Audi Q5
Author
Discussion

bananarob

Original Poster:

1,177 posts

212 months

Wednesday 6th January 2010
quotequote all
Taking delivery of the 3.0d in about 6 weeks, just wondered if anyone has one of these, doesnt seem to be any threads on here. Any feedback welcome...

Dr G

16,017 posts

273 months

Thursday 7th January 2010
quotequote all
I've not seen anyone on here post a 'bougth a Q5' thread, can't confess to having a great deal of experience with them myself either!

Only one I've driven was a 2.0T 211PS S-Tronic which drove and went surprisingly well. Looked very, very silly on the tiny standard wheels mind laugh

bananarob

Original Poster:

1,177 posts

212 months

Thursday 7th January 2010
quotequote all
Thats ok then, have ordered the 20" 7 arm alloys which look a lot better!

Dr G

16,017 posts

273 months

Thursday 7th January 2010
quotequote all
Agreed - they really lift the appearance of the car. Post us some pics when it arrives smile

Tame Technician

2,467 posts

235 months

Thursday 7th January 2010
quotequote all
Its basically the same car as then new A4/A5. just with more suspention travel.

Means you get the appearence and all seeing driving position of a soft roader, with the superior handlying of a modern saloon car.

Much better to drive than the equivelant BMW by a long shot. And I dont say that very often.

astroarcadia

1,725 posts

231 months

Thursday 7th January 2010
quotequote all
I have been driving a 2.0tdi quattro Q5 recently including 33 continuous hours spent in the car driving from Gloucestershire to France via the Eurotunnel. We got caught up in the Eurotunnel closure before Xmas and even spent the night sleeping in the car at the Ashford Terminal.

Like most new Audis the interior is well thought out and the MMI and Sat Nav is great when you get used to it. Inside is no bigger than a family car yet you feel like you are driving a large 4x4. The Bang and Olufsen upgrade is awesome and the Ipod link gives you full control and information via the screen. Xenon lights were also great and turn round the corners with the car. There is even a Headlamp Conversion setting in the menu that adjusts the alignment for European driving without the need for stickers. Seats are very comfortable with lots of adjustments that can be made. I felt no discomfort whatsoever during our epic 33 hour journey to the Alps. Wing mirrors are huge and noisy at speed.

The auto box is good and the engine quiet and refined compared to the last generation of VAG diesels. A full tank is £70. Economy can be very good if driven appropriately and the 2.0tdi had very good acceleration given the size of the car. I imagine the 3.0 would be rapid.

In the snow it is absolute rubbish. This is not an off road vehicle its just offers the additional ride hight and feeling of superiority that this brings. I don't know details of the four wheel drive set-up but it just does not work in the snow. The car feels heavy, struggles to get traction and the brakes are so sensitive that you lock up and skid as soon as you touch the pedal. I own a Subaru Forester and there is no comparison off road between the two. Brakes are great however in normal conditions. Driving position is good with places to rest your arms and pedals correctly positioned.

In all its a really good car and best in it's class imo. The X3 is awkward and the Freelander has a strong image but is not as refined as the Audi. The only thing is price yet residuals should be better. If it were my money I would buy a used RR or Disco3. You don't see many on the roads in the UK and I always thought it a bit of a "nothing' car but in the Alps we saw dozens of Q5's on German, French, Swiss and Austrian plates.

Post some pics up when you get it. Any other questions just ask.



Edited by astroarcadia on Thursday 7th January 22:58

bananarob

Original Poster:

1,177 posts

212 months

Friday 8th January 2010
quotequote all
Great right up astrocadia, good to hear the pros and cons. Interested in the poor 4x4 performance. I wouldnt expect it to work offroad, it is a road car after all but Im a little surprised it doesnt even work on the current road conditions. I currently have a 325i which is currently dreadful in these conditions (am also in glos) and i cant believe it doesnt improve on the traction there. Obviously it isnt going to work like a landy, RR or disco but i would expect it to be as good as an x5 or some of its other competition. Is it really that bad on these current roads?

Will happily post pics when it arrives (about another 8 weeks) and let you know how i get on with it.

