Golf MKV GTi & high miles
Author
Discussion

macp

Original Poster:

4,823 posts

214 months

Monday 7th December 2009
quotequote all
Dear all

The wife and I were having a discussion last night about replacing her aging Polo TDi Sport.Eventually we decided a MkV Golf GTi would suit but on our budget of about 10k we are looking at higher mileage cars of 80 to 100k.Im not scared of high miles in fact I would rather have a well serviced high miler that has stretched its legs.But the question is should you go buy something like a year old Hyundai i30 or say screw it and get the Golf ?

I think I have already made up my mind but I would be interested in PH`s views.

JKY

358 posts

223 months

Monday 7th December 2009
quotequote all
So long as it is a genuine unabused car, with proper service, then mileage should not be an issue.
What you do need to consider are a few inherant faults on these cars that can be expensive. Make sure ABS / traction is OK and bear in mind that aircon compressor failure is a common problem.
Coolant leaks do occur and are either radiator or fairly common is one of the small hoses/pipes on the engine, low down on the nearside below the cylinderhead.
17inch cars ride slightly better and do not have such a problem with cosmetic issues that plague the vulnerable 18inch wheels.
Also consider that you will be lucky to better 32mpg average - more is possible on a run but 32 is a more realistic average, which coming from a Tdi Polo may be more of an issue that you realise.


Edited by JKY on Monday 7th December 11:11

macp

Original Poster:

4,823 posts

214 months

Monday 7th December 2009
quotequote all
JKY said:
So long as it is a genuine unabused car, with proper service, then mileage should not be an issue.
What you do need to consider are a few inherant faults on these cars that can be expensive. Make sure ABS / traction is OK and bear in mind that aircon compressor failure is a common problem.
Coolant leaks do occur and are either radiator or fairly common is one of the small hoses/pipes on the engine, low down on the nearside below the cylinderhead.
17inch cars ride slightly better and do not have such a problem with cosmetic issues that plague the vulnerable 18inch wheels.
Also consider that you will be lucky to better 32mpg average - more is possible on a run but 32 is a more realistic average, which coming from a Tdi Polo may be more of an issue that you realise.


Edited by JKY on Monday 7th December 11:11
Many thanks good post
We were thinking about mpg but our combined annual mileage is around 10k so going for the petrol GTi is a no brainer really.

edcase

219 posts

244 months

Wednesday 23rd December 2009
quotequote all
Just bought a 68k mile minty mint mkv gti with DSG and full leather for £9,400 - helped by timing of xmas / they'd already bought their new car. It's rock solid, would hardly know it hasn't rolled off the forecourt.

Go for it! Bargain hard...cash is king!

edcase

219 posts

244 months

Wednesday 23rd December 2009
quotequote all
Was listed at 10.5k btw smile

VadMan

46 posts

219 months

Tuesday 29th December 2009
quotequote all
Wow, thats a pretty good deal you go there! I've been looking at GTi's with full leather and they're pretty hard to find (must have been an expensive option), I could only find ones nearer the £11K mark...

Would you recommend the DSG 'box? I don't know if I can wave goodbye to a manual yet frown

Dr G

15,994 posts

273 months

Tuesday 29th December 2009
quotequote all
Personally I found the manual a nicer drive - not that there's anything wrong with DSG when it's in good health.

One of Performance Car magazine's contributors has big miles on his MKV now and seems only to have very minor complaints.