Discussion
Pedant mode - It's a DSG box which is a manual box with (semi) automatic control. The Tips are an auto box.
First time I've ever had a non traditional manual and can't understand why people buy traditional manual. Car is a breeze to drive, in traffic you don't have the clutch to worry about, on the open road it changes gear quicker than you can think.
Had no problems in the snow last winter in mine. However winter tyres would be a better option as always.
First time I've ever had a non traditional manual and can't understand why people buy traditional manual. Car is a breeze to drive, in traffic you don't have the clutch to worry about, on the open road it changes gear quicker than you can think.
Had no problems in the snow last winter in mine. However winter tyres would be a better option as always.
worsy said:
Pedant mode - It's a DSG box which is a manual box with (semi) automatic control. The Tips are an auto box.
First time I've ever had a non traditional manual and can't understand why people buy traditional manual. Car is a breeze to drive, in traffic you don't have the clutch to worry about, on the open road it changes gear quicker than you can think.
Had no problems in the snow last winter in mine. However winter tyres would be a better option as always.
Thanks. On the Audi site they have a couple listed as tiptronic?First time I've ever had a non traditional manual and can't understand why people buy traditional manual. Car is a breeze to drive, in traffic you don't have the clutch to worry about, on the open road it changes gear quicker than you can think.
Had no problems in the snow last winter in mine. However winter tyres would be a better option as always.
I'm just looking for a lazy family car that is safe, practical and has a 'hooligan' mode so that I don't find myself wanting to hang myself with boredom.
The M5 Touring is outstanding but is going to be just a little too big. Same with the RS6.
Being lazy i suspect, the older S4 were tiptronic.
take a look here http://www.pistonheads.com/gassing/topic.asp?h=0&a...
take a look here http://www.pistonheads.com/gassing/topic.asp?h=0&a...
DonkeyApple said:
Dr G said:
V8 S4 4.2 auto 02-08 = torque covertor auto (tiptronic)
V6 3.0 s/charged S4 08> = DSG (S-Tronic)
Thanks.V6 3.0 s/charged S4 08> = DSG (S-Tronic)
Next question: Is one clearly better than t'other?
The 57 or older are obviously cheaper than the newer V6s.
The B8 S4 is the latest shape, 3.0 V6 Supercharged and optional 7 speed STronic (DSG) box ,there is no RS4 in this model and arguably unlikely until the next platform comes out.
The B8 is the next generation so arguably better, certainly the S-Tronic box is better than the Tip.
When you say "a little too big" . . . How so? Too big for your garage? I've recently been enlightened to RS6's and was surprised how compact looking the saloon really is (having studied one up close last week). Looked up Parkers and was surprised to discover that the Avant is actually shorter than the Saloon!
It's also quite a bit cheaper than equivalent 4 unless you want to replace DRC etc. If iwere you I'd rethink your sizeist views!

Having said all that the 4 is IMO visually & aesthetically a much more pleasing thing to behold and a shame it never had flappy paddle & associated widgets.
It's also quite a bit cheaper than equivalent 4 unless you want to replace DRC etc. If iwere you I'd rethink your sizeist views!


Having said all that the 4 is IMO visually & aesthetically a much more pleasing thing to behold and a shame it never had flappy paddle & associated widgets.
Edited by Digger on Sunday 20th June 08:38
Digger said:
When you say "a little too big" . . . How so? Too big for your garage? I've recently been enlightened to RS6's and was surprised how compact looking the saloon really is (having studied one up close last week). Looked up Parkers and was surprised to discover that the Avant is actually shorter than the Saloon!
It's also quite a bit cheaper than equivalent 4 unless you want to replace DRC etc. If iwere you I'd rethink your sizeist views!

Having said all that the 4 is IMO visually & aesthetically a much more pleasing thing to behold and a shame it never had flappy paddle & associated widgets.
'A little too big' because my current chore is to purchase a modest family hatchback. It's also quite a bit cheaper than equivalent 4 unless you want to replace DRC etc. If iwere you I'd rethink your sizeist views!


Having said all that the 4 is IMO visually & aesthetically a much more pleasing thing to behold and a shame it never had flappy paddle & associated widgets.
Edited by Digger on Sunday 20th June 08:38

To actually follow this instruction would be an afront to mankind. I know that I'm going to end up driving it much of the time and I don't fit in hatchbacks or enjoy them. As such, I find myself wondering whether an s4 could be passed off as a 'modest family hatchback'

There don't seem to be too many S4s on the market at present.
My mind has also begun to move to the 3L deisel A4 Avant which doesn't appear much more sluggish probably has good mid range which is all you need and cheaper to run with an easier resale?
Does anyone have experience of that model?
My mind has also begun to move to the 3L deisel A4 Avant which doesn't appear much more sluggish probably has good mid range which is all you need and cheaper to run with an easier resale?
Does anyone have experience of that model?
3.0 TDI is superb but not really a direct comparison, goes very well but nowehre near as much fun.
As with all Audis they're very spec sensitive. An SE manual with beige leather will sit around for ages whereas an S-Line in dolphin with black cow and nav will fly out. S4s sell as well as if not better than 3.0 TDIs, they've got a very strong following these days.
As with all Audis they're very spec sensitive. An SE manual with beige leather will sit around for ages whereas an S-Line in dolphin with black cow and nav will fly out. S4s sell as well as if not better than 3.0 TDIs, they've got a very strong following these days.
Sadly, was not able to swing the S4 passed the missus. It's to be her car and is apparently visually not dissimilar to a coffin, is far too big and makes her look like a traveling salesman!!!!!!. I suspect the real reason is that it wouldn't match any of her heels and it's cheaper to get a different car than go shoe shopping 
There is now a 130i on the driveway. Haven't driven it yet but hoping that it's not a total emasculation of male pride.
Thanks for all your help and sorry it came to nowt.

There is now a 130i on the driveway. Haven't driven it yet but hoping that it's not a total emasculation of male pride.
Thanks for all your help and sorry it came to nowt.
Gassing Station | Audi, Seat, Skoda & VW | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


