A3 2.0tdi Head Gasket gone
A3 2.0tdi Head Gasket gone
Author
Discussion

alanbremner

Original Poster:

3 posts

149 months

Friday 27th June 2014
quotequote all
Need advice!!!!
I have an 07 A3 tdi 2.0, had the oil cooler changed with oil change and filter as it was loosing water and had mayo oil, the garage said they'd try this 1st (£290 least expense), had car back 2 days and mayo oil and water loss again. Car has never over heated, air con works, no white smoke, loosing about 500ml water every 2/3 days. The garage did say they'd checked the head (gas/emit-ions test) but it seemed ok. I do trust the garage and have been quoted around £1200 if it's the head gasket.
Can anyone tell me if, A) This is the going rate. B) Could it be anything other than head gasket.

I'd appreciate any help!!!

Thanks.

Rich_W

12,548 posts

243 months

Friday 27th June 2014
quotequote all
If they've told you they checked the head (without removing it, not sure how they can) and it's fine. Why do they think it's the head gasket?

They sound like they are guessing.

I reckon it's the EGR cooler.

Also £1200 seems a bit steep outside a dealer (and even then it will be nearer 7-800 I would think (parts 150ish labour 6-7 hours)

Tame Technician

2,467 posts

235 months

Friday 27th June 2014
quotequote all
EGR cooler leak will cause you to loose coolant, but it wont then end up in the engine (in the oil) it just goes out the exhaust.

If I was a betting man I'd say its a porous head.

Ask the garage if they take the head off to change the head gasket, how much to have an engineer pressure test the head to see if its porous.

Somtimes if you pressure test the cooling system with the inlet manifold and the cam cover off you can actually see the coolant coming through. Have they tried this.

You will be pretty peed off if you pay for a new head gasket and the coolant still leaks through the head its self.

Edited by Tame Technician on Friday 27th June 23:36

alanbremner

Original Poster:

3 posts

149 months

Saturday 28th June 2014
quotequote all
Thanks for the responses.

I will ask for a pressure test on the head, any idea the rough going rate for this and also if it's a porous head how much I could expect to pay all in for parts and labour? Work being done at a small independent garage.

I've also been told to drive the car as little as poss before it goes back in on Wednesday, I need a car at the moment and have debated getting a hire car (not sure if limited miles could prove to end up costing me more in doing more damage)?

Any other advice greatly appreciated.

Rich_W

12,548 posts

243 months

Saturday 28th June 2014
quotequote all
Pressure testing will cost probably half hour. But as TT says removing the cam cover and inlet will add on time (probably another hour ish)

I agree with TT about the water going into the exhaust btw. I just wondered if you are sure it's going into the oil. Yes mayo. But did they flush the oil through a few times to clear all the remains from the first time out?

If you are losing 1/2 a litre as quick as you say. Presumably the oil level will be rising on the dipstick

alanbremner

Original Poster:

3 posts

149 months

Saturday 28th June 2014
quotequote all
It had a complete oil change and new filter done 5 days ago when the cooler was changed.
The oil level has risen but not to the rate of amount of water it's loosing.
Before the cooler was changed there was fresh patches of oil/water on my drive every morning. I can't really tell but it does appear that the patches aren't as bad now. Obviously if it's loosing this amount of water it has to be going somewhere.
Was also wondering if I can end up doing more damage by driving the car until it goes in again on Wednesday?