New S3 or Golf R v old S3 and Golf R...Tested and Oppinions
New S3 or Golf R v old S3 and Golf R...Tested and Oppinions
Author
Discussion

Msportman

Original Poster:

313 posts

187 months

Sunday 8th June 2014
quotequote all
Sold my 310 bhp Edition 30 runnning KW Clubsport suspension and anti lift kit and am on the hunt for an altenative everyday road and useful track tool.

Went to Audi yesterday and looked at a new S3 with options it was a whopping £37k!

Have looked at a base Golf R with a few options it comes in at 32k. Both are manual cars.

I have not tested either but I did try a new MK7 PP GTI which I found ok but not a big step on if any from my Edition 30 in terms of handling and certainly not ooomph!

Has anyone had experience of the MK6 Golf R or S3 against the newer models?

It would seem they both have a different Haldex system but how much better is it than the old system. I know there can be a fair amount done to the old S3 or R and getting 360bhp and running a Haldex controller brakes suspension will cost at least £10k on top of the car whereas the new 300bhp is just a map away from 350bhp.

Your thoughts?

b0rk

2,412 posts

177 months

Sunday 8th June 2014
quotequote all
Go elsewhere, I've test driven a new S3 and new Golf R including a 24 hour lone of a R these IMHO are not a step on if you've come from a properly modified mk5/mk6 platform car.

Basically to get back to where you where handling wise you'll need to budget for a BBK, coilovers and ARB's. Ladling on more power whilst low cost to an unmodified base will just highlight the compromises of the base package. Don't get me wrong the basic package is very very good and a considerable improvement from the mk5/6 base package just not as good as focused mk5/6.

rb5er

11,657 posts

203 months

Sunday 8th June 2014
quotequote all
Nice road cars but these cars are far too heavy for proper track work.

There are plenty of better cars to start with as a base.

aka_kerrly

12,506 posts

241 months

Sunday 8th June 2014
quotequote all
^ Are you going to suggest which of these notably lighter than a Golf cars the OP should consider?

OP - have you considered Renault Sport models? or Leon 280?

rb5er

11,657 posts

203 months

Sunday 8th June 2014
quotequote all
I don`t honestly think I need to list every car that would be better suited for track driving.

If the OP wants me to then i will make some suggestions if given some criterea.

Like you said the Renaultsport offerings to start with would be as civilised on the road but much better on the track.

b0rk

2,412 posts

177 months

Sunday 8th June 2014
quotequote all
The Megane is actually a bad example as the kerb weight is 1395 excluding driver and luggage (68+7) vs 1476 kerb for the golf inc these items. So the weight difference is 4kg. However Renault do not declare if the weight inc or ex fuel and 90% tank included in the VW figures would equate to 30kg for 40l of fuel.

In all honestly a 4kg difference in weight on two road cars will not be noticeable, the 55/45 vs 60/40 weight distribution may slightly confer a benefit but the awd system should make this back in wet/damp conditions.

I actually agree the Megane is a better base for trackwork due Renault having compromised less for road comfort and more info in needed to advise on alternative particularly the road/track split and likely road usage type.

Msportman

Original Poster:

313 posts

187 months

Sunday 8th June 2014
quotequote all
Thanks for your experience.
I have a pretty light weight track / circuit car which I also use during the summer months on the road. It's a classic old MK 2 16v Golf which is a very useful tool on track....light weight at just over1000kg over 200bhp running a Quaiffe shortened final drive big brakes sorted suspension ARB's. It heralds from GTI Engineering / BRM / Tim Stiles racing who built the car around a fast road and circuit vehicle.
I didn't want to go the whole hog with Edition due to the fact I have the 16v. I want to use a dual role car for road and track and something I can park anywhere.
I don't like French cars I 'm afraid, and I was considering either a RS4 although they are a bit heavy and are down on BHP due to coking issues or a nicely sorted E46 manual M3 or E92 version with a few buts. Both heavy on fuel but I both are well in my budget. I think the new R or S3 will be a great all rounder with a map and a few other bits but maybe slightly dull on track.


Edited by Msportman on Sunday 8th June 22:41


Edited by Msportman on Sunday 8th June 22:43


Edited by Msportman on Sunday 8th June 22:44

Actus Reus

4,312 posts

186 months

Monday 9th June 2014
quotequote all
S3 is a nice place to sit, but the R is the sharper drive in my limited experience - with the price advantage the R is the only choice for me given your criteria. No idea how it'd fair on track - though yes, I suspect it may be a tad dull given what you're used to.

aka_kerrly

12,506 posts

241 months

Monday 9th June 2014
quotequote all
b0rk said:
The Megane is actually a bad example as the kerb weight is 1395 excluding driver and luggage (68+7) vs 1476 kerb for the golf inc these items. So the weight difference is 4kg.
Exactly why I was keen to find out what cars RB5er knows about that an manage day to day duties in-line with a Golf but significantly out perform it on the track....