Seez

656 posts

211 months

Friday 8th January 2010
quotequote all
Drove one a while back, on a test drive, it is a nice car, but the thing that put me off was the interior space, but then I do like cars that the kids can 'play' in the back, literally play and run around in, the Q5 isnt very big and I did get the impression it was a jacked up A4, but it seemed well screwed together and drove well enough, not sure I would pay with my own money for one, but does anyone?

bananarob

Original Poster:

1,177 posts

212 months

Friday 8th January 2010
quotequote all
I did want something bigger but my missus had some say here and she felt most comfortable in the Q5 as it doesnt feel like a big 4x4. I dont like the look of the RR Sport or the disco, ideally wanted an X5 but she didnt like it. I think I will get one next time. We dont have kids so interior space felt fine by me and I felt the boot was not far off the X5. I went for a fairly highly spec'd 3.0d, SE rather than S line as I heard the ride was a little hard on the sline esp with 20" wheels which i also think improves the look. I added the adaptive xenons and the dynamic suspension for added comfort, tech pack, sports seats etc.. I also heard that although 0-60 is 6.5, you can feel a slight lag when booting it. I had the flapping paddles to provide some level of manual overide, not sure if this will help (8 weeks will tell...)

astroarcadia

1,725 posts

231 months

Friday 8th January 2010
quotequote all
The Q5 I speak of belongs to my dad. He had an 09 3.2TT that he traded in against the Q5 at Parklands. He wanted more space and economy so I guess the Q5 was ideal. He never has passengers and from the drivers point of view it does feel large and a safe vehicle. Not sure it would be my choice if I had to carry kids around as the rear seats offer no more room than a Golf. An X5 offers more space inside but it rivals the Q7 not the Q5 so not a fair comparison in my opinion. My dads car also has upgraded wheels as he too said the S-line option was too harsh and the standard wheels too small. Considering it will be your wife's car and not to carry children around I would say the Q5 is a great compromise. We also have no kids and my wife likes the idea of a large safe vehicle. I think she would struggle with the size of an X5 and the RRS is starting to look dated even with the new facelift model. She loved the Q5 and said it was the perfect size for her. Unfortunately we can't afford anything near this.

I tried to point out a few things that I noticed after spending time with the car. Leg room and interior space can all be looked at in the showroom. The parking sensors are a must and offer a great graphic on the display. The Sat Nav is also brilliant with a graphic that comes up showing which lane you should be in at a junction, this is also shown on a very clear LCD display between the dials. With regard to its snow performance it really was poor. Without being specific my wife and I live between Birdlip and Stroud on high ground and on Thursday we had to take the Q5 back to my dads house on the other side of Cheltenham. It was a real struggle to get out of our village. The Q5 lost traction in places my Forester stayed planted. I think the auto box in the Q5 is great in normal conditions but in the snow I felt I needed more control over the car. This sense of removal gave me no confidence in the Q5 and I was relieved to get it home undamaged. Really though, this current weather is quite an exception and for the other 50 weeks of the year the Q5 will be great.



Edited by astroarcadia on Friday 8th January 14:20

bananarob

Original Poster:

1,177 posts

212 months

Friday 8th January 2010
quotequote all
What size wheels are on your dads? I must admit autos are never preferable in the snow...

Found this video on utube, its a petrol 3.2 with 19inch wheels using all season tyres. Cant tell if its manual or auto but bearing in mind its in the US, im 95% it will be auto. They dont seem to be having too much trouble in the snow.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PSiAiHSgrrA

astroarcadia

1,725 posts

231 months

Friday 8th January 2010
quotequote all
Have to say that Q5 does look competant in the snow. Wheels are 19" 10 spoke star. I understand there is an ESP switch that triggers and off road-mode. I know the location of this (next to the hill descent switch) but must admit I did not touch it. From brochure:


The Electronic Stability Programme
in the Audi Q5 features a special off-
road mode which can be controlled
by a switch. This reprograms the ESP
system, traction control and anti-lock
braking system to adapt them to the
driving conditions encountered in
off-road terrain, such as sand, gravel
or mud. This leads to good traction
in all conditions, a more exciting
drive and great handling even on
difficult surfaces.

I'll try it tomorrow with the ESP off and report back.

bananarob

Original Poster:

1,177 posts

212 months

Friday 8th January 2010
quotequote all
I spoke with Parklands today as they called to confirm build date of 1st week feb. Asked them about any feedback on Q5 in current weather. No one is driving one at the dealer but apparently one of the sales guy driving a Q7 is not very impressed how its handling. They expect the Q5 to be a lot better but so far you are the only person to give any feedback. Let me know how you get on with ESP off....

Cheers


mr pg

2,068 posts

236 months

Friday 8th January 2010
quotequote all
astroarcadia said:
Have to say that Q5 does look competant in the snow. Wheels are 19" 10 spoke star. I understand there is an ESP switch that triggers and off road-mode. I know the location of this (next to the hill descent switch) but must admit I did not touch it. From brochure:


The Electronic Stability Programme
in the Audi Q5 features a special off-
road mode which can be controlled
by a switch. This reprograms the ESP
system, traction control and anti-lock
braking system to adapt them to the
driving conditions encountered in
off-road terrain, such as sand, gravel
or mud. This leads to good traction
in all conditions, a more exciting
drive and great handling even on
difficult surfaces.

