MK2 16V GOLF, smokey!! Need advice!
MK2 16V GOLF, smokey!! Need advice!
Author
Discussion

gticm

Original Poster:

4 posts

195 months

Sunday 1st August 2010
quotequote all

Have bought a mk2 16v golf, on the test drive there was no smoke, after a 40 min drive home and a last one mile blast, seemed to be smoking quite a bit,(only after it was tramped on a bit) , was blueish smoke! have been reading up, seems it is likely to be the valve stem seals? how much is it to get this fixed? or could it be something else?

also need to put a bushing or linkage in the gearbox as reverse, first and fith gears are tricky to get?

Anyone had similar problems?

appreciate any feedback guys!

bought the car for £1350, drives real tight, breaks, bodywork is excellent- have i bought a lot of problems?

Matt_N

9,045 posts

233 months

Monday 2nd August 2010
quotequote all
Gear linkage bushes are prone to breaking down over time and are a pretty easy fix, GSF sell the kit.

Valve stem seal problems normally show themselves at start up, as the oil has leaked down past the seals whilst the car has been sat and then gets burnt off when the car is started.

If its smoking after prolonged and heavy use it could be something else? Rings maybe?

Willber

671 posts

200 months

Monday 2nd August 2010
quotequote all
If the body is ok then I wouldn't worry about a few mechanical bits and bobs!

Doesn't sound like stem seals - as Matt N said they will show themselves at start up rather than under acceleration etc.

Gear linkage kit is easy to repair if your OK with a spanner. Good way to learn a few bits too. The cup and ball on the bottom of the gear stick might also be worn - this is a tricky fix though.

can you select reverse instead of first?

JB!

5,255 posts

211 months

Monday 2nd August 2010
quotequote all
is it pinking too?

my friends 9a/KR 16v hybrid throws out all sorts of crap when being revved hard.

sidgolf

163 posts

221 months

Monday 2nd August 2010
quotequote all
blocked crankcase-breather?

aka_kerrly

12,506 posts

241 months

Wednesday 4th August 2010
quotequote all
A head rebuild with new stems seals, valve guides, cam chain and a good clean is circa £200. Add a HG kit and bolts plus new water pump whilst you are there and £300 odd should see the engine do another 100k smoke free so long as the bottom end is in good nick.

sidgolf said:
blocked crankcase-breather?
If it isnt the Stem seals then id be inclined to go with this. If you remove the breather pipe from the front of the block there is a channel which is supposed to have a metal guaze in it. Often these get blocked or dislodged, remove it and clean the breather pipe out.

If there is loads of oil in the breather pipe your bottom end is breathing heavily - sign of worn piston rings then DONT connect the breather from the block to to air box, instead run it into a vented catch tank.

JB!

5,255 posts

211 months

Wednesday 4th August 2010
quotequote all
also, for £300, i'd be looking at swapping in an ABF or a 9a/KR hybrid

aka_kerrly

12,506 posts

241 months

Thursday 5th August 2010
quotequote all
JB! said:
also, for £300, i'd be looking at swapping in an ABF or a 9a/KR hybrid
That certainly is a option. Although there are some terribly worn 9A/ABF lumps out there that people still want 3-500 for and then you still want to spend the money on HG/Cam belt/tensioner/water pump/ oil pump if you actually want a reliable long term solution.

Sometimes you are better off finding a entire donor car at least then you can drive it about for a bit and make sure its a good engine. I was lucky and found a Passat GT 2.0 16v for £120 a few years back that donated its engine for my mk2. Followed by a £200 9A lump then a good ol KR for £50.

Remember that Audi/Seat can also supply engines to - Ibiza Cupra 16v, Toledo, Cordoba are often a lot cheaper to buy than mk3 Golf GTI 16v and Audi Coupes had the ACE/6A variations of the 2.0 16v which just require the sump and oil cooler to be swapped with your existing ones on your KR engine and these can be fitted.

Dave

Dr G

16,006 posts

273 months

Thursday 5th August 2010
quotequote all
^^^ this!

When my KR died it was the rings, excessive fuel causing bore wash (previous owner) wrecked it.

Got a bit jammy and picked up a 20,000 mile old engine with a nice head for £250.

aka_kerrly

12,506 posts

241 months

Thursday 5th August 2010
quotequote all
Dr G said:
^^^ this!

When my KR died it was the rings, excessive fuel causing bore wash (previous owner) wrecked it.

Got a bit jammy and picked up a 20,000 mile old engine with a nice head for £250.
it is the rings that are failing on one of my KR lumps at the moment as its blowing a tad too much oil out the breather pipe on the front of the block. Still runs VERY well though so i wont give up on it just yet.

i reckon il go ABF block, KR head running on KJET as a relatively easy/quick fix.

Dave

JB!

5,255 posts

211 months

Thursday 5th August 2010
quotequote all
9a's are pence to buy, as is a good KR head, it's what i'd do on a shoestring.

for £500 ish, i'd go ABF, although a rusty mk3 vr6 would be considered

£1k, vr6, chains done, new clutch, all running gear

£2k+ 20vt.