PD140 Timing belt / water pump
PD140 Timing belt / water pump
Author
Discussion

SB10

Original Poster:

558 posts

197 months

Wednesday 25th August 2010
quotequote all
Ok, its that time of my cars life where it needs the timing belt done.

called up to book it in at SEAT, only to be informed i would need to get the water pump replaced also. Seat apparently recommend this, and if they advise u the new belt could fail due to not having the water pump done same time.. then the warranty on their work is void?

Anyone if this is true or just a con to get me to pay out their rates to get the water pump done at same time?

Also, the belt is 4 years or 60/70/80km.. Anyone know what life expectancy the water pump has?

FunkySon

139 posts

254 months

Wednesday 25th August 2010
quotequote all
That's a new take on the problem. Normally they don't mention it and then when the water pump fails the dealer will end up charging for the timing belt again as it has to come off to change the water pump.

I'm assuming your PD140 is basically the same as my VW PD150. The water pumps have plastic impellors which fail far too often. It doesn't cost much extra to do the water pump at the same time as the timing belt so it makes sense to do so.

I would say that your dealer sounds much more clued up than my VW dealer who have never mentioned this. The last time I had the timing belt done I specifically asked for them to swap the water pump and they didn't query it at all. The bill mentioned something like "timing & water pump kit" so it's obviously something that they do regularly if they have a specific repair kit for it.

Duncan

Dr G

16,007 posts

273 months

Wednesday 25th August 2010
quotequote all
Doing the water pump at the same time is a no brainer, it's a cheap bit of preventative maintenance.

Interval is 5yrs/75 for th ebelt on these unless VAG have changed their minds again!

FamilyDub

3,587 posts

196 months

Wednesday 25th August 2010
quotequote all

^^^ Per his comments. smile

While it might seem unneccesary at the time, getting the WP done is money well spent.

It would be a £300+ bill again, should it fail at a later point.

Although, make sure they only charge for the part, since the labour required is contained in the belt work anyway.

SB10

Original Poster:

558 posts

197 months

Thursday 26th August 2010
quotequote all
FamilyDub said:
^^^ Per his comments. smile

While it might seem unneccesary at the time, getting the WP done is money well spent.

It would be a £300+ bill again, should it fail at a later point.

Although, make sure they only charge for the part, since the labour required is contained in the belt work anyway.
Oh, they are claiming labour for each part smile

Due to the this i'll probably just get it done at an independent/vag specialist. Dealers really do shoot themselves in foot at times.


Cheers for your help guys!

fatboy b

9,666 posts

247 months

Thursday 26th August 2010
quotequote all
Dr G said:
Doing the water pump at the same time is a no brainer, it's a cheap bit of preventative maintenance.

Interval is 5yrs/75 for th ebelt on these unless VAG have changed their minds again!
Service book is not clear for the Seat. Just had the Mrs' done at 4 years by an indy as they said it needed doing. £300 incl water pump.

SB10

Original Poster:

558 posts

197 months

Thursday 26th August 2010
quotequote all
fatboy b said:
Dr G said:
Doing the water pump at the same time is a no brainer, it's a cheap bit of preventative maintenance.

Interval is 5yrs/75 for th ebelt on these unless VAG have changed their minds again!
Service book is not clear for the Seat. Just had the Mrs' done at 4 years by an indy as they said it needed doing. £300 incl water pump.
Service book for Seat is utterly horrendous! Trying to work out what needs done and what intervals is guess work.

fatboy b

9,666 posts

247 months

Thursday 26th August 2010
quotequote all
SB10 said:
fatboy b said:
Dr G said:
Doing the water pump at the same time is a no brainer, it's a cheap bit of preventative maintenance.

Interval is 5yrs/75 for th ebelt on these unless VAG have changed their minds again!
Service book is not clear for the Seat. Just had the Mrs' done at 4 years by an indy as they said it needed doing. £300 incl water pump.
Service book for Seat is utterly horrendous! Trying to work out what needs done and what intervals is guess work.
Don't get me started on anything to do with Seat & servicing. Damn thing costs more to service than my 3.0 TDi Audi (at a main dealer) because of Seat's fuucking fixed term servicing of 10K, Vs my variable of roughly 19K.