I'll try it tomorrow with the ESP off and report back.
I'd be interested in your comments with the ESP off, as I might consider a Q5 in the future to replace my '04 A6 Allroad. This has been brilliant in the snow, although I have fitted winter tyres, which I would recommend to anyone. Ours is a tiptronic too, but I have at times used it in manual.

bananarob

Original Poster:

1,177 posts

212 months

Saturday 9th January 2010
quotequote all
Just been reading a number of 'net' reviews on audi performance in the snow. They write up pretty well with a couple of them referencing the ESP off road mode and hill descent control. I also came across a number of owner reviews in a Q5 owners forum that say fitting the Pirelli Snow and Ice tyres made a HUGE difference. For 20" rims, thats an extra £1k fitted but if they do make that much difference, got to be worth it. I was also surprised to read they fit the S Line with sports tyres. I know the S-Line range is supposed to be the sportier version but im not sure a 4x4 should be fitted with sports profile tyres. I only hope my SE doesnt get the same!

bananarob

Original Poster:

1,177 posts

212 months

Monday 11th January 2010
quotequote all

astroarcadia

1,725 posts

231 months

Monday 11th January 2010
quotequote all
Spent some time driving the Q5 at the weekend and playing with the ESP. Most of the roads around here are clear now and the main problem is ice not snow. When you press the ESP button the dash reads "ESP Off Road Mode" with a warning message I cant remember.I stand by my previous comments that with or without ESP engaged the Q5 is hopeless under braking. There is a moment of uncertainty when you brake on ice and you can't tell if the car has engaged the ABS or is just braking normally, you can't hear the wheels and there is no feedback through the pedal but you feel the weight of the vehicle. On the flat the car copes well but on the hills around Stroud the ESP light was flashing non stop. It did climb these hills but was less confident coming back down. It all depends on what you compare it to, a Golf TDI would have had no chance of climbing the lanes yet my beat-up Forester felt much safer than the Q5 without all the technology. I took the Q5 on some really testing hills through the back lanes of Slad so maybe a little unfair to base my comments on this terrain. Around town the Q5 feels much safer than other cars and patches of black ice are no problem, you don't even notice you have driven over ice. The Q5 is marketed as a compact 4x4 and current conditions are about as tough as UK roads will get so in this respect it does a good job. If I had to drive it snow for more than one week a year I would seriously consider winter tyres but thats only because I live in such a hilly area. One thing I was reminded of was how comfortable the car is and how well made the cabin is.

I think the Q7 being driven a Parlklands guy is white in colour with the S-line wheels. I can imagine this would be a nightmare on the snow with such wide low profile tyres.

edit to add: mirrors are heated but washers are not. Frozen for 9 hours from Calais to destination.

Edited by astroarcadia on Monday 11th January 21:56

bananarob

Original Poster:

1,177 posts

212 months

Monday 11th January 2010
quotequote all
Thanks for the feedback, all told it sounds like for me its sufficient even without winter tyres. My 325 coupe has been nothing short of dreadful even on the smallest amount of snow/slush so it sounds like a vast improvement. I think I'll invest in either some winter tyres or snow chains at some point too.

In any case, im thoroughly looking forward to taking delivery in March...

astroarcadia

1,725 posts

231 months

Monday 11th January 2010
quotequote all
Agreed, don't listen to me, I'm very critical and used to have a Defender anyway. The Q5 is a very complete car and grows on you the more time you spend with it.

Don't forget the pics in March.

smile

Deva Link

26,934 posts

276 months

Monday 11th January 2010
quotequote all
astroarcadia said:
There is a moment of uncertainty when you brake on ice and you can't tell if the car has engaged the ABS or is just braking normally,
You should always be able to feel the ABS pulsing the pedal. Don't forget the way ABS works is that is references wheels against each other, looking for differences in slippage. If you lock all the wheels on ice then there's no difference for the ABS to detect! I've also seen it suggested that on some cars ABS doesn't work below certain speed, 15MPH was mentioned. Again, if you lock all the wheels then the car doesn't know it's moving.

I know these "soft-roaders" are often criticised but you do make your Dad's Q5 sound hopeless. It's obviously done some miles, are the tyres very worn?
Winter tyres would obviousy transform it, as they do on any vehicle.