Audi S4 B5 or Skoda Oct VRS
Audi S4 B5 or Skoda Oct VRS
Author
Discussion

phil08

Original Poster:

5 posts

249 months

Monday 16th August 2010
quotequote all

Hi all,

I'm having a bit of a mare at the moment on deciding on my next car and wondered if anyone had any advice or views....

I would either like a 52 plus plate oct vrs in black and there's plenty about with medium mileage and high miles.

The vrs looks good but obviously needs a remap to make it a faster more enjoyable car obviously it's slightly more modern in terms of looks but the internals are now quite old having been used in various guises in VAG cars



The Audi s4 is obviously a very much quicker car but alighted older and has 130k plus miles has various options and recently replaced parts such as turbos

I have had numerous 'fast' cars and lots of quick cars but nothing with the capabilities of the s4 and it's been a car I've always wanted to own

It would only be a weekend car with occasional weekday use....

What are peoples views?

Insurance and fuel costs aren't an issue as I simply don't cover very much mileage




patmahe

5,924 posts

235 months

Monday 16th August 2010
quotequote all
If its only for occasional use, why not treat yourself to the car you've always wanted. If you buy the Octavia (good though I'm sure it is) you'll wonder what if.

istoo

2,365 posts

233 months

Tuesday 17th August 2010
quotequote all
I would second that, would you regret buying the VRS if you really wanted an S4?
Both are good cars in their own right, if it was a daily i would probably go for the VRS purely on running costs, weekend car, the S4. That said i have a C4 S4 as my daily!

FamilyDub

3,587 posts

196 months

Tuesday 17th August 2010
quotequote all
phil08 said:
Insurance and fuel costs aren't an issue as I simply don't cover very much mileage
^^^ If you don't have to compromise on running costs, then surely this makes this thread redundant?

S4, every time wink

kmm

1,781 posts

211 months

Tuesday 17th August 2010
quotequote all
I looked at lots of different cars when i was buying last year. Looked at volvo V70, Skoda vrs, Jag and various others. Was looking for an estate, but eventually decided on an S4.

100% glad i did. Awesome car and although it is 12 years old, it still looks reasonably modern.
Good performance and still just over 20mpg when playing. Bought mine with 84k, full service and was under £5k. Pictures of my car in the Stirling run threads, last one 3-4 pages back.

kmm

1,781 posts

211 months

Tuesday 17th August 2010
quotequote all
should have added - Stirling run thread under Scottish section.

phil08

Original Poster:

5 posts

249 months

Tuesday 17th August 2010
quotequote all
Hi guys

Thanks for the views I was more worried that it's a 1999 reg car as appose to maybe a 2004 reg skoda I do believe I would be bored of the vrs in reality bearing in mind they need a few mods to get them right.

I'm by no means a boy racer but an experienced driver who loves to drive properly the s4 have mixed reviews from people who say they have had no problems and still on mega miles without a turbo change but to minimise the risk I'm looking for one that's had these replaced...there's not Many about at the moment but going to look at a few Friday!

Witchfinder

6,388 posts

283 months

Wednesday 18th August 2010
quotequote all
The S4 will crucify a vRS in terms of pace, and I've owned a remapped vRS. It was a great car, and I miss it like mad, but if it were my own money, I'd probably buy the S4 now.

The S4 will undoubtedly be more expensive to run.

f1btn

56 posts

239 months

Friday 27th August 2010
quotequote all
Sold a mapped octy vrs for an s4,the scud was cheap to run and realiable but kinda souless the audi is expensive to run frustrating at times and has broken a fair bit,but i use it more and it is tuned to quite a high state (as was the scud) mine is coming upto 150k miles now so i was expecting things to go wrong but alot has.
If you can live with only 330bhp ish then it should be realiable go above this figure and things start to get pricey,try and find one with less than 100k if you can with service history and the 2nd cambelt swap done and you should be ok!