Msportman

Original Poster:

313 posts

187 months

Monday 9th June 2014
quotequote all
It's the holy grail of petrol heads who want an ultimate track car in budget but can also be used for family duties....I don't think it exists. I think that the Haldex may be flawed for track creating some under steer whereas the a FWD with diff maybe a better dry set up on track. 4WD tend to under steer but they are better in the wet.
I may revisit the PP GTI with a map should be interesting.

Actus Reus

4,312 posts

186 months

Monday 9th June 2014
quotequote all
I'd look at a Cupra in that case.

Msportman

Original Poster:

313 posts

187 months

Monday 9th June 2014
quotequote all
Perhaps I should have gone stage 2+ with my Edition 30 and put a proper mechanical diff some big brakes ARB's etc....would have been another 8-10k but cheaper than the new R or S3.....bit of a sleeper with potential of 360+ hp!

Another option is a good B8 S4 with sports diff and go MRC or APR stage 2 with some proper suspension and big brakes?

CraigV6

348 posts

162 months

Monday 9th June 2014
quotequote all
Got the new S3. Fairly uninspiring in all honesty.
6 months in and I'm trying to get to a deal to replace it.

Audi value them highly - still worth over £30k on a trade in and it's not got many options.

CraigV6

348 posts

162 months

Monday 9th June 2014
quotequote all
Got the new S3. Fairly uninspiring in all honesty.
6 months in and I'm trying to get to a deal to replace it.

Audi value them highly - still worth over £30k on a trade in and it's not got many options.

b0rk

2,412 posts

177 months

Monday 9th June 2014
quotequote all
Does it have to be new? a used 1M can be had for high mk7 R money not to compromised for road use and decent on track as a 2nd car.

rhysmoreton

223 posts

170 months

Monday 9th June 2014
quotequote all
CraigV6 said:
Got the new S3. Fairly uninspiring in all honesty.
6 months in and I'm trying to get to a deal to replace it.

Audi value them highly - still worth over £30k on a trade in and it's not got many options.
I've heard this a few times, I've owned 2 S3's in the past both lovely cars, but I hear the R has it's pants totally down! Audi are slacking I feel, BMW seem to be ruling the roost (albeit lots of fanboys unhappy with the forced induction engines).

the-photographer

5,209 posts

207 months

Tuesday 10th June 2014
quotequote all
Msportman said:
It's the holy grail of petrol heads who want an ultimate track car in budget but can also be used for family duties....I don't think it exists. I think that the Haldex may be flawed for track creating some under steer whereas the a FWD with diff maybe a better dry set up on track. 4WD tend to under steer but they are better in the wet.
I may revisit the PP GTI with a map should be interesting.
See http://www.autoexpress.co.uk/volkswagen/golf/86378...

JackReacher

2,291 posts

246 months

Tuesday 10th June 2014
quotequote all
Try the Cupra 280, the new Leon's are very good.

But I don't really understand why you'd want to spend £30k on a road/track car. It will always be a compromise. You could get a great road car for £20k and a decent track toy for £10k. If it has to be a compromise, then a Meganes Renaultsport is probably the best option.

SuperchargedVR6

3,138 posts

251 months

Tuesday 10th June 2014
quotequote all
Msportman said:
It's the holy grail of petrol heads who want an ultimate track car in budget but can also be used for family duties....I don't think it exists. I think that the Haldex may be flawed for track creating some under steer whereas the a FWD with diff maybe a better dry set up on track. 4WD tend to under steer but they are better in the wet.
I may revisit the PP GTI with a map should be interesting.
Sounds like it did exist....your MK5 that you sold!

Haldex decouples the rear diff when you brake, so unless you recouple the rear diff with excessive throttle openings on the apex, under steer shouldn't be an issue, but power under steer affects FWD with trick diffs as well. The diff in the PP MK7 is a lot better than Quaife's ancient design though, which loses *all* drive like an open diff when one wheel has zero grip.



ManOpener

12,467 posts

200 months

Tuesday 10th June 2014
quotequote all
SuperchargedVR6 said:
Msportman said:
It's the holy grail of petrol heads who want an ultimate track car in budget but can also be used for family duties....I don't think it exists. I think that the Haldex may be flawed for track creating some under steer whereas the a FWD with diff maybe a better dry set up on track. 4WD tend to under steer but they are better in the wet.
I may revisit the PP GTI with a map should be interesting.
Sounds like it did exist....your MK5 that you sold!

Haldex decouples the rear diff when you brake, so unless you recouple the rear diff with excessive throttle openings on the apex, under steer shouldn't be an issue, but power under steer affects FWD with trick diffs as well. The diff in the PP MK7 is a lot better than Quaife's ancient design though, which loses *all* drive like an open diff when one wheel has zero grip.
Could always fit a Wavetrac, they mitigate this and by all accounts are fantastic.