 bill.
Thanks. I asked for goodwill but they said they had discounted it down as far as possible. The car doesn't have full VW SH (the person I bought it from used a specialist). My understanding is that the compressor on 2006-7 cars (which mine is) fails and its only once they replace it with a Sanden unit that the issue goes away - which hopefully it now will have done.

gashead1105

626 posts

184 months

Thursday 15th May 2014
quotequote all
pjfamilyguy1 said:
Thanks guys, this is really helpful, I have been starting to think about an Octavia Vrs, which is a bigger car, but guess would be affected by some of the similar issues mentioned above.
There's a separate very common fault on the air conditioning pumps on Skodas of this vintage (according to the VW dealer when I tried quoting a couple of VW tech bulletins at him).

anonymous-user

85 months

Thursday 15th May 2014
quotequote all
My compressor failed 2-months outside my warranty and VW replaced the part for free and contributed 50% towards the labour. I was very surprised.

the-photographer

5,209 posts

207 months

Friday 16th May 2014
quotequote all
gashead1105 said:
the-photographer said:
gashead1105 said:
I've just bought an edition 30 (off here).

It's lovely but I'd echo all of the above. Especially the air conditioning as I've just been stung for a bill of over a grand - there was a whistle coming from the engine bay, which as narrowed down to the bearing in the compressor failing. It's a very common fault which causes swarf in the air conditioning system. The only cure is a new compressor, new condenser and a full system flush and re-gas. I spoke to the local specialist and he wasn't really interested in sorting it out, so had to have it done by the dealer. A 2 year warranty is small consolation.

Car's still great even so.
The Sanden unit they fitted should last the lifetime of the car (assuming its always "gassed").

You can ask for goodwill from the factory, the dealer SHOULD contact the factory, who will say NO (too old) but still offer 10%.

The dealer should then add 10%, so I managed £200 off the original £1000 bill.
Thanks. I asked for goodwill but they said they had discounted it down as far as possible. The car doesn't have full VW SH (the person I bought it from used a specialist). My understanding is that the compressor on 2006-7 cars (which mine is) fails and its only once they replace it with a Sanden unit that the issue goes away - which hopefully it now will have done.
Yes, it should be fine "forever" now.

My car has full service history, so perhaps that was the factor in the 20% discount.

kazman

308 posts

198 months

Friday 16th May 2014
quotequote all
My Ed30 also has a receipt for a new compressor (at substantial cost) in the history. Hopefully it will now be "good for life"...