What to swap my Golf R estate for
What to swap my Golf R estate for
Author
Discussion

srdenny80

Original Poster:

1 posts

3 months

Sunday 16th August
quotequote all
Hi all

New to writing posts here but been on PH for years, hoping some of you can help my 1st world dilemma!

Presently have a Golf R mk7 estate with a rare very high spec (Oryx white, carbon nappa leather, Prets, pano roof, DCC, ACC, keyless entry/start, winter pack, Dynaudio, AA/CarPlay etc...). Has 64k. Nothing wrong with it, is comfy, modern, fast/chuckable when needed and can equally potter to shops, fit our dogs, bikes etc. Also own a R129 500SL for occasions, top down motoring etc.

Before I can't for whatever reason I want to try out some other stuff, meaning the Golf goes. Still needs to be practical, but quick, some tech etc. Budget is around 23k & be nice to have bit of that for maintenance if possible.

Have looked online but not in person:
B8.5 RS4
B9 S4 Avant
E63 AMG estate (not C63 as don't like the styling or image)

Interested to hear from owners of the above and what daily- ing them is like. I do mostly small trips so not overly fussed about mpg (Golf isnt great here anyway lol). Or if anyone else has gone from Golf R to something else...

Cheers
Scott

ManicMunky

715 posts

151 months

Sunday 16th August
quotequote all
I've got a decent spec 7.5 R Estate and cannot think of anything I'd replace it with for true daily duties - the other cars you've mentioned are a step up in running and maintenance costs, but all are good choices!

Belle427

12,046 posts

264 months

Monday 17th August
quotequote all
That`s the only thing that puts me off those cars is the running costs especially the AMG and RS models but if you can afford it then go for it.
Not sure if the S4 is as bad so may be a decent compromise and still sounds lovely.

Dr G

16,014 posts

273 months

Tuesday 18th August
quotequote all
I'll buy the Golf when it goes smile

B9 S4 Avant at 23 is going to be a more basic or higher mileage car - really proper ones are a bit ahead of this still. B8 RS4 that's also the cheaper end of the market and they're high-maintenance cars at the best of times. Finding either with the level of specification you've got and in good order (combined with low mileage) will be tricky/expensive.

B9 S4 Avant is a very good car mind you, if you think of it as an Audi version of what you already have you won't be far of the mark. Very quick in the real world, quality interior, nice sounding engine, relatively rare.

catso

16,575 posts

298 months

Tuesday 18th August
quotequote all
Dr G said:
I'll buy the Golf when it goes smile

B8 RS4 that's also the cheaper end of the market and they're high-maintenance cars at the best of times. Finding either with the level of specification you've got and in good order (combined with low mileage) will be tricky/expensive.
Although getting on a bit now don't discount the B8 S4, IMHO the RS4 is not worth the extra (cost & maintenance) over an S4 of the same vintage.

If performance is your thing, a simple 'chip' will bring it up to RS4 levels and with a little more work easily exceed it, whilst still being easier/cheaper to run.

I'm biased of course but my S4 is all the car I need and, despite it being 12 years old I have no intention of changing it anytime soon.

The Cardinal

1,389 posts

283 months

Tuesday 18th August
quotequote all
Hard to find a good one, but I'd put in a word for a 2015-16 ("PFL") RS3. Not the same boot size as the current car, maybe slightly less feelsome handling, but definitely a step up in all other regards.

Barleyboy

51 posts

138 months

Friday 6th November
quotequote all
srdenny80 said:
Hi all

New to writing posts here but been on PH for years, hoping some of you can help my 1st world dilemma!

Presently have a Golf R mk7 estate with a rare very high spec (Oryx white, carbon nappa leather, Prets, pano roof, DCC, ACC, keyless entry/start, winter pack, Dynaudio, AA/CarPlay etc...). Has 64k. Nothing wrong with it, is comfy, modern, fast/chuckable when needed and can equally potter to shops, fit our dogs, bikes etc. Also own a R129 500SL for occasions, top down motoring etc.

Before I can't for whatever reason I want to try out some other stuff, meaning the Golf goes. Still needs to be practical, but quick, some tech etc. Budget is around 23k & be nice to have bit of that for maintenance if possible.

Have looked online but not in person:
B8.5 RS4
B9 S4 Avant
E63 AMG estate (not C63 as don't like the styling or image)

Interested to hear from owners of the above and what daily- ing them is like. I do mostly small trips so not overly fussed about mpg (Golf isnt great here anyway lol). Or if anyone else has gone from Golf R to something else...

Cheers
Scott

Barleyboy

51 posts

138 months

Friday 6th November
quotequote all
Hi. Are you selling golf. Would be very interested in it. Yours mark

srdenny80 said:
Hi all

New to writing posts here but been on PH for years, hoping some of you can help my 1st world dilemma!

Presently have a Golf R mk7 estate with a rare very high spec (Oryx white, carbon nappa leather, Prets, pano roof, DCC, ACC, keyless entry/start, winter pack, Dynaudio, AA/CarPlay etc...). Has 64k. Nothing wrong with it, is comfy, modern, fast/chuckable when needed and can equally potter to shops, fit our dogs, bikes etc. Also own a R129 500SL for occasions, top down motoring etc.

Before I can't for whatever reason I want to try out some other stuff, meaning the Golf goes. Still needs to be practical, but quick, some tech etc. Budget is around 23k & be nice to have bit of that for maintenance if possible.

Have looked online but not in person:
B8.5 RS4
B9 S4 Avant
E63 AMG estate (not C63 as don't like the styling or image)

Interested to hear from owners of the above and what daily- ing them is like. I do mostly small trips so not overly fussed about mpg (Golf isnt great here anyway lol). Or if anyone else has gone from Golf R to something else...

Cheers
Scott

Trevor555

5,566 posts

115 months

Friday 6th November
quotequote all
If I had your Golf I'd prob keep it until my last breath.

Gazzab

21,714 posts

313 months

Friday 6th November
quotequote all
I’ve had my 2018 since new. It’s been faultless. A great car but like you can’t think what to replace it with. Hence I’ve kept it for over 8 years! Maybe a mk8 R estate ? The Audi alternatives are too showy for me and will be stolen from my driveway.

PushedDover

7,725 posts

84 months

Friday 6th November
quotequote all
A good friend has a R Mk7 Wagon. We call it a Unicorn (5% or 5%).

But I'd trade for this all day long :

https://www.pistonheads.com/gassing/topic.asp?h=0&...


For me almost the right car, wrong timing.