Best Scirroco Engine
Author
Discussion

bullrunner

Original Poster:

153 posts

235 months

Monday 16th August 2010
quotequote all
Hi Guys just after some information relating to which is the best package in the Scirroco...My wife is looking to replace her 08 Cooper S with a 'WHITE' Scirroco...her words not mine...

Anyway just looking for some current owners to advise on whch package they think is best real world...Heard lots about TSI and Derv but which is overall best package...

She does a mix of driving town and motorway so want the overall best package...she is not an overly quick driver so its not about outright grunt just best all round girly package!!!....look forward to your thoughts.

FamilyDub

3,587 posts

196 months

Monday 16th August 2010
quotequote all
If speed isn't the biggest concern, forget the 2.0 petrol.

If economy isn't the biggest concern, forget the 2.0 TDI.

(Derv's are hard to justify unless you do 12k+ miles a year, because any fuel saving is negated by the higher purchase price).

That leaves the 1.4 TFSI, a nice mix of pace and economy. wink


trix-a-belle

1,074 posts

206 months

Monday 16th August 2010
quotequote all
Bullrunner

I can speak from the girly and current scirocco owner angle smile

As familydub says if speed & performance aren't a big consideration then that kind of knocks out the 2.0Tsi, if shes only pootling about on short journeys then that begins to rule out diesels, they can be used on short journeys but due to the dpf you do need to give them a good blow on a regular basis so that it doesn't get clogged up so the 1.4 is a good balance between.

I'm probably considered biased as I've got the 1.4Tsi (160) (manual) but hey. I'm in the position that insurance was a factor when I was looking to buy so the 1.4 kept that cost aspect down, I use it to mainly drive to & from work (15 minutes each way) which doen't really give me the opportunity to use the extra grunt that a 2.0Tsi would have given me and the 1.4 gives me a reasonable mpg (generally round the 35 mark) but is also lots of fun.

The questions you need to ask are; How long are her journeys & whats her annual mileage as the diesels give a very good mpg but as above need a good blow for the dpf regeneration purposes, & Do you want the extras that the GT trim adds (front fogs, highline computer, 18" alloys etc those are the ones that spring instantly to mind)

If you do go down the diesel route unfortunately I can't advise the difference personally as I haven't driven both but I have plenty of owners who will say go for the 170 for the extra grunt & plenty who will say the 140 is perfectly satisfactory

at least she wants white which will give you some extra money to spend on gadgets wink

Hope that helps, shout if you have any other questions

S

FamilyDub

3,587 posts

196 months

Monday 16th August 2010
quotequote all
trix-a-belle said:
Bullrunner
As familydub says...
^^^ In touch with the females, me! wink

1.4 TSI GT spec is seeming lik the pick of the range, so far.

trix-a-belle

1,074 posts

206 months

Monday 16th August 2010
quotequote all
FamilyDub said:
trix-a-belle said:
Bullrunner
As familydub says...
1.4 TSI GT spec is seeming lik the pick of the range, so far.
but sadly you can't get the 1.4 in the GT trim as standard, you have to add the various GT extras on as separate options to 'build' it yourself.
I didn't think some of the GT extras were really worth it another reason for sticking with the 1.4

S

FamilyDub

3,587 posts

196 months

Tuesday 17th August 2010
quotequote all
http://www.volkswagen.co.uk/#/new/scirocco/which-m...

From a (brief) scan of the above; Climate Control, MFSW, ACC and 18" alloys are upgrades you get with the GT pack. These are worth it, IMO.

ETTO - you pays your money, you makes your choice, etc... smile

Edited by FamilyDub on Tuesday 17th August 11:37

trix-a-belle

1,074 posts

206 months

Tuesday 17th August 2010
quotequote all
ACC is standard on the 1.4 160 but not the 1.4 122 (probably too weedier engine for the car anyway imo)

S

bullrunner

Original Poster:

153 posts

235 months

Tuesday 17th August 2010
quotequote all
Looks like we are going to go for a GT 170 DSG in Candy White and 19" Lugano's....hope she trys to clean this one......

trix-a-belle

1,074 posts

206 months

Tuesday 17th August 2010
quotequote all
bullrunner said:
Looks like we are going to go for a GT 170 DSG in Candy White and 19" Lugano's....hope she trys to clean this one......
no chance biggrin
good luck with it, shout if you have any scirocco specific questions

S

FamilyDub

3,587 posts

196 months

Wednesday 18th August 2010
quotequote all
Is the 170 not the diseasel...?

To be fair, DSG really suits a derv engine - keeps the engine powering on the waves of torque. smile

Nice spec - enjoy it.

Gusbang

199 posts

226 months

Wednesday 18th August 2010
quotequote all
bullrunner said:
Looks like we are going to go for a GT 170 DSG in Candy White and 19" Lugano's....hope she trys to clean this one......
Snap!! Bugger to keep clean!!

Steve996

1,240 posts

246 months

Saturday 21st August 2010
quotequote all
bullrunner said:
Looks like we are going to go for a GT 170 DSG in Candy White and 19" Lugano's....hope she trys to clean this one......
Exactly what I just bought for my commuting car - very chuffed with it, it's just about to be remapped to 210 bhp too.......

ge0rge

3,053 posts

236 months

Saturday 21st August 2010
quotequote all
Its obv why theyve put these puny engines in the car but its kinda sacrelidge imo..

va1o

16,118 posts

238 months

Saturday 21st August 2010
quotequote all
ge0rge said:
Its obv why theyve put these puny engines in the car but its kinda sacrelidge imo..
What is that supposed to mean exactly? I don't think a 170 brake diesel is a "puny" engine in a Golf sized car.