Camshaft Harness HELP
Author
Discussion

Lordbenny

Original Poster:

8,754 posts

250 months

Tuesday 10th August 2010
quotequote all
So, after getting no response on an earlier thread I have been told that the reason that my Diesel Passat (PD) 130 dropped down to 3 cylinders yesterday (after after stopping and re-starting was ok) could well be the camshaft wiring harness. Apparently they are prone to cracking up and this would cause the intermittent problem (It happened about 2 months ago but hasn't happened again until yesterday). Could this be the cause, I was told that it probably wasn't a faulty injector as it would have happened more regularly.

Im driving to Germany on Friday and I need it sorted, please help!

Tame Technician

2,467 posts

235 months

Tuesday 10th August 2010
quotequote all
With out testing the car in a failed state you can only guess. Harness is cheaper than an injector and injectors dont usually pay up intermitantly, they usualy fail and stay failed.

But the only way to correctly diagnose your concern is, with the vehicle in a failed state (you cant test for a fault, when its not faulting)

Read the fault memory or check the MVB data to identify which cylinder is misfiring. Then swap the injector from that cylinder to a good one.

If the misfire remains on the same cylinder its the injection harness.

If the misfire moves to the cylinder you moved the injector too, its the injector.

PD injectors are about £500 each, harness is arround £150. So its well worth a two hours labout it takes to do the test.

Lordbenny

Original Poster:

8,754 posts

250 months

Tuesday 10th August 2010
quotequote all
Tame Technician said:
With out testing the car in a failed state you can only guess. Harness is cheaper than an injector and injectors dont usually pay up intermitantly, they usualy fail and stay failed.

But the only way to correctly diagnose your concern is, with the vehicle in a failed state (you cant test for a fault, when its not faulting)

Read the fault memory or check the MVB data to identify which cylinder is misfiring. Then swap the injector from that cylinder to a good one.

If the misfire remains on the same cylinder its the injection harness.

If the misfire moves to the cylinder you moved the injector too, its the injector.

PD injectors are about £500 each, harness is arround £150. So its well worth a two hours labout it takes to do the test.
Thanks smile

Lordbenny

Original Poster:

8,754 posts

250 months

Wednesday 11th August 2010
quotequote all
Im going for a harness change, apparently the rocker cover has to be replaced so in all its costing £268 (the harness is only £50, rocker cover £150 + labour) I've got a good mechanic wink

FunkySon

139 posts

254 months

Wednesday 11th August 2010
quotequote all
Lordbenny said:
Im going for a harness change, apparently the rocker cover has to be replaced so in all its costing £268 (the harness is only £50, rocker cover £150 + labour) I've got a good mechanic wink
Did this on my PD150 4 or 5 months back.

Had the occasionaly misfire (which was logged) and the odd other random fault came up (can't remember now what they were but they seemed unrelated and I don't think they got logged).

Consensus from a search on uk-mkivs of the fault code for the misfire was that it was most likely the injector loom. £50 on parts and an hour or two fiddling around had it all sorted and the problem hasn't come back.

Why do you need the rocker cover changed? Mine was fine and there's no sign of it leaking.

Duncan

Lordbenny

Original Poster:

8,754 posts

250 months

Wednesday 11th August 2010
quotequote all
FunkySon said:
Why do you need the rocker cover changed? Mine was fine and there's no sign of it leaking.
I've been told that I don't have to get it changed but,....It will leak....apparently!

Tame Technician

2,467 posts

235 months

Wednesday 11th August 2010
quotequote all
You do not need a rocker cover, just the gasket.

I've done loads only one that ever leaked I over tightened and cracked it. Customer got it for free.

Lordbenny

Original Poster:

8,754 posts

250 months

Wednesday 11th August 2010
quotequote all
Tame Technician said:
You do not need a rocker cover, just the gasket.

I've done loads only one that ever leaked I over tightened and cracked it. Customer got it for free.
I'm being told by a very reputable source (mate who's a VW technician!)Gasket comes with the plastic rocker cover, because the covers twist and warp you cant re-use them!

Tame Technician

2,467 posts

235 months

Wednesday 11th August 2010
quotequote all
Spend if you want to.

Its up to you. I was just saying I have personally with my own hands removed and refitted quite alot of 1.9TDI cam covers in my 5 years as a technician in an Audi centre, replacing only the gasket.

Only one of mine has ever leaked.

Lordbenny

Original Poster:

8,754 posts

250 months

Wednesday 11th August 2010
quotequote all
Tame Technician said:
Spend if you want to.

Its up to you. I was just saying I have personally with my own hands removed and refitted quite alot of 1.9TDI cam covers in my 5 years as a technician in an Audi centre, replacing only the gasket.

Only one of mine has ever leaked.
Are you saying that you can buy a gasket without a cover?